Rita's Italian Ice & Frozen Custard

8469 AL-63, Alexander City
(256) 587-2001

Recent Reviews

JuOuttaHTown

I came to Rita's looking forward to a cold, tasty treat. The parking lot had plenty of parking upon my arrival, on a Saturday afternoon. When I entered Rita's I was greeted by a smiling, young lady who was eager to take my order and offered additions to my order. I ordered the vanilla flavored frozen custard "Concrete" with Reese's Peanut Butter Cup and Oreo pieces blended in. I can't imagine how anyone could NOT enjoy one of these frozen custard treats, they're delicious. As was mine.If I had any sort of complaint, if you'd even want to call it that, it would just be the price point for what I received. My "Concrete" came in a 4 inch tall, plastic cup, that wasn't really filled up. I tipped the nice server $1 on top of my product purchase, for a total cost of $9.26. So I paid $8.26 for a tiny cup that wasn't full. Knowing I could get an entire 1/2 gallon of ice cream from the grocery store at the same price.... I, personally, would probably elect to do that in the future as opposed to paying this high of a price for a tiny cup of frozen custard.The store was clean, signs and options posted well. There is no seating inside this tiny custard shop, so your order will need to be taken to-go. However, the store is adjoining Lake Martin Pizza Co, which has a good portion of covered, outdoor seating with a nice ambiance. I'd assume there would be no issue taking your frozen custard treats to Lake Martin Pizza's outdoor seating area.Delightful treat, but Expensive.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 5

Randy Knowles

Awesome service and a wide assortment of wonderful flavors to choose from!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Brandon Bowers

The best custard around.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Julie Dowdy

We were gifted with a box of 6 frozen cookie sandwiches; 3 Oreo & 3 chocolate chip, each with Vanilla Custard filling . Huge and SO delicious. We look forward to all your wonderful products! Welcome to the area!

Rob Green

We stopped in on our way home and Rita's never disappoints! Such a wonderful staff, clean establishment, and many great flavors to try!

Settles Settles

Everyone is very friendly and always smiling. Everything is so great and delicious. The custard ice cream of my favorite!!! Go and enjoy you want be disappointed at all.

Will Allee

The Gelati is the best!

Heidee Luiz

Yummy! We don't have one where we currently live but We always visit whenever We visit FLORIDA.

Cynthia Denney

Soft opening was great. So excited to have Rita's nearby.

Lannett Horsley

Today was my 1st trip here and definitely will be back such a great staff and if you're not sure what to order the ladies will give you samples. Please go by there and try them out today I had the Peach n Mango Italian Ice sugar-free and was delicious

Load More

Rita's Italian Ice & Frozen Custard

8469 AL-63, Alexander City, AL 35010
(256) 587-2001