The Old Mill
$$ • Seafood, Steakhouses, Vegetarian
Hours:
2557 Murphy Mill Rd, Dothan
(334) 794-8530
About The Old Mill
Customers' Favorites
The Old Mill Reviews
Share your opinion about The Old Mill
Been living in the area for almost 6 years, we finally tried The Old Mill Restaurant. I visited with my husband for a date night for the first time around 8:00pm on a Saturday night, after visiting a haunted house event in October. The restaurant was not too busy , and the hostess sat us right away.
At first it seemed lovely and homey with older carpet and comfortable booths. With a closer look I noticed artificial planters hanging from the ceiling covered in furry dust....read full review
A group of us ate at the Old Mill Restaurant on Monday night, 8/4/25. Most of us had the grouper. It was dry and overcooked. The onion rings had way too much batter on it. The crab claws were less than stellar. I should have learned my lesson from the first time we visited. However, I tried it a second time, and now I have learned from my last two mistakes, and there will not be a third visit to his establishment. The only thing I would say is the waitress was attentive and prompt....read full review
This was our first time visiting due to traveling, OUR SERVER KALEY WAS ABSOLUTELY AMAZING! She went above and beyond on everything and made sure we were 100% happy.
The food was great too, highly recommend
Ratings
Menu
Hours
| Monday | 4:30 - 8PM 11AM - 1:30PM |
| Tuesday | 4:30 - 8PM 11AM - 1:30PM |
| Wednesday | 11AM - 1:30PM 4:30 - 8PM |
| Thursday | 11AM - 1:30PM 4:30 - 8PM |
| Friday | 4:30 - 9PM 11AM - 1:30PM |
| Saturday | 4:30 - 9PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
The Old Mill offers a mixed dining experience. The yeast rolls served upon arrival are described as exceptional. The food was great, including the service. Some customers found the ribeye steak and seafood platter to be underwhelming, with the steak needing additional seasoning and the seafood lacking flavor. However, a coworker's seafood dish was enjoyed, and a son's shrimp alfredo was loved by a picky eater. The service is praised as attentive and amazing, with servers going above and beyond. The ambiance of the old-style restaurant was excellent and made up for some meals being under or overcooked. Overall, the reviews suggest The Old Mill provides an average dining experience, with standout yeast rolls and great food and service, but room for improvement in the preparation and seasoning of some main courses.