Edgar's Bakery

125 Stadium Wy, Madison
(205) 987-0790

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Susan M

Disappointed. My husband and I stopped in this morning for a quick coffee and to share a sweet. Coffee was not so quick, they had just run out, but because we already paid for it , we waited about 20 min to get a cup. My husband got a sweet roll but it wasn’t cooked all the way. There’s other places to go with better and quicker service.

David Sutton

Great food and service. Cleanliness less than it should be. The men's room had obviously not been cleaned in days, the urns at the coffee station needed a wipe down, the highchairs had crumbs on the trays, and the floor needed mopping. Disappointing. Speaks poorly of management.

jannus country

Ordered my food 1 hour before pickup and i still had to wait 15 minutes for my food and when i got it everything was soggy and cold

Jameskia Thompson

Absolutely delicious, moist and great lemon flavor

Tellus L

Sarah provided excellent customer service. She was very courteous! She was almost as nice as the strawberry cake.

The crazy panhandlefoodie

So it’s been some time since I’ve been back to any Edgar’s Bakery my previous experiences just not that great. This location was different because of the service. Rachel helped me and she was very pleasant. I ordered the handheld croissant ham egg and cheese and it was really good. I do wish the egg was seasoned with salt and not scrambled overhard but that could be my preference. Other than that great breakfast sandwich. But don’t take my word for it come try for yourself. Later foodies

A. Pleasant

Service was terrible. I was completely ignored in a practically empty store. No hello or can I help you or anything. I tried to calm my anxiety by continuously looking at the desserts which half the items were gone or possible never in stock that day, the cake slices were big but looked crumbled and smashed. I was still interested cause I heard good things when I came in town but I couldn’t even place an order and the food didn’t look that appealing. I can’t recommend this place.

danny newton

How TF does a bakery run out of bread?!! I blame management, but I used to love eating here. There are too many options nearby.

Edit: went back a week later and had another bad experience. Gave it another shot, but it just isn't working out. I ordered the same thing I've ordered for over a year. They told me I cannot order that any more. (Breakfast potatoes with a lunch sandwich)

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 1

Service: 1

M Doh

Good food and great service in a clean and modern deli/ bakery..
strawberry cake is awesome. I had the Edgar’s chicken- peppers melt with side of fruit and was very pleased- got some kick ! I sampled my wife’s choice of avacado chicken wrap - was bland for my taste buds but she liked it .

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chicken Melt

Amber R

If you’re looking for a bakery that bakes their own stuff fresh daily this is not the place. The goods are transported in and many times they eithertaste frostbite or stale. I called to complain and hopefully get my money back and I was advised that I needed to bring in the half eaten product which was stale. My coworker got strawberry cheesecake on a stick and it was moldy. Won’t be going back

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 1

Service: 4

Teresa Slovak

I love Edgars, but I have ordered to go twice from here. Both time I ordered the same breakfast. I ordered the all American breakfast with scrambled eggs with cheddar. Both times the eggs looked like omelet chopped up, no cheese , no flavor. This never happens if I eat in. They are definitely a 5 out of 5 to dine in , but a 3 if I order to go.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

James

Had breakfast there this morning. Food came like instantly, while I appreciate quick service, it was clear the food was previously prepared. Eggs were obviously not fresh. Potatoes were half raw and very spicy/hot. And no salt, pepper, or condiments available in the dining area. One plus is refills on drinks. Staff was nice, but not going back.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 3

Natalie Brasher

Awesome location. Sara at the counter is super sweet. I enjoyed the food. Mac and cheese was a bit bland. But I would definitely come back. I love all of the natural light and the overall atmosphere. Food was fresh. It was $18 for my meal and I’d usually be complaining about the price right now but… I think I’d pay that again. Chicken was a tad chewy and dry but only on my very last 2 bites. :) The rest of the sandwich tastes fresh and juicy.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Annalicia Rosado

Came here this morning for a coffee and a pastry. I got a chocolate croissant which was so overly sweet that I only ate one bite. The drip coffee that I got tasted alright, except their drip coffee dispensers look like they haven't been cleaned properly in a long time.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 3

Keith Jackson

visited June 2024

Like all Edgar's locations, this one serves excellent pastries, and deli sandwich items. The staff is always helpful and friendly, and this location has plenty of seating (including outdoor seating). Their bakery items are probably the best in town, and are worth a try.

This location has plenty of storefront free parking, but that may change during baseball games. Would go again.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...