8 Best Pizza Restaurants near Sylacauga

“My sister and I ate there today, we are from NJ so we know a good pizza! Pizza and Pint has THE BEST PIZZA we have had since moving to Alabama over 30 years ago! Prices were very reasonable and the service was excellent. Highly recommend and will definitely be eating here again. If I could give more than 5 stars I would!“

“We ate at the Founders Pub (Old Tom's Pub) at Pursell Farms two times, 3/20 and 3/22/25. One dinner and one lunch. We believe they make from scratch as both were excellent but I'll tell you about lunch as we found it exceptional. We ordered the lunch specials of chicken soup with grilled cheese and pork belly with bacon jam (I think that is a close description). Hubby is a home chef and very knowledgeable (and picky) about taste, presentation and execution. He couldn't find any fault for the pork belly sandwich and enjoyed it tremendously. I am not a soup eater usually but wanted to try something different and found the chickens soup to be delicious. We think it had at least a half of a chicken in the soup. Hearty and savory. We also were impressed with the generous portion sizes at the pub and at Arrington's. That was particularly refreshing and we felt supported your pricing. In Indiana, fine dining establishments tend to reduce portion sizes greatly. We ate at Arrington's March 21, 2025 and really enjoyed the entire dinner. Anyone traveling to Sylacauga AL must make reservations for both. You will not be disappointed.“

“There always nice people, the pizza vey good and warm.“

“usually not bad ,but tonight it looked like they was out of sauce and toppings and only about half of each pizza had sauce and toppings ! price of everything going up and quality of products going down ! burgers at other places getting smaller prices going up .I guess they think we don't notice .rich get richer and poor get poorer.god is gonna get tired of this greed ! and dirty pool the world is playing and it's gonna be O.V. for us !“

“Why is this place so trashy and dirty I love the pizza but this place is in need of deep cleaning outside looks like a trash dump“

“My husband and I eaten at Old Town Grille regularly for years. They have a great menu with many choices. Everything we have eaten has always been so good. Our favorite is the lemon pepper chicken with their delicious white sauce. So tender and moist. We highly recommend Old Town Grille. The service is great as well.“

“After a mistake was made with our order, the manager (I assume, I didn’t catch his name!) was quick, generous and professional while correcting it! We are all humans who make mistakes, the way we handle issues is what makes us. 10/10. We will definitely be back!“