TuscNY Pizza

229 McFarland Cir N, Tuscaloosa
(205) 248-2149

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Michelle Silye

Must try the toasted ravioli!! Also the pizza is the best I’ve ever eaten anywhere in the United States.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Britney Johnson

i've had this pizza twice in less than a week because i loved it so much the first time and i usually hate pizza. i LOVE this place. the staff is cool, the paintings on the walls are cool, they even have black toilets. yeah there's so dark parts on the crusts but that's the way it's cooked, and it's cooked divinely. this is REAL pizza. don't come here if you're wanting some cici/domino bs.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Karl Burroughs II

Wonderful pizza! Definitely have to try the garlic confit

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Lorraine Price

I wanted to try this new place and stopped by for lunch. We were the only customers there. I didn't know what to expect since I had no knowledge of the place. If you want to know the menu and prices, go to DoorDash. We walked in and saw the deal on the chalkboard that said, 2 slices and two drinks for $13. So we ordered our preference and also chose two Caesar salads. We should have split it. The salad was large. It was fresh romaine lettuce, hard and crunchy croutons, pecorino romano cheese, and caesar dressing. I don't know, but it seemed very plain. Maybe the dressing was missing something. I had a slice of cheese pizza. There wasn't much sauce or cheese on it. The crust was as thin as a piece of cardboard. It tasted like toast. The edge of the crust was plain and dry. No sauce, oil, cheese, nothing. After I had finished eating, I saw them put up another chalkboard. This one offered hand-tossed and thick-crust pizza slices. Had I known, I would have chosen differently. Our server answered my questions about the pizza and their sizes. She showed me the 20" pizza box which feeds a crowd, mostly Friday and Saturday nights. The long rectangular box was for the thick crust pizza which has square slices. The smaller box was for their 12" pizzas. The slices are priced according to the deal of the day, how many toppings, and the choice of crust. I hope you will visit them for lunch based on this knowledge you have been given. The menu is also included in the pics below.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 3

Service: 5

Noah Peterson

Great food, great customer service, good atmosphere. Probably the best pizza I have had.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Sicilian Pizza, Chicken Bacon Ranch 20

Mahogany Taz

Stumbled upon this restaurant and when I tell you it was a great stumble. The artichoke dip was amazing. The food, atmosphere and customer service are all top tier

AnnMarie Tracz

From NJ/NY area...this is a pretty good NY style pie. We order from here periodically and are pleased with the pizzas. My 4 instead of 5 stars is because of our 1st experience ordering salads to go with our pizzas. I think it's pretty disappointing to get a TINY container of lettuce with tubs of dressing and cheese taking up half of the TINY container of what is an $8.00 Caesar salad. There could not have been more than 6-10 pieces of lettuce in the TINY $8.00 container!

Food: 4

Alexis Jefferies

Food was terrible and service was just as bad. Server never once checked to see if we liked our overly cooked pizza. The spinach dip was weird and a cold dip, not a warm dip. We were the only people in the place and it still took forever to get our pizza. Pizza cooks didn’t wear gloves when stretching dough so not sure if they are grabbing toppings barehanded. Serves behind the counter just on the computer and cussing. All and all a super bad experience and we will not be returning.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 1

Service: 1

Joshua Singh

The best pizza I've ever had!! New York style pizza ??????

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

M “blessedandhf” R

Normally this establishment's pizzas are good. I ordered a large Margherita Pizza, which was not that good. It had too much tomato sauce and not enough of the other ingredients. The sauce was watery.

Parker Gardner

When we went it was a busier time of the day, and they seemed a little understaffed, but the service was still amazing, and the food was excellent.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Nonya Bizness

$42 for a half supreme, half plain....food was o.k. waitress was great, price was absolutely ridiculous!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Michella Mcwilliams

Food was hot , service was great! I will be back!

Food: 5

bob weatherly

We got a large Farmers Medley to go last night, excellent! We will finish the pie for lunch. Bob

Food: 5

Service: 5

Allison Ryans

This was mine and my son's first time here and definitely will be back. It was the best pizza I had in this area. It is a bit pricey but it's worth it. Service was great also.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Side of Marinara

Loading...