Reasonably priced, delicious treats! The restaurant is brightly decorated, tables and restrooms really clean. The gelatis were delicious. The Oreo frappe with Oreo mocha Italian ice and soft serve ice cream was good. The Oreo mocha had a good coffee flavor. We also did a make your own and one just the Italian ice. The prices were really good for the serving size. The sizes in the photo are small and medium. The employees were friendly and very helpful answering all of our questions.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jonathan T
I got the Oreo Mud Slide which was delicious. Staff was very patient and helpful as my family of five picked out what we all wanted on our first visit. Weather was perfect to enjoy outdoor seating. Will certainly return!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Amy B.
LegenDAIRY! My wife & I dropped by Jeremiah's Italian Ice the other night for a sweet treat. They were having a Leap Back party in celebration of being in business for 28 years. Jeremiah's specializes in Italian ices & gelatis. Jeremiah's offers many fun flavor combos of gelatis. Gelatis are a layering of any flavor of Italian ice & creamy soft ice cream. Their menu features "pre built flavorite combos" such as strawberry shortcake, mud pie, peanut butter cup etc or you can build your own. I opted to build my own featuring cake batter Italian ice layered with vanilla ice cream & cookie butter crumbles. I really enjoyed this gelati! The Italian ice is actually pretty similar in taste & texture as the ice cream. The cookie butter crumbles were the icing on the cake...or the topping on the ice cream *chef's kiss*. For those with any food allergies, worry not, Jeremiah's has you covered! My lactose intolerant love inquired about dairy-free flavors which Jeremiah's does offer. In fact, they have an allergy list menu available upon request. She went with the dairy-free peanut butter Italian ice. Jeremiah's atmosphere is fun. You can tell this is a favorite spot for all ages. This particular location is run by a very nice couple whose staff is super friendly. Warm weather is right around the corner & so is Jeremiah's Vestavia! Be sure to sign up for their rewards program for awesome perks!
Madison E.
Who knew we needed an Italian ice and ice cream fusion?! Green apple and salted caramel Italian ice mixed with vanilla ice cream and chocolate chips. Divine. Perfect dichotomy of sour and sweet. I've never had anything like it. Next on my list to try is the frosted animal cracker. Service was extremely friendly! Download their app and you'll get a free small treat on your first visit!
Virginia H.
Not our first time here and definitely will not be our last! Celebrated Leap Day here today and Jeremiah's does not disappoint. The employees are nice and helpful! They are very patient as well when you cannot decide what flavor you want due to the many choices available and happy to offer samples. I am a huge fan of their cookie crumbles layer. It's good with anything! I will say my favorite is still their seasonal flavor of pumpkin, which is not currently available. With the cookie crumbles layer, it tastes just like pumpkin pie, but better! I can't wait for a pumpkin to come back!! Also, they offer pup cups. It gets my daughter every time. She loves being able to give the pup we are watching over a treat!! Random side note: The manager (owner?) has a very pretty and very nice wife that was helping at the store today! He definitely scored, haha....and I can say that as an objective third female party lol.
Jennifer Bice
I wanted to try this place out around Halloween last year. The employees there refused to serve me and told me to leave because I was in violation of their dress code. I had on a pair of blue jeans and a pullover with a Marvel Comics character on it. The employees had an issue with my pullover, calling it "Satanic." I thought this was odd because Jeremiah's was selling Halloween themed treats.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Rachel S.
This was my second visit to Jeremiah's Italian Ice and it was just as lovely an experience as my first. I was welcomed warmly and the staff was so friendly. The shop is so cute, inside and out, and was very clean. Here you can get Italian Ice in a ton of yummy flavors , soft serve ice cream in vanilla, chocolate, or swirl, or a combination of the two with mix's in that they call gelati. They have a favorites board that have a list of gelati combinations or you can make your own. I My dad and I stopped by on our way from his doctor's appointment. He got the strawberry shortcake gelati, a combination of vanilla soft serve, cake batter and strawberry Italian ice, and cookie butter crumbles. He said it was delicious. I got the peanut butter chocolate chip cookie gelati, a combination of vanilla soft serve, P-Nutty and Cookie Butter Italian ice, cookie butter crumbles, and Hershey's mini chocolate chips. It was decadent and delicious. It really did taste like a peanut butter chocolate chip cookie. I hope to work my way through their menu and try everything. If you want a delicious treat, come try a gelati.
Robert Hollingsworth
Great place to stop by if you are craving something sweet. The staff was very friendly and happy to give you a free sample while debating what to order. Price is very reasonable as well.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jalexus H.
Everyone at Jeremiah's is so nice every time I visit! They offer as many free samples as you need so that you can make the right decision. The staff is so friendly and personable. There are so many options and they are willing to let you try anything! I will definitely be back!
Todd B.
If you have ever thought that the combination of Italian ice and traditional ice cream could be a good idea- Jeremiah's takes that idea and runs with it! With an almost endless amount of combinations, any that you think of can be a reality. You could have either components by themselves, for the less adventurous. Staff is friendly and plenty of seating for any looking to pop in, I highly recommend checking it out!
Came back after our Yelp event because hubby wanted it again. Who was I to say no? Lol I got a small grasshopper. So good. Mint, vanilla, and chocolate with cookie crumbles. So delicious. This will probably be my go to in the future. I'm excited for their holiday flavors to come out. Staff are very nice and check on you too make sure you are happy. We'll be back.
Eleonor M.
Thank you Yelp Elite for introducing me to Jeremiah's Italian Ice. I've been wanting to try this since I lived in metro Orlando FL, never got there, and it's been awhile--yikes like 18 years. How embarrassing!!! It does show you that Jeremiah's is not a fad. I mean whoever heard of an 18 year fad. Anyway I finally got to try one and I'm hooked. I loved the Italian Ices from the street vendors when living on Long Island and going into NYC. Don't even ask me when that was--like eons ago. You get a colorful welcoming as you approach the store. When you walk in it's very open and clean but has a friendly feel. Staff acknowledges you as you enter. Although I may have gotten a little extra VIP treatment when I told them I was a Yelp Elite, I noticed that every customer was greeted with VIP panache. There are tables to have your treat there or you can ask for it to-go. I took it to-go and much appreciated that the two items were placed in a tray, with spoons and napkins and placed in a bag. The staffer helping me explained the menu thoroughly and then I proceeded to decide. I chose the Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip and wanted something fruity. Staffer recommended the Orange Mango so that's what I got. The Orange Mango is sitting in the freezer. I've eaten half the Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip and wonder why it's taken me all these years and three moves to finally try it. If you like cool treats with flavor that are not too sweet this is for you. Just like the street vendor Italian Ices I had in NYC just with many flavor choices. I'll be passing word to my family and anyone looking for a cool treat. Of course they'll see my mug again in the future.
Bryanna Fox
I went yesterday for the very first time. The staff were very professional, I told them that I have a food allergy, and the woman at the counter gave me a list with all the food allergies. What I wanted was not on the list which were a gelati the guy assist me and we went over the ingredients together very sweet of him honestly. I will most DEFINITELY be coming back very soon. :-) I had the Strawberry Shortcake LOVE it!
Travis Vanlandingham
Soft serve was good but the kid behind the counter could use a little customer service coaching.
Joiya A.
Where ever I am in the country when I see a Jeremiah's Italian Ice I am stopping! I absolutely love their soft serve and Italian ice. It was actually a Yelp event that introduced me to this company and I have been a fan ever since! My go to is the cotton candy Italian ice with vanilla soft serve. It never disappointments my tastebuds. Staff at this location like all the other's I have visited are super friendly and patient if you are undecided. You can taste as many samples as you like until you decide on your favorite.
Reasonably priced, delicious treats! The restaurant is brightly decorated, tables and restrooms really clean. The gelatis were delicious. The Oreo frappe with Oreo mocha Italian ice and soft serve ice cream was good. The Oreo mocha had a good coffee flavor. We also did a make your own and one just the Italian ice. The prices were really good for the serving size. The sizes in the photo are small and medium. The employees were friendly and very helpful answering all of our questions.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I got the Oreo Mud Slide which was delicious. Staff was very patient and helpful as my family of five picked out what we all wanted on our first visit. Weather was perfect to enjoy outdoor seating. Will certainly return!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
LegenDAIRY! My wife & I dropped by Jeremiah's Italian Ice the other night for a sweet treat. They were having a Leap Back party in celebration of being in business for 28 years. Jeremiah's specializes in Italian ices & gelatis. Jeremiah's offers many fun flavor combos of gelatis. Gelatis are a layering of any flavor of Italian ice & creamy soft ice cream. Their menu features "pre built flavorite combos" such as strawberry shortcake, mud pie, peanut butter cup etc or you can build your own. I opted to build my own featuring cake batter Italian ice layered with vanilla ice cream & cookie butter crumbles. I really enjoyed this gelati! The Italian ice is actually pretty similar in taste & texture as the ice cream. The cookie butter crumbles were the icing on the cake...or the topping on the ice cream *chef's kiss*. For those with any food allergies, worry not, Jeremiah's has you covered! My lactose intolerant love inquired about dairy-free flavors which Jeremiah's does offer. In fact, they have an allergy list menu available upon request. She went with the dairy-free peanut butter Italian ice. Jeremiah's atmosphere is fun. You can tell this is a favorite spot for all ages. This particular location is run by a very nice couple whose staff is super friendly. Warm weather is right around the corner & so is Jeremiah's Vestavia! Be sure to sign up for their rewards program for awesome perks!
Who knew we needed an Italian ice and ice cream fusion?! Green apple and salted caramel Italian ice mixed with vanilla ice cream and chocolate chips. Divine. Perfect dichotomy of sour and sweet. I've never had anything like it. Next on my list to try is the frosted animal cracker. Service was extremely friendly! Download their app and you'll get a free small treat on your first visit!
Not our first time here and definitely will not be our last! Celebrated Leap Day here today and Jeremiah's does not disappoint. The employees are nice and helpful! They are very patient as well when you cannot decide what flavor you want due to the many choices available and happy to offer samples. I am a huge fan of their cookie crumbles layer. It's good with anything! I will say my favorite is still their seasonal flavor of pumpkin, which is not currently available. With the cookie crumbles layer, it tastes just like pumpkin pie, but better! I can't wait for a pumpkin to come back!! Also, they offer pup cups. It gets my daughter every time. She loves being able to give the pup we are watching over a treat!! Random side note: The manager (owner?) has a very pretty and very nice wife that was helping at the store today! He definitely scored, haha....and I can say that as an objective third female party lol.
I wanted to try this place out around Halloween last year. The employees there refused to serve me and told me to leave because I was in violation of their dress code. I had on a pair of blue jeans and a pullover with a Marvel Comics character on it. The employees had an issue with my pullover, calling it "Satanic." I thought this was odd because Jeremiah's was selling Halloween themed treats.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
This was my second visit to Jeremiah's Italian Ice and it was just as lovely an experience as my first. I was welcomed warmly and the staff was so friendly. The shop is so cute, inside and out, and was very clean. Here you can get Italian Ice in a ton of yummy flavors , soft serve ice cream in vanilla, chocolate, or swirl, or a combination of the two with mix's in that they call gelati. They have a favorites board that have a list of gelati combinations or you can make your own. I My dad and I stopped by on our way from his doctor's appointment. He got the strawberry shortcake gelati, a combination of vanilla soft serve, cake batter and strawberry Italian ice, and cookie butter crumbles. He said it was delicious. I got the peanut butter chocolate chip cookie gelati, a combination of vanilla soft serve, P-Nutty and Cookie Butter Italian ice, cookie butter crumbles, and Hershey's mini chocolate chips. It was decadent and delicious. It really did taste like a peanut butter chocolate chip cookie. I hope to work my way through their menu and try everything. If you want a delicious treat, come try a gelati.
Great place to stop by if you are craving something sweet. The staff was very friendly and happy to give you a free sample while debating what to order. Price is very reasonable as well.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Everyone at Jeremiah's is so nice every time I visit! They offer as many free samples as you need so that you can make the right decision. The staff is so friendly and personable. There are so many options and they are willing to let you try anything! I will definitely be back!
If you have ever thought that the combination of Italian ice and traditional ice cream could be a good idea- Jeremiah's takes that idea and runs with it! With an almost endless amount of combinations, any that you think of can be a reality. You could have either components by themselves, for the less adventurous. Staff is friendly and plenty of seating for any looking to pop in, I highly recommend checking it out!
Restaurantji Recommends
Came back after our Yelp event because hubby wanted it again. Who was I to say no? Lol I got a small grasshopper. So good. Mint, vanilla, and chocolate with cookie crumbles. So delicious. This will probably be my go to in the future. I'm excited for their holiday flavors to come out. Staff are very nice and check on you too make sure you are happy. We'll be back.
Thank you Yelp Elite for introducing me to Jeremiah's Italian Ice. I've been wanting to try this since I lived in metro Orlando FL, never got there, and it's been awhile--yikes like 18 years. How embarrassing!!! It does show you that Jeremiah's is not a fad. I mean whoever heard of an 18 year fad. Anyway I finally got to try one and I'm hooked. I loved the Italian Ices from the street vendors when living on Long Island and going into NYC. Don't even ask me when that was--like eons ago. You get a colorful welcoming as you approach the store. When you walk in it's very open and clean but has a friendly feel. Staff acknowledges you as you enter. Although I may have gotten a little extra VIP treatment when I told them I was a Yelp Elite, I noticed that every customer was greeted with VIP panache. There are tables to have your treat there or you can ask for it to-go. I took it to-go and much appreciated that the two items were placed in a tray, with spoons and napkins and placed in a bag. The staffer helping me explained the menu thoroughly and then I proceeded to decide. I chose the Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip and wanted something fruity. Staffer recommended the Orange Mango so that's what I got. The Orange Mango is sitting in the freezer. I've eaten half the Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip and wonder why it's taken me all these years and three moves to finally try it. If you like cool treats with flavor that are not too sweet this is for you. Just like the street vendor Italian Ices I had in NYC just with many flavor choices. I'll be passing word to my family and anyone looking for a cool treat. Of course they'll see my mug again in the future.
I went yesterday for the very first time. The staff were very professional, I told them that I have a food allergy, and the woman at the counter gave me a list with all the food allergies. What I wanted was not on the list which were a gelati the guy assist me and we went over the ingredients together very sweet of him honestly. I will most DEFINITELY be coming back very soon. :-) I had the Strawberry Shortcake LOVE it!
Soft serve was good but the kid behind the counter could use a little customer service coaching.
Where ever I am in the country when I see a Jeremiah's Italian Ice I am stopping! I absolutely love their soft serve and Italian ice. It was actually a Yelp event that introduced me to this company and I have been a fan ever since! My go to is the cotton candy Italian ice with vanilla soft serve. It never disappointments my tastebuds. Staff at this location like all the other's I have visited are super friendly and patient if you are undecided. You can taste as many samples as you like until you decide on your favorite.