McGarity's Restaurant & Saloon ® -- Eureka Springs, AR

We had excellent service. The atmosphere is cozy. I love love love the music. The food is out of this world!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

This family-owned restaurant serves up authentic Irish cuisine with a modern twist. The cozy, rustic setting, combined with the warm hospitality, creates a welcoming ambiance.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

A place filled with charm and character. Lots of menu options and portions are quite filling. The wait staff is attentive and friendly. There is a bar area, two private booths with a curtains and television for couples or party of four. There’s also games (uno,dominos)at your table to keep yourself entertained and plenty of condiments to choose from.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Too dark to see menu or food. Server was eager to take our order. I should have taken longer to decide, do it wasn’t his fault. The shepherd’s pie was a generous serving, but server had to place food on a big plate so that I could see to eat. Husband ordered white wine salmon. Fish didn’t taste pr smell fresh. A side of asparagus consisted of 3 below average-tasting spears. Cheese grits were absolutely the best part of the meal. Service was really good. My last recommendation is to provide better lighting inside AND OUTSIDE.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 5

It was a good meal. The timing was off. Wife had the Red snapper. She loved it. I ordered the Ruben. As you can see from the picture it was dried out from sitting under a heat lamp. It was like the Ruben was done for about 20 to 25 minutes before my wife's dish. It took about an hour for the food to come out. My side was onion rings and I didn't care for them. Wife's sides were the mashed potatoes and grill cabbage. Once again she loved them too! Over all we'll be back.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

I just wish there was one of these in our city. Truly a hidden gem in Eureka. The Craft beer menu must have had 50 beers on it but more importantly is the Guinness on tap, it’s the real deal. I don’t know how they stay in business with the portions. I heard the owners are from Texas and I guess they do everything big in Texas and now Eureka Springs.

Great food and staff was friendly and very efficient. Owner is super great and went to great lengths to return a jacket to me that I had accidentally left. 3 thumbs up for this restaurant, I highly recommend.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Our new favorite place to eat in Eureka Springs! Amazing atmosphere, excellent service. Be ready to eat. Portions are LARGE! Bangers n Mash was excellent. Fish n Chips great as well!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Busch Mountain Fishing Lodge and Busch Mountain Fishing Guide Service enjoyed an evening at McGarity's Restaurant. Even our customers left a review inside our Lodge saying great food. We highly recommend McGarity's Restaurant they are kind people and good food.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

This place just opened about 6 months ago. I first came and it was was pretty decent. I just came back after all this time and boy oh boy have they turned up their game. The food is even bigger and better than I remembered, flavors going everywhere. They made a lot of changes to their menu and I guess the staff just got better and better as time has gone on. Truly fantastic in each and every way.

Delicious food. Corn beef is amazing.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

This place does not disappoint! The service was absolutely outstanding. They were attentive as soon as we walked in the door and never let up. Meesh offered up suggestions on favorites and made sure we had everything we needed to enjoy our experience. We had shepherds pie and a Reuben sandwich. We also had the appetizer of medallions. All of the portions were amazing and way too much for us to eat. Our mixed drinks and beer were served immediately. We will definitely be back.

I wish it was possible to give more than 5 stars! I can't begin to say how wonderful this restaurant is! It was crazy busy, being the zombie crawl weekend, but they got us in quickly. The host was very kind and apologetic about us having to wait but we knew we'd have to. He told us 20 minutes but it was about 10. The inside of the restaurant is very pub like. Very cozy and comfortable. They have a couple of booths that are booths (if you look at the photos you'll understand). Our waiter was a very sweet young man and I'm sorry I can't remember his name. Our drink order came out fast, which was shocking, given the large crowd. The food was fantastic! The cheese and pretzel appetizer was soooooo good. I joked with my husband that if we don't have enough pretzel to finish the cheese, I was just going to dig in with a spoon. It was that good. I had the shepherds pie and loved it. Great flavor. It wasn't traditional, not made with lamb so it was more of a cowboy pie, but it was absolutely yummy. My husband had the rueben sandwich and he said it was the best one he'd ever had. We had some cocktails. I had the luck of the Irish and he had the Irish maid. Both were very good and refreshing. Sweet but not too sweet. This was our anniversary weekend and we got married in Alaska, where duck farts are common and we had a lot of them there. Well when I went to the bathroom my husband ordered us duck farts, which McGarity's doesn't make a lot of, I'm sure. But when he asked, they checked the ingredients and made them! It was a pleasant suprise! McGarity's is definitely going to be one of the places we must go to every time we come to Eureka Springs. I can't wait to go back! We loved this place and it was actually one of my favorite things we did while in town! 20/10!!! Good job McGarity's! ❤️🍀
I would also love to mention that they supplied feminine hygiene products in the bathroom. They also have a sign asking for people to NOT tip on take away orders! 💚

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Very strange table setup; mostly 3tops & hardly any 4tops. Wait time grossly underestimated. Servers very nice & attentive & helpful with menu. Blackened redfish excellent, country fried steak not good at all. Quaint place seating very tight but good atmosphere.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 4

Ethan don't go!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5