McGarity's Restaurant & Saloon ® -- Eureka Springs, AR

I love everything about McGarity’s Irisih Pub. They feed those in need for free which is on their sign outside. The ambiance is to die for like something right of Europe and the food is so delicious. I had a mouth watering Reuben full of Juicy corned beef cooked to perfection. It was so big, I couldn't eat it all. The wife had the best Crab Cakes she has ever eaten and my eldest son had the Guinness Fish & Chips. Seriously, the best he has ever had and it’s his go-to food everywhere. They give huge portions and children 5 and under eat free. Who does that these days? You won’t be disappointed, that’s for sure. Hands down the best place to eat and drink in Eureka Springs.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Guinness Fish Shrimp and Chips, Irish Reuben Egg Rolls, McGarity's Reuben, Crab Cakes

Kind of an odd ren fest kind of vibe with. TVs at every angle. A bunch of old timers enjoying food as a lone patron yelled at them about the election. No one cared - the foods too good.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Shepherd's Pie

Make sure you come hungry, huge portions with delicious tasting food. This is my new "go to" in town.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

We all loved it. Even the dessert was great and all reasonably priced for the portion sizes you get!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Step into a world of elegance and sophistication at this upscale Irish Saloon lol love the name it’s like Restaurant, Saloon, Irish Pub all in one. The stunning decor, impeccable service, and innovative Irish cuisine make it a must-visit for any foodie and those with taste for true Irish flair and decor.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

This place has some seriously good grubs.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

We got bangers and mash and shepards pie ? ? was so amazing and the portions are enough to share or take home n have for lunch the next day. The waitstaff is amazing
Will definitely go back.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Irish Bangers and Mash, Shepherd's Pie

We had a remarkable positive dining experience. Friendly and exceptional service. One of the more authentic Irish dining experiences my wife and I have enjoyed. Shepherd's Pie superb, presentation table side made me ask my bride "How do I eat this?" Best flavored S Pie ever. 5 star recommendation here, try it, enjoy!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I had never eaten Irish food before. I was pleasantly surprised at how good my meal was.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Shepherd's Pie

The best wedge salad i have ever seen or eaten. The thing was so huge and fresh I coulnd't beleive my eyes.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

This is one of the best spots Eureka Springs has for good quality food. I have yet to have a bad dish there, and the staff are great.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

The place looked cool on the inside. I was hoping the food would be good too but I was highly disappointed. We ordered two lettuce wedge salads to start. The salad was huge and occupied the entire plate. It was nearly impossible to cut into it without making huge mess. It was very difficult to eat. It was pretty much flavorless as far as the veggies. The lettuce tasted like water. I think the tomatoes had been stored in the fridge bc they had no taste, the red onions were too strong and the avocado was old and mushy. Mind you, this salad was $17. It did have a lot of blue cheese, too much if you ask me and not enough dressing. I asked for more dressing to make it more palatable and when I saw the check I was charged for the little bit of ranch dressing the server brought me. There was absolutely no thought put into this dish or how a customer would eat this.
My hubby had the Shepard’s pie and he like it, which is why I’m giving it two stars. I had the jackfruit lemon pasta and it was the worst pasta dish I’ve ever had in my life. There was no “sauce” at all. It was very dry but covered in herbs; which I think were old bc they barely had any flavor. The jackfruit tasted weird and not well prepared. It was like they got some boiled penne, opened a can of Jackfruit threw some herbs in and squeeze a lemon on top of it and called it a day. For this they charged me $16. I was starving so I had a few bites, but I couldn’t eat it anymore. It was that bad. I would be embarrassed to serve this to anyone at my house. So all in all our check was a little over $80 for two people. The food is overpriced and not fresh. I would never go back here or recommend it to anyone. We should’ve went to Pizza Hut which is right there within walking distance or bought frozen microwave food from Walmart. Frozen dinners would’ve tasted better and been a fraction of the price.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 2

Stopped in for the first time. Overall it was really good!! The nachos were packed with flavor and they used sweet potato fries as the base. Bangers and mash was a pretty solid dish. Loved the fried cabbage so full of flavor! My only slight issue was that they put so much on plate, when I’d try to cut into food the juices from fried cabbage (and there was a lot) spilled over the side of my plate which turned into a mess on table. Not sure if it was supposed to be that much liquid. We went a la carte for our daughter and we won’t do that again if we come back. We should’ve asked more questions on that. A side of shrimp, a single crab cake and side of carrots cost almost more than my husband’s and my dish combined! Not a huge issue but a little taken back by almost $30. Overall really good though!

The waitress was nice offered good menu selections. The food was reasonable priced especially for the quality.

The setting was nice. The Irish Pub decor was impressive. The restaurant and restrooms were clean.

Minus a star only because we were seated in a cramped spot. We sat next to a couple in a cramped corner when there were many other open seating areas that would’ve boosted our experience. Understandable for the area in town though.

I will be back to try other menu items.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Irish Reuben Egg Rolls, Blackened Red Fish, Shepherd's Pie

Me and my wife were starving, went in had the best shepards/cottage pie I've ever had. Food was out fast, great quality, big portions, very reasonable and tasted immaculate. Beautiful interior as well, definitely recommend this to anyone in the area!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Mashed Potatoes, Shepherd's Pie