Old Mill Pizza
CLOSED$ •
About Old Mill Pizza
Old Mill Pizza Reviews
Friendly staff and good pizza. Ignore the comments from the brain-washed Liberals about the masks. They have hopefully woken up by now!
Great food. It is also a bar. I dont drink but enjoy that the lights are low. With all the florescent lights now the break from them is great. Food is always good and not just a heat and serve place. The pizza is good but the sandwiches are listed on here but they are great as well
Homey atmosphere. Great pizza with crispy crust. Had the supreme pizza with a salad. Seth waited on us. He works hard and goes the extra mile to make sure his guests feel welcome. He was extra busy too. Good kid. Glad to have met him and plan on going back and enjoying some more pie.
Old Mill Pizza is a beloved local eatery that consistently impresses customers with its exceptional pizza and warm, welcoming atmosphere. The pizza is universally praised for its delicious balance of flavors and satisfying crunch, with standout dishes like the Harvey pizza and Acropolis pizza with ranch dressing. The friendly staff provide fast and attentive service, going the extra mile to ensure a memorable dining experience. The restaurant also functions as a bar, featuring low lighting that offers a nice break from fluorescent lights, creating a homey atmosphere. Customers often enjoy the crispy crust of the great pizza, and some appreciate that the food is more than just heat and serve, with sandwiches also receiving praise. Visitors have found the staff to be very friendly and helpful, making them feel welcome whether dining in or picking up carry-out. Despite some negative comments from a few years ago, many find the restaurant clean, the staff welcoming, and the pizza good. Old Mill Pizza remains a favorite spot for pizza nights, offering consistently good food and a hospitable ambiance.