poor service. long wait on food 3 customers that ordered after us got there food before us, hush puppies tasted burnt. one waiter kept scratching his crotch while walking thru restaurant. everything was over salted. fillet in the sampler says 2 fillet. basically mine was 1 fillet broke in half compared to my wife fillets which were normal size. Will never return to your establishment.
Eli Stokes
By far the worst experience at eat my catfish. Our shrimp smelled and tasted like beach we sent it back and they didn’t even offer to refund us. The sides were cold and bland, condiments like lemons were setting out so long they had wilted and went mushy. After bringing up the food issues with the server she offered us a pie which turned out to be a single serving fried pie. No compensation nor apology from the manager nothing. We will not be back
Dave Wilson
Catfish portions were small, but tasty. Okra a bit undercooked. Have good hushpuppies
Aizak
2dY iz da best day evA. i got chimkin i got frys i got sweet tee n i got 2 sit by the window and look at cars go zooom da chimkin was CRONCHY an it tasted awsummm my mom sayed slow down but i was EATIN like a dragon i droped a fry and i was sad but the nice ladie Lilli sayed itz ok and i felt bettr i wish i culd live there an eat all day 2dY iz da best day evA
— Aizak (age 6 n 1 have)
Eddie Suttle
My experience was very good all the way around. Food was great, service was the best thanks to (Sara). Better than the Whippet in Prattville, Ar. Was yrs ago.
fulltimedogdad (fulltimedogdad)
man i love this siloam springs branch because the service here is so great. Lilli thank you for checking up on us!
carol cerny
The catfish was breaded lightly and flavorful and the coleslaw was delicious. I saved the location so we could stop again.
Ethan Pearson
Good chicken, good root beer, and nice staff. 10/10 would eat here again.
Jeanine Dierking
My husband and I love everything about eat my catfish. The food is always delicious & the service is second to none. Lilli is the friendliest server in town (Siloam springs). Highly recommended.
Gayle Williams
We had a large church group meet Sunday for lunch after church. Sara and Lee were very helpful and pleasant as they took our orders and delivered our food. The food came out much quicker than we expected and, as usual, it was delicious! It was a very good dining experience and I appreciate their service and smiling faces. I always have a good time when I come to Eat My Catfish. I can't recommend it enough. 🥰
Had an awesome experience at Eat My Catfish in Siloam Springs! Boone was extremely funny and kept the energy up the whole time, and Rowan was super charming and made us feel right at home. The catfish? Cooked to absolute perfection — crispy, flavorful, and piping hot. And don’t even get me started on the Willie Dust… absolutely addictive! Ontop of that, the area is super clean making the entire experience even better. Can’t wait to come back for more. Would highly recommend to anyone in the area.
Eva Gemarino
Food is excellent, absolutely delicious. Great service special thanks to Sarah and Lee they are amazing and so helpful.
Lanny Ashlock
Awesome catfish and crawdads. Friendly staff!! Plan to go back!!
Jennifer Cochran
The service was really friendly the atmosphere was nice & pleasant the food was great my compliments to the chef Booner🐟
Carney Caughman
Great service from both Isaac and Helene, and the cook Rowan did an excellent job on the crawfish and shrimp this guy can cook very good place to eat.
poor service. long wait on food 3 customers that ordered after us got there food before us, hush puppies tasted burnt. one waiter kept scratching his crotch while walking thru restaurant. everything was over salted. fillet in the sampler says 2 fillet. basically mine was 1 fillet broke in half compared to my wife fillets which were normal size. Will never return to your establishment.
By far the worst experience at eat my catfish. Our shrimp smelled and tasted like beach we sent it back and they didn’t even offer to refund us. The sides were cold and bland, condiments like lemons were setting out so long they had wilted and went mushy. After bringing up the food issues with the server she offered us a pie which turned out to be a single serving fried pie. No compensation nor apology from the manager nothing. We will not be back
Catfish portions were small, but tasty. Okra a bit undercooked. Have good hushpuppies
2dY iz da best day evA. i got chimkin i got frys i got sweet tee n i got 2 sit by the window and look at cars go zooom da chimkin was CRONCHY an it tasted awsummm my mom sayed slow down but i was EATIN like a dragon i droped a fry and i was sad but the nice ladie Lilli sayed itz ok and i felt bettr i wish i culd live there an eat all day 2dY iz da best day evA
— Aizak (age 6 n 1 have)
My experience was very good all the way around. Food was great, service was the best thanks to (Sara). Better than the Whippet in Prattville, Ar. Was yrs ago.
man i love this siloam springs branch because the service here is so great. Lilli thank you for checking up on us!
The catfish was breaded lightly and flavorful and the coleslaw was delicious. I saved the location so we could stop again.
Good chicken, good root beer, and nice staff. 10/10 would eat here again.
My husband and I love everything about eat my catfish. The food is always delicious & the service is second to none. Lilli is the friendliest server in town (Siloam springs). Highly recommended.
We had a large church group meet Sunday for lunch after church. Sara and Lee were very helpful and pleasant as they took our orders and delivered our food. The food came out much quicker than we expected and, as usual, it was delicious! It was a very good dining experience and I appreciate their service and smiling faces. I always have a good time when I come to Eat My Catfish. I can't recommend it enough. 🥰
Restaurantji Recommends
Had an awesome experience at Eat My Catfish in Siloam Springs! Boone was extremely funny and kept the energy up the whole time, and Rowan was super charming and made us feel right at home. The catfish? Cooked to absolute perfection — crispy, flavorful, and piping hot. And don’t even get me started on the Willie Dust… absolutely addictive! Ontop of that, the area is super clean making the entire experience even better. Can’t wait to come back for more. Would highly recommend to anyone in the area.
Food is excellent, absolutely delicious. Great service special thanks to Sarah and Lee they are amazing and so helpful.
Awesome catfish and crawdads. Friendly staff!! Plan to go back!!
The service was really friendly the atmosphere was nice & pleasant the food was great my compliments to the chef Booner🐟
Great service from both Isaac and Helene, and the cook Rowan did an excellent job on the crawfish and shrimp this guy can cook very good place to eat.
Loading...