Excellent pizza and salad. The server was attentive and friendly. Some of the best pizza anywhere
Opentable Diner
1.Waited 35 min with a reservation. And 10 min before seeing anyone at our table (in a Monday night) 2. Saw our drinks from the bar sit at the bar for 20 minutes (timed it) before we got up and got them ourselves 3. Waiter was told that one in our party has a SEVERE and life threatening allergy to egg and peanut. First, he gives an “I think it's ok” answer. After we asked him to please check, he comes back and said he's been googling it and trying to find pasta boxes. He announces,” no egg in anything. Then the next time he comes to the table tells us ALL the pasta has egg. Why not send a manager or ask the chef? 4. When ordering salad- waiter tells us there is no arugula. So, we ask for 2 salads romaine substitute on the arugula salad. No onion. Salad comes out at the end of the meal. One HAS arugula. The other doesn't- but does have onion. 5. Had to ask for one of our main dishes and all the salads repeatedly. Waters and drinks never tended to. 6. Staff was put out, but they caused the issues that led to the frustration. I still left a 10% tip because I understand it's not JUST The waiter or kitchen or hostess fault. But, the whole thing felt like the restaurant was overwhelmed and unprofessional. I cannot see myself ever going back and definitely would not ever bring guests or trust this restaurant with any food allergies.
Karlene
Food good as always, we keep coming back whenever we're visiting, a family favorite. What is that service tax, let customers choose to give gratis. Not a fan.
Sara
Everything was great! The food and the service were top notch. Parking is a little tight and you need to make reservations
Wendy
First time here and it was delicious! We got the burrata appetizer, a Cesar salad and Ms. Piggy pie. All of them were so flavorful and crave worthy! Can't wait to go back!
Linda
Highly recommend! Pizza delicious and staff very pleasant and professional. Definitely will return when passing thru Flagstaff.
Jennifer
Jennifer was our server and she was excellent. So good at multi tasking but also giving all her tables her utmost attention. The pizza and salad we got were FANTASTIC. We would highly recommend eating at this restaurant but also highly recommend getting a reservation. We had one and it made it so easy to walk in and be seated immediately. Seems like a place that is ALWAYS busy which is a good sign too.
Jody
Food was good and seated on time. Service was terrible. We asked them to take the dirty dishes from the appetizers away so we could have room for the pizzas. Finally the third person we asked to take them did take them. Never received our refills on sodas. Love the pizzas, however, the last three times we were there the service has been bad. Time to find a new pizza place.
Jacklyn
Fat Olives is awesome! Highly recommend the sracciatella appetizer. It is amazing! We also had the sausage pizza and added button mushrooms. We come to this restaurant every time we are in Flagstaff!
Alan
It's a great little place to eat... it busy most of the times around lunch... it's best to make reservations if you don't want to be waiting for a table.. they use traditional flour, tomatoes, olive oil and mozzarella cheese are their signature ingredients...
We drove from Globe AZ to get pizza to take back home after visiting one of their sisters restaurant. Both are high on the marks for good quality of food. I will drive up to Flagstaff to do this again. The long drive is worth the drive to eat here again and again. We had Belogio Dolce same one Guy Fiera ate when he visited from DDD show
Rachael K
Great place in Flag. Ate there 2x in 1 week.
Sue Clark
We shared a Margherita pizza and a cherries and chocolate canolli, both of which were delicious. The mixed-flavor canolli was suggested by our excellent waitress.
Shannon Lieber
The food came out quickly, was over the top amazing and friendly staff. We have a new favorite spot when we visit flagstaff.
Taylor Dlugopolski
The Experience here was very authentic, we had the chicken parmesan , spaghetti and meatballs, and the famous lasagna. Every dish was delightful. Definitely can tell the sauce was handmade for hours. I recommend this to anyone who passes through this little cute town!
Excellent pizza and salad. The server was attentive and friendly. Some of the best pizza anywhere
1.Waited 35 min with a reservation. And 10 min before seeing anyone at our table (in a Monday night) 2. Saw our drinks from the bar sit at the bar for 20 minutes (timed it) before we got up and got them ourselves 3. Waiter was told that one in our party has a SEVERE and life threatening allergy to egg and peanut. First, he gives an “I think it's ok” answer. After we asked him to please check, he comes back and said he's been googling it and trying to find pasta boxes. He announces,” no egg in anything. Then the next time he comes to the table tells us ALL the pasta has egg. Why not send a manager or ask the chef? 4. When ordering salad- waiter tells us there is no arugula. So, we ask for 2 salads romaine substitute on the arugula salad. No onion. Salad comes out at the end of the meal. One HAS arugula. The other doesn't- but does have onion. 5. Had to ask for one of our main dishes and all the salads repeatedly. Waters and drinks never tended to. 6. Staff was put out, but they caused the issues that led to the frustration. I still left a 10% tip because I understand it's not JUST The waiter or kitchen or hostess fault. But, the whole thing felt like the restaurant was overwhelmed and unprofessional. I cannot see myself ever going back and definitely would not ever bring guests or trust this restaurant with any food allergies.
Food good as always, we keep coming back whenever we're visiting, a family favorite. What is that service tax, let customers choose to give gratis. Not a fan.
Everything was great! The food and the service were top notch. Parking is a little tight and you need to make reservations
First time here and it was delicious! We got the burrata appetizer, a Cesar salad and Ms. Piggy pie. All of them were so flavorful and crave worthy! Can't wait to go back!
Highly recommend! Pizza delicious and staff very pleasant and professional. Definitely will return when passing thru Flagstaff.
Jennifer was our server and she was excellent. So good at multi tasking but also giving all her tables her utmost attention. The pizza and salad we got were FANTASTIC. We would highly recommend eating at this restaurant but also highly recommend getting a reservation. We had one and it made it so easy to walk in and be seated immediately. Seems like a place that is ALWAYS busy which is a good sign too.
Food was good and seated on time. Service was terrible. We asked them to take the dirty dishes from the appetizers away so we could have room for the pizzas. Finally the third person we asked to take them did take them. Never received our refills on sodas. Love the pizzas, however, the last three times we were there the service has been bad. Time to find a new pizza place.
Fat Olives is awesome! Highly recommend the sracciatella appetizer. It is amazing! We also had the sausage pizza and added button mushrooms. We come to this restaurant every time we are in Flagstaff!
It's a great little place to eat... it busy most of the times around lunch... it's best to make reservations if you don't want to be waiting for a table.. they use traditional flour, tomatoes, olive oil and mozzarella cheese are their signature ingredients...
Restaurantji Recommends
We drove from Globe AZ to get pizza to take back home after visiting one of their sisters restaurant. Both are high on the marks for good quality of food. I will drive up to Flagstaff to do this again. The long drive is worth the drive to eat here again and again. We had Belogio Dolce same one Guy Fiera ate when he visited from DDD show
Great place in Flag. Ate there 2x in 1 week.
We shared a Margherita pizza and a cherries and chocolate canolli, both of which were delicious. The mixed-flavor canolli was suggested by our excellent waitress.
The food came out quickly, was over the top amazing and friendly staff. We have a new favorite spot when we visit flagstaff.
The Experience here was very authentic, we had the chicken parmesan , spaghetti and meatballs, and the famous lasagna. Every dish was delightful. Definitely can tell the sauce was handmade for hours. I recommend this to anyone who passes through this little cute town!
Loading...