If you like authentic, This is the place for your Italiano pizza, salad and breadsticks! You can feel the love in the food, it does take some wait time but you will not be disappointed! One of the owners was the only one there and he was so pleasant! Would definitely be coming back!!! Traveled in from Texas!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Brian Luna
Amazing 👏, food was so fresh and could tell there's love in every bite. Spoke with Marco awesome soul. From the cheesy breads to the house salad to the pizza , 100 💯 chefs kiss. The dinning room choice of music was awesome, I wonder if he picks it. My wife couldn't sit still.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jackson Fin
Visited during Christmas, amazing staff and amazing pizza! Very accommodating
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Orlando Suarez
Placed a dine in order, 2 16’ pizzas, waited for 30 min. Asked how long order would be and was told 15 -20 minutes. After 20 minutes asked if order was almost ready and was told it would be 15 - 20 minutes. Multiple orders that were placed after mine were given out. I felt I was made to wait due to my race as I am Hispanic. Will not be going back
Service: 1
Anthony Gillette
Best pizza in Flagstaff must try it
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jordan
Yes, the waits are long, and also yes, it's the best New York style pizza in all of Arizona, and trust me, I've been to them all.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jorge Izquierdo
Best pizza in Flagstaff, staff so so kind
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Samuel Lawton
It takes a while but that’s because it’s real wood fire pizza. Best pizza in Flagstaff and it’s not even close - unless of course you hate pizza from the north east. A bit expensive but a real treat.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Dennis Morey
True confessions, been here a couple times. One time eat in and another to go. Tonight we ordered a couple pies and they said 50 minutes. I told him I would be there 10 min early because rather have my food hot vs cold. Got there and waited for maybe 5-7 min as other patrons got serviced. Then learned it would be another 15 minute wait. I told them no issue. When the pies were ready the total was over $50. I had a Grant and used my credit card for remainder. They said the card was declined. Likely cause was we weren't locals and prob caught up in fraud prevention algorhythms. I said hey I have other payment tools. Not sure but either the manager or owner was like hey just make it up next time. I said hey brother I want to tip. He said no worries see you next time. Got home and all parties said the food was the shittz. Legit killer good. Better than pies in Phoenix metro with 5M people.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Johnny Fernandez
The WAIT is INSANE! We waited 90+ minutes. Yes, 1 1/2 hours. For pizza. Told them it was our first time here. Never warned us about the wait. It wasn’t busy for dine in. But apparently take out is the priority. But it wasn’t like it was dozens of people. The pizza was very good. But no pizza is nearly 2 hours good.
Alright y’all, these reviews are a rollercoaster so here’s what’s happening here: This is a small, local business making NJ style (aka thin foldable) pizza with fresh & homemade ingredients and you WILL wait a little bit longer and it WILL be delicious and the small & busy staff WILL be kind. While there is a small dining area, they are catering to take-out orders, so just take your za home & watch TV like everyone else. The VEGAN pizza is absolutely delicious and the ✨homemade cashew cheese✨was so good! And to the poor humans who waited too long for someone else to make them pizza on a Saturday night…I guess you should’ve gone to Little Caesars. As for me, I will be retuning here! 🤘🏽
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
A.S.G.
This is, hands down, the best pizza in Arizona. Tastes just like we’re back east. Thank you!!!
Mike Fritsch
I'm just a one week visitor to Flagstaff but to me their pizza is just okay with the thinner crushed one being better than the thick crust. I really liked the pizza at Fat Olives Italian restaurant a lot better. They have some interesting pizza choices however, and you can pretty much make whatever you want so they're still in the top group in Flagstaff in my mind
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Joyce Kelly (GLHN)
Best Vegan Pizza EVER! The crust, tomatoes, piles of veggies and olives and fresh basil on top were astounding. I substituted the pineapple for a single, premium anchovy. It was superb and fueled a 2 mile evening hike. It was a little too smoky in there and smelled of cleaning agents so we didn't eat in. The public shelf of excellent cook books made the wait for the pizzas fly by. I'll be back.
Joyce Kelly
Best Vegan Pizza EVER! The crust, tomatoes, piles of veggies and olives and fresh basil on top were astounding. I substituted the pineapple for a single, premium anchovy. It was superb and fueled a 2 mile evening hike. It was a little too smoky in there and smelled of cleaning agents so we didn't eat in. The public shelf of excellent cook books made the wait for the pizzas fly by. I'll be back.
If you like authentic, This is the place for your Italiano pizza, salad and breadsticks! You can feel the love in the food, it does take some wait time but you will not be disappointed! One of the owners was the only one there and he was so pleasant! Would definitely be coming back!!! Traveled in from Texas!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Amazing 👏, food was so fresh and could tell there's love in every bite. Spoke with Marco awesome soul.
From the cheesy breads to the house salad to the pizza , 100 💯 chefs kiss.
The dinning room choice of music was awesome, I wonder if he picks it. My wife couldn't sit still.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Visited during Christmas, amazing staff and amazing pizza! Very accommodating
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Placed a dine in order, 2 16’ pizzas, waited for 30 min. Asked how long order would be and was told 15 -20 minutes. After 20 minutes asked if order was almost ready and was told it would be 15 - 20 minutes. Multiple orders that were placed after mine were given out. I felt I was made to wait due to my race as I am Hispanic. Will not be going back
Service: 1
Best pizza in Flagstaff must try it
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Yes, the waits are long, and also yes, it's the best New York style pizza in all of Arizona, and trust me, I've been to them all.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best pizza in Flagstaff, staff so so kind
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
It takes a while but that’s because it’s real wood fire pizza. Best pizza in Flagstaff and it’s not even close - unless of course you hate pizza from the north east. A bit expensive but a real treat.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
True confessions, been here a couple times. One time eat in and another to go. Tonight we ordered a couple pies and they said 50 minutes. I told him I would be there 10 min early because rather have my food hot vs cold. Got there and waited for maybe 5-7 min as other patrons got serviced. Then learned it would be another 15 minute wait. I told them no issue. When the pies were ready the total was over $50. I had a Grant and used my credit card for remainder. They said the card was declined. Likely cause was we weren't locals and prob caught up in fraud prevention algorhythms. I said hey I have other payment tools. Not sure but either the manager or owner was like hey just make it up next time. I said hey brother I want to tip. He said no worries see you next time. Got home and all parties said the food was the shittz. Legit killer good. Better than pies in Phoenix metro with 5M people.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The WAIT is INSANE! We waited 90+ minutes. Yes, 1 1/2 hours. For pizza. Told them it was our first time here. Never warned us about the wait. It wasn’t busy for dine in. But apparently take out is the priority. But it wasn’t like it was dozens of people. The pizza was very good. But no pizza is nearly 2 hours good.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 2
Restaurantji Recommends
Alright y’all, these reviews are a rollercoaster so here’s what’s happening here: This is a small, local business making NJ style (aka thin foldable) pizza with fresh & homemade ingredients and you WILL wait a little bit longer and it WILL be delicious and the small & busy staff WILL be kind. While there is a small dining area, they are catering to take-out orders, so just take your za home & watch TV like everyone else. The VEGAN pizza is absolutely delicious and the ✨homemade cashew cheese✨was so good! And to the poor humans who waited too long for someone else to make them pizza on a Saturday night…I guess you should’ve gone to Little Caesars. As for me, I will be retuning here! 🤘🏽
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
This is, hands down, the best pizza in Arizona. Tastes just like we’re back east. Thank you!!!
I'm just a one week visitor to Flagstaff but to me their pizza is just okay with the thinner crushed one being better than the thick crust. I really liked the pizza at Fat Olives Italian restaurant a lot better. They have some interesting pizza choices however, and you can pretty much make whatever you want so they're still in the top group in Flagstaff in my mind
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Best Vegan Pizza EVER!
The crust, tomatoes, piles of veggies and olives and fresh basil on top were astounding.
I substituted the pineapple for a single, premium anchovy. It was superb and fueled a 2 mile evening hike.
It was a little too smoky in there and smelled of cleaning agents so we didn't eat in. The public shelf of excellent cook books made the wait for the pizzas fly by.
I'll be back.
Best Vegan Pizza EVER!
The crust, tomatoes, piles of veggies and olives and fresh basil on top were astounding.
I substituted the pineapple for a single, premium anchovy. It was superb and fueled a 2 mile evening hike.
It was a little too smoky in there and smelled of cleaning agents so we didn't eat in. The public shelf of excellent cook books made the wait for the pizzas fly by.
I'll be back.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...