New Jersey Pizza Co

2224 E Cedar Ave #6, Flagstaff
(928) 774-5000

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Meat Lovers Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Vegan Supreme
Bread Sticks
House Salad

Menu

Build Your Own
One Item Pizza
Two Item Pizza
Margherita
Classic Cheese Pizza
Four + Item Pizza
Three Item Pizza

Specialty Pies
Crimini (V)
Extra virgin sauce, fresh pulled mozzarella, cheddar, chevre, mushroom, onion, caramelized onion, parmesan, and basil.
Alex (V)
Fresh pulled mozzarella, spinach, tomato, black olive, garlic, feta, parmesan, and basil.
Meat Lover
Fresh pulled mozzarella, sausage, ham, bacon, pepperoni, meatball, parmesan, and basil.
Combo
Fresh pulled mozzarella, sausage, ham, roasted red bell pepper, onion, olive, parmesan, and basil.
Four Cheese Pizza (V)
Fresh pulled mozzarella, cheddar, ricotta, parmesan, and basil.
DiBartolo (V)
Extra virgin sauce, fresh pulled mozzarella, marinated baby-tomatoes, onion, parmesan, and basil.
Chucho
Extra virgin sauce, fresh pulled mozzarella, meatball, fresh tomato, fire-roasted tomato, onion, bacon, chevre, parmesan, and basil.
Award Winning Steamy V (Vegan)
Cheese-less, spinach, bell pepper, onion, mushroom, pineapple, fresh garlic, Nicoise olive, and basil.
Veggie (V)
Fresh pulled mozzarella, tomato, mushroom, roasted red bell pepper, Nicoise olive, onion, parmesan, and basil.
Sausage Lover
Fresh pulled mozzarella, sausage, onion, chili's, roasted red bell pepper, cheddar, parmesan, and basil.
Bleu Ball
Extra virgin sauce, bleu cheese, meatballs, fresh pulled mozzarella, spinach, onion, bacon, parmesan, and basil.
Ball Lover
Fresh pulled mozzarella, meatball, onion, bacon, cheddar, parmesan, and basil.
Hawaiian
Fresh pulled mozzarella, cheddar, chicken, onion, pineapple, bacon, and parmesan.
White (V)
Extra virgin sauce, fresh pulled mozzarella, chevre, spinach, tomato, onion, black olive, parmesan, and basil.
Nate
Extra virgin sauce, fresh pulled mozzarella, feta, chicken, pineapple, bacon, chili's, onion, and parmesan.
Pesto (V)
House-made pesto sauce, fresh pulled mozzarella, tomato, mushroom, onion, bell pepper, and parmesan.

Starters
Cheese Breadsticks
Extra virgin olive oil, cheddar, mozzarella, parmesan, and served with red sauce.
Chicken Wings (1.5 lb) (dozen)
Mary's chicken wings are hormone free, antibiotic-free, veg-fed, and cage-free. Baked not fried.
House Salad
Organic mixed greens, baby tomatoes, Nicoise olives, and shaved parmesan.
Green Salad
Organic mixed greens, shaved parmesan.
Breadsticks
House-made with a choice of homemade dipping sauce.

Mezze & Hummus
#4 Hummus: Goats Milk Feta, Za'atar
All hummus is served with house-made, heart-baked pita, and pickled vegetables.
#1 Mezze Platter (Feta)
Includes Hummus, Baba Ganoush, Charred Beets, Israeli Salad, Olives, Pickled Vegetables, Goat's Milk Feta and a Hearth-Baked Pita
#1 Hummus: Evoo, Smoked Paprika, Urfa Biber
All hummus is served with house-made, heart-baked pita, and pickled vegetables.
Extra Pita
House-made, hearth-baked. All hummus is served with house-made, heart-baked pita, and pickled vegetables.
#5 Hummus: Fermented Cashew Labneh, Za'atar
All hummus is served with house-made, heart-baked pita, and pickled vegetables.
#2 Mezze Platter (Vegan)
Includes Hummus, Baba Ganoush, Charred Beets, Israeli Salad, Olives, Pickled Vegetables,Fermented Cashew Labneh and a Hearth-Baked Pita
#2 Hummus: Zhoug
Spicy Yemenite fresh pepper sauce. All hummus is served with house-made, heart-baked pita, and pickled vegetables.
#3 Hummus: Toasted Pine Nuts, EVOO
All hummus is served with house-made, heart-baked pita, and pickled vegetables.

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: facebook
+41 photos
Photo credit: facebook
+40 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

It takes a while but that’s because it’s real wood fire pizza. Best pizza in Flagstaff and it’s not even close - unless of course you hate pizza from the north east. A bit expensive but a real treat.
August 2025
True confessions, been here a couple times. One time eat in and another to go. Tonight we ordered a couple pies and they said 50 minutes. I told him I would be there 10 min early because rather have my food hot vs cold. Got there and waited for maybe 5-7 min as other patrons got serviced. Then learned it would be another 15 minute wait. I told them no issue. When the pies were ready the total was over $50. I had a Grant and used my credit card for remainder. They said the card...
August 2025
The WAIT is INSANE! We waited 90+ minutes. Yes, 1 1/2 hours. For pizza. Told them it was our first time here. Never warned us about the wait. It wasn’t busy for dine in. But apparently take out is the priority. But it wasn’t like it was dozens of people. The pizza was very good. But no pizza is nearly 2 hours good.
August 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Polibertos - 2221 E Cedar Ave
Mexican, Tacos, Vegetarian
Cedar House Coffee Shop & Bakery - 2009 E Cedar Ave
Coffee Shops, Coffee & Tea, Bakery, Coffee, Gluten-Free
Little Caesars Pizza - 1500 E Cedar Ave
Pizza, Chicken Wings

New Jersey Pizza Co

2224 E Cedar Ave #6, Flagstaff, AZ 86004
(928) 774-5000