Best pizza in flag. Too bad it's $75 for one pizza, boneless wings and zucchini. I'll splurge here and there
Flora Paddock
Pizza was delicious!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
William Prestridge
As a long time purveyor of pizza myself, I can pleasantly say I am particular to this place. Please place your order as soon as possible.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Trenton Floyd
Fratellies is better.the ranch tasted like a hidden valley bottle.the pizza sauce was kinda bland.not a fan of how thick the bread is price was fair.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 4
Cerita Metcalf
We ordered a pepperoni and a meat lovers type of pizza. The kids had a slice of the pineapple and ham. We also purchased the antipasto salad. Everything was delicious served hot and with a smile. There was a place for the kids to play when they got bored. Great experience
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza by the Slice, Specialty Pizzas, Hot Wings, Salads, Antipasto
Heather Tigra- Hair of the Tiger Beauty \u0026 Wellness
If you are ever in Flagstaff, eat this pizza! Vegan cheese option, very tasty. Crust was crispy (not chewy) which I really enjoyed. Very yummy red sauce. We dined and they offer garlic cholulua as an option to add. So yummy!
Chuck Skinner
Ordered online for delivery. Expected delivery was 1 hour, it was at our door in 40 minutes. Hot, delicious and exactly what we ordered. Definitely living up to your reviews and ratings. Thank you!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jason Phinney
Hands down the best pizza in the state of Arizona. Every time we visit this is the first place we always go to eat.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Wayne Fredrick
So I spend 23 dollars on a pizza and get the smallest amount of toppings of any pizza parlor in flagstaff. Even tho they have great pizza they need to put toppings on the pizza 10 pepperoni aint enoug
Tim Farrell
First time was hoping to get some crispy cooked wings and got all drums barely cooked and served barely warm. Tried both bone and boneless wings, and they both were not good, would not recommend.
Came in at 9 o'clock on Oct 2nd 2025. Guy that said he was manager asked me to leave because I was holding an unlit cigarette. Then proceeds to have the gentleman that was behind me leave when he used his inhaler. He told the guy he couldn't vape in there. The gentleman showed it to him and told him it was an inhaler. He said they all look the same and had him leave anyway. None of us had even ordered yet. Lost 2 sales while he chatted it up with his friends. No way I would ever recommend this place to anyone. Guess he doesn't know there's laws against discrimination to disabled people also.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
baby Jesus
Pizza is always consistent. The wings are really good. Not the best service, but it's mostly young adults... I get it, I was young once.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 3
Gregory Perez
This establishment ranks high for me in service Suppp
... er friendly and attentive
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ally
We had the best experience here . The food was delicious . We got the pizza , wings and salad . Thanks for the awesome customer service too . We will be back soon . God bless you 😇
I discovered NiMarco’s Pizza on the way back from the Grand Canyon passing through Flagstaff to Phoenix.
I called in my order & through that process got a gentleman on the phone. I gave him the order. Medium Half Pepperoni w/ hot honey and half Gary’s Special No Olives or Mushrooms. Three times I told him medium Flagstaff Crust.
When I arrived at the store I was greeted by an unfriendly young woman. When she got the pizza I said that a medium? No, it’s a large. Well I ordered a medium, well I got to pay for a large. Two people a large specialty that’s is only half a specialty because the other half is pepperoni. Plus the waste. We can’t eat all that and paying for wasted food. Frustrating when it’s not my mistake.
The Pizza: The Flagstaff Crust was magnificent. Crispy bottom & sturdy to hold the toppings. The Half that was pepperoni & Hot Honey had plenty of honey and it added that spicy sweet flavor. The sauce is excellent and paired with the crust & sauce was delicious.
The Gary’s Special with Pepperoni, sausage, onions, & bell peppers was a phenomenal pie. Fresh vegetables, nice sauce, meat, and cheese. Perfect pie.
I would definitely recommend the pizza. They only have one size apparently and it’s large. I did tell the lady and it was there’s nothing I can do attitude. Well I would rather not pay for something I didn’t ask for.
Also be friendly, I get it’s busy and maybe your job sucks, but your attitude sucks worse. Be glad you have a job and that place has great pizza so you should be happy.
Best pizza in flag. Too bad it's $75 for one pizza, boneless wings and zucchini. I'll splurge here and there
Pizza was delicious!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
As a long time purveyor of pizza myself, I can pleasantly say I am particular to this place. Please place your order as soon as possible.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Fratellies is better.the ranch tasted like a hidden valley bottle.the pizza sauce was kinda bland.not a fan of how thick the bread is price was fair.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 4
We ordered a pepperoni and a meat lovers type of pizza. The kids had a slice of the pineapple and ham. We also purchased the antipasto salad. Everything was delicious served hot and with a smile. There was a place for the kids to play when they got bored. Great experience
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza by the Slice, Specialty Pizzas, Hot Wings, Salads, Antipasto
If you are ever in Flagstaff, eat this pizza! Vegan cheese option, very tasty. Crust was crispy (not chewy) which I really enjoyed. Very yummy red sauce. We dined and they offer garlic cholulua as an option to add. So yummy!
Ordered online for delivery. Expected delivery was 1 hour, it was at our door in 40 minutes. Hot, delicious and exactly what we ordered. Definitely living up to your reviews and ratings. Thank you!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Hands down the best pizza in the state of Arizona. Every time we visit this is the first place we always go to eat.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
So I spend 23 dollars on a pizza and get the smallest amount of toppings of any pizza parlor in flagstaff. Even tho they have great pizza they need to put toppings on the pizza 10 pepperoni aint enoug
First time was hoping to get some crispy cooked wings and got all drums barely cooked and served barely warm. Tried both bone and boneless wings, and they both were not good, would not recommend.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Restaurantji Recommends
Came in at 9 o'clock on Oct 2nd 2025. Guy that said he was manager asked me to leave because I was holding an unlit cigarette. Then proceeds to have the gentleman that was behind me leave when he used his inhaler. He told the guy he couldn't vape in there. The gentleman showed it to him and told him it was an inhaler. He said they all look the same and had him leave anyway. None of us had even ordered yet. Lost 2 sales while he chatted it up with his friends. No way I would ever recommend this place to anyone. Guess he doesn't know there's laws against discrimination to disabled people also.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Pizza is always consistent. The wings are really good. Not the best service, but it's mostly young adults... I get it, I was young once.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 3
This establishment ranks high for me in service
Suppp
... er friendly and attentive
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
We had the best experience here . The food was delicious . We got the pizza , wings and salad . Thanks for the awesome customer service too . We will be back soon . God bless you 😇
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Specialty Pizzas, Chicken Wings, Salads
I discovered NiMarco’s Pizza on the way back from the Grand Canyon passing through Flagstaff to Phoenix.
I called in my order & through that process got a gentleman on the phone. I gave him the order. Medium Half Pepperoni w/ hot honey and half Gary’s Special No Olives or Mushrooms. Three times I told him medium Flagstaff Crust.
When I arrived at the store I was greeted by an unfriendly young woman. When she got the pizza I said that a medium? No, it’s a large. Well I ordered a medium, well I got to pay for a large. Two people a large specialty that’s is only half a specialty because the other half is pepperoni. Plus the waste. We can’t eat all that and paying for wasted food. Frustrating when it’s not my mistake.
The Pizza: The Flagstaff Crust was magnificent. Crispy bottom & sturdy to hold the toppings. The Half that was pepperoni & Hot Honey had plenty of honey and it added that spicy sweet flavor. The sauce is excellent and paired with the crust & sauce was delicious.
The Gary’s Special with Pepperoni, sausage, onions, & bell peppers was a phenomenal pie. Fresh vegetables, nice sauce, meat, and cheese. Perfect pie.
I would definitely recommend the pizza. They only have one size apparently and it’s large. I did tell the lady and it was there’s nothing I can do attitude. Well I would rather not pay for something I didn’t ask for.
Also be friendly, I get it’s busy and maybe your job sucks, but your attitude sucks worse. Be glad you have a job and that place has great pizza so you should be happy.
Food: 5
Service: 2
Recommended dishes: Specialty Pizzas
Loading...