I came to flagstaff on a short trip . I was looking for a good pie and I found them ! I went to one of the locations were they deliver daily . Coconut and Blueberries đThey are great !!!
Starr Kaleikini
The customer service at this business is absolutely unacceptable. My relative had a terrible experience speaking with the owner on the phone. He was rude, dismissive, and claimed he prefers texts over callsâsomething that isnât stated on his website. When she simply asked about leftover pies, he got angry, said orders need to be placed a week ahead, and even used the term âsweetheartâ in an inappropriate tone. Itâs clear that customer care is not a priority here. I wonât be supporting this business.
Service: 1
Jen Ramirez
Iâm not from flagstaff and wanted to try buying a pie. Called to ask how he sells them order ahead or if I could do walk up. He was very rude right away and was shouting through the phone. Then he hung up on me. Not the way to handle a phone call for a business, looks like heâs done that to others too.
Service: 1
Dolores Herrera
We live in Albuquerque and we always buy 6 pies to take home for ourselves and family. The owner is phenomenal!!! Pies too delicious for words.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cherry Pie, Apple Pie, Fresh Pies
Christopher Paquette
I purchased an apple crumb from the local gas station in Flagstaff. When I got home to eat the pie, it had strong aftertastes that were displeasing. The topping had an almost dish soap aftertaste and the apples had a musty aftertaste. It even smells off. Not a fan đĄ
Food: 1
Recommended dishes: Apple Pie
Jeff Burke
Not a retail location. I wish the owner would change the location to one of the stations that sells his pies. This address is his house, and when I went there he redirected me to these 5 stores which he stocks:
1. Kachina Villageâs Pic and Run on I 17 2. Mobil at Butler and I 40 3. Silver Saddle on 89 in Doney Park 4. Marathon Station on 4th and 7th 5. Chevron at Highway 180 and Forest
Look for a small stand in the stores with the pies.
The strawberry rhubarb was very good! ?
Food: 5
PJ Collier
Delish. Just purchased a peach pie (his fave) for hubby for Dad's Day. Got it at the gas station just down the street. It's wonderful, the crust is light & fluffy & the peachy center is yummy. We don't usually eat the crust when it's heavy, but when you buy Pie Guy's Pies...you can eat the whole thing!
Food: 5
PJ C (Godsgirl)
Delish. Just purchased a peach pie (his fave) for hubby for Dad's Day. Got it at the gas station just down the street. It's wonderful, the crust is light & fluffy & the peachy center is yummy. We don't usually eat the crust when it's heavy, but when you buy Pie Guy's Pies...you can eat the whole thing!
Food: 5
Christi Kainz
I called the Pie Guyâs phone number to inquire about what flavors they had available today.They donât have a store front but operate out of a commercial kitchen and sell in convenience stores.Since I was from Show Low AZ (2 Hours away) I unfortunately couldnât place order for pick up the following morning.I was texted a list of stores that had their pies. I went to a Chevron station right around the corner from my location.I purchased the Chocolate Cream, and the Strawberry Rhubarb pies.The crusts and the fillings were delicious!!My family loves them! They couldnât wait till Motherâs Day to get into them!!?So if youâre ever out and about, stop into these stores and grab a absolute delicious pie!These 4 stores carry our pies:Mobil at Butler and I 40Silver Saddle on 89 in Doney ParkMarathon Station on 4th and 7thChevron at Highway 180 and Forest
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cherry Pie, Apple Pie, Fresh Pies
Delicious, excellent crust and fillings!
These pies are soooo good!
Call and order it for pickup the next day or get it at various convenience stores around Flagstaff AZ.
You wonât be disappointed!
Jeremy Kingsbury
Picked up a pie at the gas station across from Little America. Strawberry rhubarb and it was delicious. Definitely will be back to try other flavors.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fresh Pies
Leslie 1 Call Tech
We had an amazing lemon meringue pie. Absolutely delicious. We canât wait to try another
Food: 5
Service: 5
Tillandsia Ducar
Just a text away. Very easy to order and pick up without hassle. Pie was delicious and perfect for my husband's birthday. We tried strawberry rhubarb, which was a first, and we loved it. Will order a pie every time we after in Flagstaff from now
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
T D
we stopped at a gas station and got one of the pies. I thought it tasted really good but my girlfriend went beserk with pie lust. she looked up the other pies that this guy makes and she had to have them. She texted him what pies he had available. He said he could make her any type and I donât know if he does this for everyone or if he knew that she was going to bust through his kitchen wall like the coolaid guy and eat everything in sight. Now whenever we go up to flagstaff she texts this poor guy at any hour of the day to order pies. Their text thread is getting lengthy
Incredible pies 3 rd time ordering
Food: 5
Service: 4
I came to flagstaff on a short trip . I was looking for a good pie and I found them ! I went to one of the locations were they deliver daily . Coconut and Blueberries đThey are great !!!
The customer service at this business is absolutely unacceptable. My relative had a terrible experience speaking with the owner on the phone. He was rude, dismissive, and claimed he prefers texts over callsâsomething that isnât stated on his website. When she simply asked about leftover pies, he got angry, said orders need to be placed a week ahead, and even used the term âsweetheartâ in an inappropriate tone. Itâs clear that customer care is not a priority here. I wonât be supporting this business.
Service: 1
Iâm not from flagstaff and wanted to try buying a pie. Called to ask how he sells them order ahead or if I could do walk up. He was very rude right away and was shouting through the phone. Then he hung up on me. Not the way to handle a phone call for a business, looks like heâs done that to others too.
Service: 1
We live in Albuquerque and we always buy 6 pies to take home for ourselves and family. The owner is phenomenal!!! Pies too delicious for words.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cherry Pie, Apple Pie, Fresh Pies
I purchased an apple crumb from the local gas station in Flagstaff. When I got home to eat the pie, it had strong aftertastes that were displeasing.
The topping had an almost dish soap aftertaste and the apples had a musty aftertaste. It even smells off. Not a fan đĄ
Food: 1
Recommended dishes: Apple Pie
Not a retail location. I wish the owner would change the location to one of the stations that sells his pies. This address is his house, and when I went there he redirected me to these 5 stores which he stocks:
1. Kachina Villageâs Pic and Run on I 17
2. Mobil at Butler and I 40
3. Silver Saddle on 89 in Doney Park
4. Marathon Station on 4th and 7th
5. Chevron at Highway 180 and Forest
Look for a small stand in the stores with the pies.
The strawberry rhubarb was very good! ?
Food: 5
Delish. Just purchased a peach pie (his fave) for hubby for Dad's Day. Got it at the gas station just down the street. It's wonderful, the crust is light & fluffy & the peachy center is yummy. We don't usually eat the crust when it's heavy, but when you buy Pie Guy's Pies...you can eat the whole thing!
Food: 5
Delish. Just purchased a peach pie (his fave) for hubby for Dad's Day. Got it at the gas station just down the street. It's wonderful, the crust is light & fluffy & the peachy center is yummy. We don't usually eat the crust when it's heavy, but when you buy Pie Guy's Pies...you can eat the whole thing!
Food: 5
I called the Pie Guyâs phone number to inquire about what flavors they had available today.They donât have a store front but operate out of a commercial kitchen and sell in convenience stores.Since I was from Show Low AZ (2 Hours away) I unfortunately couldnât place order for pick up the following morning.I was texted a list of stores that had their pies. I went to a Chevron station right around the corner from my location.I purchased the Chocolate Cream, and the Strawberry Rhubarb pies.The crusts and the fillings were delicious!!My family loves them! They couldnât wait till Motherâs Day to get into them!!?So if youâre ever out and about, stop into these stores and grab a absolute delicious pie!These 4 stores carry our pies:Mobil at Butler and I 40Silver Saddle on 89 in Doney ParkMarathon Station on 4th and 7thChevron at Highway 180 and Forest
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cherry Pie, Apple Pie, Fresh Pies
Restaurantji Recommends
Delicious, excellent crust and fillings! These pies are soooo good! Call and order it for pickup the next day or get it at various convenience stores around Flagstaff AZ. You wonât be disappointed!
Picked up a pie at the gas station across from Little America. Strawberry rhubarb and it was delicious. Definitely will be back to try other flavors.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fresh Pies
We had an amazing lemon meringue pie. Absolutely delicious. We canât wait to try another
Food: 5
Service: 5
Just a text away. Very easy to order and pick up without hassle. Pie was delicious and perfect for my husband's birthday. We tried strawberry rhubarb, which was a first, and we loved it. Will order a pie every time we after in Flagstaff from now
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
we stopped at a gas station and got one of the pies. I thought it tasted really good but my girlfriend went beserk with pie lust. she looked up the other pies that this guy makes and she had to have them. She texted him what pies he had available. He said he could make her any type and I donât know if he does this for everyone or if he knew that she was going to bust through his kitchen wall like the coolaid guy and eat everything in sight. Now whenever we go up to flagstaff she texts this poor guy at any hour of the day to order pies. Their text thread is getting lengthy
Loading...