Toasted Mallow
Customers' Favorites
Menu
Combos
-
Birthday Bash Combo $62.00
Surprise that special someone with a dozen assorted cupcakes (NO SUBSTITUTIONS), comes with 1 birthday candle, 2 birthday toppers, and a choice of 2 pints of ice cream.
Variety Packs
-
6 Pack Variety $23.99
NO SUBSTITUTIONS! Need a quick box of cupcakes? We put together the box of our top sellers. No muss no fuss. If you want specific flavors DON'T PICK THIS OPTION
-
12 Pack Variety $47.00
NO SUBSTITUTIONS! Need a bigger pack? We got you! Our dozen pack will be full of our most amazing flavors that we pick, to satisfy even the pickiest person. If you want specific flavors DON'T PICK THIS OPTION.
Seasonal Cupcakes
-
Pumpkin Cheesecake $3.99
Pumpkin spice cake with a graham cracker bottom, signature cream cheese buttercream, sprinkles and a pumpkin candy. Limited time only.
-
Pumpkin Spice Latte $3.99
Pumpkin cake topped with a coffee buttercream, sprinkled with a spice mix and pumpkin candy.
Rotating Flavors of Yum
-
Hot Fudge Sundae $3.75
Devils food chocolate cake, sweet vanilla buttercream, chocolate drizzle, rainbow sprinkles and a cherry on top. Only available Week 2 of every month.
-
Banana Cream $3.75
Sweet banana cake stuffed with marshmallow fluff and topped with our handmade vanilla buttercream and Nilla Wafer. Only available Week 3 of every month.
Cupcakes
-
Strawberry Cream (aka Pink Cadillac) $3.99
Strawberry cake stuffed with house-made marshmallow fluff and topped with sweet strawberry buttercream and vanilla swirls.
-
Happy Camper $3.99
Chocolate cake with graham cracker crust, filled and topped with homemade marshmallow fluff, toasted and drizzled with chocolate. No fire required.
-
Cookie Butter $3.99
Vanilla cake with a sweet Graham cracker bottom, Biscoff buttercream and topped with a Biscoff cookie.
-
Red Velvet $3.99
Classic red velvet cake topped with a house-made cream cheese frosting and red velvet crumbs. A favorite!
-
Banana Foster $3.99
Sweet banana cake topped with house-made cream cheese frosting and topped with rich caramel and banana chips.
-
Doodah $3.99
Funfetti or vanilla cake topped with vanilla buttercream and covered in rainbow sprinkles.
-
Cookies & Cream $3.99
Rich chocolate cake, topped with our house-made cookies and cream cookie buttercream and, an Oreo cookie.
-
Triple Chocolate $3.99
Made with a rich devil's food cake and chocolate buttercream, a chocolate lover's dream!
-
Chocolate Cheesecake $3.75
Chocolate cake, with a graham cracker crust bottom. Topped with cream cheese buttercream, chocolate sauce, chocolate chips, and more graham cracker crumbs.
-
Cloud 9 $3.99
Vanilla or funfetti cake topped with cotton candy buttercream, fluffy vanilla clouds and a sweet candy rainbow.
-
Very Vanilla $3.99
A classic. Perfectly simple vanilla cake and a house-made vanilla buttercream, sprinkles, and topped with a cherry.
Cake Bites
-
Cake Bite 4 pack Variety $12.00
Cake Bites are handcrafted cakes, dipped in rich chocolates, and offer a variety of deliciously sweet flavors! ( No Substitions )
Seasonal Drinks & Milkshakes
-
Pumpkin Pie Milkshake $8.99
A returning favorite. Blue Bell vanilla ice cream, pumpkin spice and milk. Always topped with our Fluff from Toasted mallow, sprinkles and a candy.
-
Oatmeal Dream shake $8.99
Oatmeal cream pie ice cream topped with fluff from Toasted Mallow, sprinkle of cinnamon sugar and an oatmeal cookie.
Fluffed Up Milkshakes
-
Cookie Butter Milkshake $8.99
Vanilla ice cream is mixed and hand-spun with a scoop of Lotus Biscoff Cookie Butter. This seasonal drink is topped with house-made marshmallow fluff and a Lotus Biscoff cookie. LIMITED TIME.
-
Cookies & Cream Milkshake $8.99
Hand-spun Cookies & Cream ice cream milkshakes with 2 Oreo cookies, Oreo sprinkles and house-made marshmallow fluff. Top favorite!
-
Cookie Monster Milkshake $8.99
Hand-spun Blue Monster ice cream with cookies, cookie dough syrup chocolate, blue candy and house-made marshmallow fluff.
-
Happy Camper Shake $8.99
Hand-spun Vanilla ice cream milkshake with chocolate chips, Ghirardelli chocolate, and Toasted Mallow syrup, topped with graham cracker, and house-made marshmallow fluff.
-
Goofy Goober $8.99
Hand-spun Chocolate Peanut Butter ice cream milkshake with chocolate, peanuts, peanut butter cups, and house-made marshmallow fluff.
-
Pretty Unicorn Milkshake $8.99
Hand-spun Cotton Candy ice cream milkshake, buttercream, candy bits, topped with cotton candy and house-made marshmallow fluff.
-
Happy Unbirthday $8.99
Hand-spun Cake Batter ice cream milkshake with rainbow sprinkles, buttercream and house-made marshmallow fluff.
-
Frozen Hot Chocolate $8.99
Hand-spun Chocolate ice cream milkshake with swirls of Ghirardelli chocolate and hot chocolate mix, topped with house-made marshmallow fluff.
-
Bam Bam Milkshake $8.99
Hand-spun Strawberry ice cream milkshake, Fruity Pebbles cereal and a scoop of house-made marshmallow fluff.
Frozen Drinks
-
Lava Flow $5.99
Frozen lemonade topped mixed and topped with strawberry puree and a scoop of house-made marshmallow fluff.
-
Gimmie S'mores $5.99
Vanilla coffee frappe, vanilla bean marshmallow fluff, chocolate syrup and graham cracker crumbs.
-
Frozen S'mores Mocha $5.99
Ice, costa rican cold brew coffee, hot cocoa mix, toasted marshmallow syrup and whole milk. All blended together in a frosty frap. Topped with vanilla bean marshmallow whip and a chocolate drizzle.
-
Frozen Rican Chata $5.99
Costa rican cold brew blended with ice and horchata. Topped with vanilla bean marshmallow whip and cinnamon sugar.
-
Frozen Chai $5.99
Frozen chai and whole milk topped with vanilla bean marshmallow whip and cinnamon sugar.
-
Frozen Mocha $5.99
Ice, costa rican cold brew coffee, hot cocoa mix, and whole milk. All blended together in a frosty frap. Topped with vanilla bean marshmallow whip.
-
Frozen Caramel Mocha $5.99
Ice, costa rican cold brew coffee, hot cocoa mix, caramel syrup and whole milk. All blended together in a frosty frap. Topped with vanilla bean marshmallow whip and caramel drizzle.
Cold Brew Coffee
-
S'mores Mocha Cold Brew $5.99
Organic Costa Rican cold brew coffee, toasted marshmallow syrup, chocolate sauce, and whole milk. Topped with vanilla bean marshmallow fluff, chocolate drizzle and graham cracker dust.
-
Vanilla Mocha Cold Brew $5.99
Organic Costa Rican cold brew coffee, vanilla syrup, chocolate sauce, and whole milk. Topped with whip cream and a chocolate drizzle.
-
Caramel Mocha Cold Brew $5.99
Organic Costa Rican cold brew coffee, caramel syrup, chocolate sauce, and whole milk. Topped with whip cream and a caramel drizzle.
Ala Carte
-
Two Homemade Marshmallow Brookies $9.00
Homemade vanilla bean marshmallow fluff, between 2 homemade Brookies (Cookie + Brownie).
Bottled Beverages
-
Bottle Water $2.00
-
Coca Cola $2.50
S'more
-
Cookie Monster $5.99
Vanilla bean marshmallow toasted and snug between two chocolate chip cookies and chocolate.
Recent Reviews
It was wonderful to chat with you Trisha!
I’ll be back for that unBirthday cake shake real soon!! Thank you!