Brother's Pizza

I'm writing this review because I want to warn everyone about Sheena Saiti, she is the manager of this store. She also does hair at Avanti Salon. Well I was one of her hair clients and we became friends. About a year or so ago she asked me if I would co sign on a vehicle for her as her only vehicle broke down and was going to cost alot to fix. I agreed to co sign for her because I truly thought that she would do right by me. Well guess what....she didn't! She made the 1st four payments and then nothing after...she didn't notify me at anytime about this. The car went into default and the bank repossessed the vehicle. The bank has since auctioned off the vehicle and now there is a $19,000 balance in collections and she will not take my call nor will she respond to my text messages. She has made no attempt in contacting the bank to resolve this balance. So, because of her bad decisions (gambling and drug addictions), she has once screwed another so called friend over. I recently found out that she has been evicted from her place of residence prior to where she is now and she has been taken to court for eviction for her current residence. The power has been shut off several times at this restaurant and employees have had their paychecks bounce. I wish I had known all of this prior to making the decision to help her out. So just want to give anyone that may come in contact with her or she trys to friend you and asks you to help her financially...here's what you will deal with....Be careful who you trust. I've definitely learned a hard lesson.

3 pies , Peppers and onion,white,and plain.
All large 16 inch ordered.
Shocked to see size of each pie when opening boxes, looked like maybe 14 inches,at best.

All 3 looked like the cheapest ingredients were used. Very unappetizing appearance.

The full peppers and onion pie for $18.50 looked like the plain pie, saw maybe 3 or 4 small pieces of
f peppers, onions were invisible.
Terrible taste. never again !

White pie,$26.00 small and very poor taste,way overpriced
Plain pie again small, and cost $18.50! Never Again

Classic case of Shrinkflation, terrible pies at extremely high priced.

Still on search for New Jersey , size,taste and prices in AZ.

This experience will make me never come to this pizza place again...3 large pies for $73.00 is nuts.

I really like everything about this place.

Too bad about whatever has happened to this place I am legally blind and can't driveronce in awhile I get a craving for good Italian food so I will order their spaghetti and meatballs and I love a good meatball sub so I spring for Uber eats occasionally and get it delivered all the way to Peoria! As I did today and received a meatball sub that was so dang hard even my 80 lb dog wouldn't take a bite out of the bun just dropped it on the ground burnt black hard as a damn Rock any manager who would let food like that go out the door to a customer better back up to get his pay anyway after years of enjoying their delicious Italian food they have seen the last of my dollars I cannot believe anyone would let food like that go out the door to a customer fortunately there are more Italian restaurants around here so I will live without them

Bit pricey, but Sheena took care of my soggy pizza with a smile. Tasted great, but center was soggy. Endless soda! Small bar/pizza joint. Friendly staff! Oh, went in a bit late, no problem hot fresh pizza!

I'm a pizza enthusiast, and it pains me to give pizza spots bad reviews. But an hour to get a pizza order was for sure not what I was expecting for a dining room that only had one other couple on a Sunday afternoon. Pizza (Sicilian) definitely not, very underwhelming. Perhaps having a slice in person changes this, but I strongly doubt it.

If you love your pizza burnt so well that you can’t eat the crust then this is the place for you! We’ve eaten here before and it was great! But having just ordered through Slice tonight provided feedback it was burnt and photos but we were told the restaurant says there’s no way it was burnt and it was cooked perfectly according to their standards! We weren’t even asking for anything just letting them know. Guess we won’t be back then!

Great pizza and wings;)

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

I’ve been going here since 2016 and its been exceptional consistently.
The pizza and wings are phenomenal. The people who work there are always in amazing moods and are always great conversations. The atmosphere is a lot like a small town where everyone knows everyone. The vast majority of people i’ve seen come here for the first time I constantly see back.
I’m a semi truck driver as of the past year and I’ve gone to several pizza places all across the United States and Brothers Pizza is by FAR the best pizza, bar NONE.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza

Got 2 Large pizza for lunch, first time coming here we took the pizza to go and when we started eating it it just taste burnt and it was very burnt on the crust, next time we will be choosing a different pizza place

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 2

The crew gets 5 stars!
The pizza and wings are good!
Affordable prices! It’s A must try!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Service sucked took us half hour to get anything and there was nobody in there except for us. We went in for lunch

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 2

Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza

The service was great on our takeout order but the pizza and salads were stunningly bad. The crust was hard and chewy. The salad was the saddest pile of yellowing lettuce and toppings. I really wanted to like this place and support local business but I honestly cannot recommend the food.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 5

Been eating there for 10 years. The last 3 years, they suck! Pizza is gross and wings are small and way overpriced!

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 2

Service: 1

Delicious pizza every time and their sizes are perfect, not like the chain pizza joints with a large being small they are the best on this side of town

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5