Brooklyn New York Pizza & Wings I

5965 E Brown Rd, Mesa
(480) 474-4949

Recent Reviews

Raul Perez

Couldn't get any service for 20 mins & of course my order was already ready just sitting there. Hope to never return to this place.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Gordon Bond

Ordered delivery & it was a disaster. Never

Food: 3

Service: 1

LLucky Red Beard

It's inside a gas station, I ordered a slice. They make the slice and then cook it, the dough was average, sauce was as well, the pizza overall is ok. But I wouldn't go out of my way to go

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 4

John Corona

Tasty pizza

S Keith

Family loves this pizza. I believe it has changed ownership (menus are all different, different layout and "feel"), or at least the folks behind the counter are not the same group as before. Prior crew was really on top of things, and the only complaint I had was the price... it's a little more spendy than I like.Quality also seems to be variable. Bake quality is less consistent, and sauce quantity is variable - often a little too much.I want to caution against the use of Slice app for ordering. I would regularly order through Slice with the old crew, and every order went perfectly - ready when stated, etc.The first slice order with the new crew: showed up about 5 minutes after the "it's ready" notification, and it was still in the oven. No biggie to wait a few minutes - though it was 8-10 minutes overdue.Yesterday was the second order with the new crew. I ordered expecting to pick it up on the way home. Got there a few minutes after the "it's ready" notification... Not only was it not in the oven, it was not even made yet. I waited almost 15 minutes.I have a feeling that they just aren't watching for when those orders come in, and the ~15 minute ready time is just a default.I only give 1 star (will never go again) or 5 star (will go again) reviews unless there are odd circumstances. This place gets 5 stars - for now. I will go back. Bake and build quality needs to get back to where it was before the new ownership/crew, or it's down to 1 star, and I'll go save a bunch of money at Pizza-Pizza for less enjoyable, but more consistent pie.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 3

Felipe

Busy, but great ambience!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

Michael A.

This place is in a gas station and immediately that pushed most away, don't let it be the reason you miss out on a great pizza. This was my first time trying it out and when we got there the owner was so friendly and excited to see me walk in had my food ready to go quickly and it smelled great. I ordered a medium half pepperoni jalapeño half margarita and fried zucchini. The fried zucchini was crispy and honestly better than most places I've had I gave it a solid 9/10. The pizza had a lot of flavor and crust was crispy. I will be coming back for sure. Eat local and give them a try.

Kirsten Kavanaugh

Favorite place on this side of town. I always see 1 guy running the entire kitchen. Quick and well made food! I love the honey hot wings the most.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Bone in Chicken Wings, Meat Lovers Pizza, Antipasto Salad

Spooky Da scary

Went there on Christmas day and it was busy as hell just 3 guys busting their balls while people where waiting in line and not only did I not wait a long time the food was amazing, flavorful, and gas I would 100% cone back and eat again any day of the week.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Mozzarella Sticks, Mild Wings, Cheese Pizza

Daniel “Superman”

Wow this place is amazing I walked into the gas station and found this place the food was so good I cannot wait to go back.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Authentic New York Pizza, Mild Wings

Nic Hu

Perfect BBQ pizza !!!!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Bone in Chicken Wings, Buffalo Chicken Pizza, Meat Lovers Pizza, Cheese Pizza

Jon T

Excellent pizza, really nice new

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Kimberly A Olson

We had a pizza & garlic bread. Great food & great people. We will definitely be back to try the all you can eat special!

Darlene Reyes

I ordered online, it was a very seamless and straight forward process. I got their lasagna pie in their largest size along with 24 wings and it took about 25 minutes. They had a driveway but it was no longer in service. The gas station attendant was tending to someone outside for 10 minutes and locked the doors to the entry, a little hangry I called the store direct and the gentleman was very polite and pleasant, picked up right away and then opened the door for me to gave me my order. It was hot and ready when I arrived and delicious to enjoy. I know the food industry doesn't get the credit they deserve from the public most of them time so I wanted to take the time to say thank you for the great food polite service and for being a go-to local spot for my friends and family to eat.

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Bone in Chicken Wings, Lasagna Pizza

Alice Reed

This place is in a gas station, which isn't a problem, but makes it hard to find. You have to ring the bell at the front to wake up the guy who's supposed to be making your order and then he says 10 mins and makes you wait over 30. Was better when they had actual staff and a better owner.Would not recommend, just go to little Ceasars

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Load More

Brooklyn New York Pizza & Wings I

5965 E Brown Rd, Mesa, AZ 85205
(480) 474-4949