Brooklyn New York Pizza & Wings I
$ • Pizza, Chicken WingsAbout Brooklyn New York Pizza & Wings I
Customers' Favorites
Authentic New York Pizza
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Bone in Chicken Wings
Pizza with Mushrooms
Meat Lovers Pizza
Mozzarella Sticks
NY Supreme Pizza
Antipasto Salad
Pepperoni Pizza
Lasagna Pizza
Recent Reviews
192 ratings
Share your opinion about Brooklyn New York Pizza & Wings I
Best pizza and wings I have had in Arizona. Quality ingredients used and great service. This is mostly a carry out restaurant because it is inside the Chevron gas station but don’t let that deter you fantastic food.
We had a pizza & garlic bread. Great food & great people. We will definitely be back to try the all you can eat special!
Just had the all-you-can-eat deal for Sunday lunch. Excellent food and superb service. All at very reasonable prices. We shall return!!
Hours
| Monday | 11:30AM - 9:45PM |
| Tuesday | 11:30AM - 9:45PM |
| Wednesday | 11:30AM - 9:45PM |
| Thursday | 11:30AM - 9:45PM |
| Friday | 11:30AM - 9:45PM |
| Saturday | 11:30AM - 9:45PM |
| Sunday | 11:30AM - 9:45PM |
Brooklyn New York Pizza & Wings offers delivery and take-out services. The restaurant, located inside a gas station, is known for its pizza made in a pizza oven with great ingredients. Customers often praise the wings, especially noting they are the best for miles, even from Buffalo. The owner, from Brooklyn, takes pride in everything he creates. The pizza by the slice can be customized, and the food is considered very good with super fresh ingredients. While the dough and sauce were described as average, a recent 10” pepperoni pie was praised for its perfectly proofed dough, medium toasted crust, and ideal portions of cheese and pepperoni, making it one of the best in town.
The previous crew was praised for their efficiency, but the current team's performance has been inconsistent, with orders through the Slice app sometimes delayed. A recent visit noted that the place gets very busy, and quality issues have appeared after ownership changes. Some customers expressed concerns about sanitation, food handling, and personal cleanliness, especially when seeing the staff through the restaurant's large window. Despite these issues, the pizza remains enjoyable, and many still find the pepperoni to be the best in town.
Customers also shared that waiting times can be longer than expected, so scheduling an order an hour ahead is recommended. Overall, Brooklyn New York Pizza & Wings is a place with a strong reputation for good wings and pizza, with hopes that the quality and consistency will improve to match the original standards. The quest for the perfect pie continues for many regulars.