Smitholator Cookie Shop

124 W Main St, Mesa
(480) 529-4498

Recent Reviews

Lynn Coutee

I have known the owner, Heather, for years. Sad to read that she closed the shop ? but so glad to hear that she is still baking and taking orders for all the great customers!! ? ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Arizona Cookies, Sugar Cookie Dough, Cookie Decorating Kit, Halloween Cookie Decorating, Decorated Cookies, S’Mores Cookie Dough, Sugar Cookies

Beth Colley

We've taken 2 cookie classes & plan on taking more. Heather is helpful & makes the class fun.

Patricia Williams

This was my first cookie decorating class. It has been on my bucket list for a while. This class definitely did not disappoint. The instructor did a fantastic job and we were allowed to decorate six cookies. No question was off-limits. I had a fantastic experience and definitely plan to return. I would like to take her cookie 101 class. Highly recommended. ?

Diana Villarin

Took a cookie decorating class with Heather, and it was so much fun! She's a great teacher, and walked us through all her tips and tricks. Plus, everything tasted fantastic, too! SUPER worth it, will have to come back for the baking classes!

Ashley S.

Did a class on the weekend here and it was so much fun! Awesome set up and instructor was good at explaining/giving directions.

Vanessa Fettig

Took a cookie making class and it was so amazing! We had the best time.

Grace

Love their chocolate chip cookies. Best I have had in a while (if ever ?). Only thing I hate is their very INCONSISTENT store pickup and delivery hours. You never really know when you can order.

Chad Hutchins

Such a fun time learning to decorate holiday cookies!! Excellent teacher who loves her job! I will forever eat homemade cookies with more respect... this was not easy!!

Debbie Darling

Such a fun family time project. A variety of cookie kits to choose from for every season! And, yummy! Thank you Heather for the excellent service.

Jennifer Dugan

I took one of the cookie decorating classes and loved it. Instruction was great and easy to follow. It was my first decorating class and my cookies came out so much better than I expected. You learn skills you can do at home. Also shares cookie and icing recipe.

Jenny Gault

We attended a cookie decorating class there and loved it! The instructor was great and the cookies came out so cute!

Summer Novelle

I recently ordered a large order of cookies about a week before I needed them for an event. Heather replied very quickly, was so kind and even offered to have the cookies couriered to make sure I got them on time. The cookies came individually wrapped and in perfect condition. They were beautiful, everyone loved them and asked where I got them. Will definitely order again when I have another event!!

Nicole L.

Amazing experience with Heather. She had great ideas for mermaid cookies for my daughters 6th birthday. They looked fantastic and tasted delicious! Will definitely be back.

Lisa C.

Yummy tasting cookies and beautifully decorated. They were a hit at our engagement party. We had a slight issue with the order and they handled it immediately, even sending a courier out with the cookies so I did not have to drive back. Will definitely be a return customer.

Grace Akeeh

Love their chocolate chip cookies. Best I have had in a while (if ever ?). Only thing I hate is their very INCONSISTENT store pickup and delivery hours. You never really know when you can order.

Load More