By the Bucket

319 AZ-260, Payson
(928) 451-0061

Recent Reviews Order Online Reserve

Customers' Favorites

Bucket of Meatballs and Spaghetti
Meatball or Italian Sausage
Bread Puddings Tiramisu
Spaghetti and Meatballs
Family Bucket Feeds 3-5
Full Loaf Garlic Bread
Middle Bucket Feeds 2
Meatball Sandwich
Marinara - 8 Oz
Meatball Sub

Menu

Featured items
Small Bucket
Half a pound of pasta with sauce, with three slices of Garlic Bread
Middle Bucket
One pound of pasta with sauce, with 1/4 loaf of Garlic Bread
Meatball
Signature blend of Italian spices, aged cheese, and select cuts of pork & beef
Family Bucket
One and a half pounds of pasta with sauce, with 1/2 loaf of Garlic Bread
Full Loaf of Garlic Bread
Full Loaf of fresh baked bread with house made garlic spread, toasted to order
Half Load of Garlic Bread
Half Loaf of fresh baked bread with house made garlic spread, toasted to order
Cheesy Bread
Half loaf of toasted garlic bread smothered with mozzarella cheese

Pasta
Family Bucket
One and a half pounds of pasta with sauce, with 1/2 loaf of Garlic Bread
Middle Bucket
One pound of pasta with sauce, with 1/4 loaf of Garlic Bread
Small Bucket
Half a pound of pasta with sauce, with three slices of Garlic Bread

Protein
Meatball
Signature blend of Italian spices, aged cheese, and select cuts of pork & beef

Sandwiches
Meatball Sub
3 Meatballs, marinara sauce, and melted mozzarella cheese, served on a lightly toasted roll
Stretch Meatball Sub
4 Meatballs and Extra Cheese

Sides
Cheesy Bread
Half loaf of toasted garlic bread smothered with mozzarella cheese
Half Load of Garlic Bread
Half Loaf of fresh baked bread with house made garlic spread, toasted to order
Extra Sauce
8 ounces of our signature sauce *Available only with spaghetti bucket purchase.
Full Loaf of Garlic Bread
Full Loaf of fresh baked bread with house made garlic spread, toasted to order

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: facebook
Photo credit: facebook
+34 photos
Photo credit: facebook
+33 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

We stopped in when we were passing through Payson and had a late lunch. The meatball (stretch)sandwich was fantastic, so flavorful and fresh. It was perfect for my husband and I to split.
July 2025
My wife and I absolutely LOVE this place! We got the meatball Monday special (5 for 4 - $8) and some marinara to go with our two Chicken Parmesan sandwiches and two Caesar Salads. EVERYTHING was outstanding! The marinara is perfect and did not give me indigestion like some marinara sauces can. The meatballs are very good and addictive. The salads were very fresh and had a really nice balance of ingredients and you get a nice portion. The chicken parmesan sandwiches were so very...
January 2025
Went in around Christmas time and got a bucket for the family! A very nice young man was at the front named Reagan. Super responsible and respectful. Such great customer service! Will definitely continue supporting their business.
January 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Starbucks - 401 AZ-260
Coffee Shops, Coffee & Tea, Coffee
Jimmy John's - 303 AZ-260
Sandwich Shop, Fast Food
Jack in the Box - 301 AZ-260
Fast Food, Burgers, Tacos

By the Bucket

319 AZ-260, Payson, AZ 85541
(928) 451-0061