Fabio On Fire | Panini & Gelateria

24775 N Lake Pleasant Pkwy, Peoria
(623) 238-3664

Recent Reviews

J

Great place to get a Margherita pie and a capacinoo only thing I would say tho is they should make the capacinoo bigger it's very small

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Richard Savino

Fantastic authentic Italian......

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Half Panini

David Rodriguez

Love it here. Always great food and service!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jon D

Split a Panini not bad. Order at the counter. No drink refills. All and all not bad.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 3

Wanda Henson

Chef Fabio literally never misses, and he hasn’t missed here. The paninis, the gelato, the tiramisu and the diplomatico are all stupidly good. I’m begging you not to sleep on this place.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Andrea Cortes

We love going to the original location for dinner and this location for lunch. It’s more of a relaxed environment with the options of a sand which or gelato. They also do sell imported meat by the pound and fresh bread when they have extras! I also love that the gelato flavors are always changing so you can always try new ones. I always get the piccante sand which if you like spicy this is the one to try!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Brittany

"Fabio on Fire might be the best Italian food I have ever had outside of my own kitchen"- My 85 year old Italian Grandma (Feom Sicily who made everything from scratch)"I agree"- My 87 year old Italian ex Chef Grandfather

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Shelly K.

Our second time visiting and we loved it! The first time we ordered to go and wished we had dined in. This time we grabbed some friends and enjoyed the no-nonsense atmosphere to sit and visit for dinner and dessert! Even though they were busy, our server was kind, friendly, and outgoing. We ordered the pear salad and a couple of different paninis, and they were great. The bread was incredible, and the spicy salami was amazing. Would never have imagined partnering some of the ingredients in the way they do but it was so flavorful and in huge quantity. I was also impressed with the bright, clean environment and the freshness of the food. A sit on the patio is perfect in the evenings, but you miss a bit of the great smells from inside. Go for the bread, stay for the gelato!

Kristen Michelle

I got the caprese salad and a pear salad. The tomato was gross. It was old and had no flavor, light drizzle of balsamic. No basil. The pear on the salad wasn't ripe yet and there was barely any dressing on it. Small salad. Both were $10 each, but worth maybe $4. Disappointed.

David Berg

Gross. Can’t believe that’s what I am writing but that’s how I felt after I ate half of my sandwich. Gooey, gummy, no distinctive taste. Way too much $$ for a panini, even if it had been good. Go back and start over on this idea, Fabio. Or stick to your other - very good - restaurant.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 2

Service: 5

Smk27 M.

I've tried the panini and now a dessert, 100% disappointing for both. I find it hard to believe all these 5 star reviews are real. I suggest you all try it and the. Post your true review... there's no way you'll not agree.

Kevin L.

Ok. The food I think is pretty good. It's hard to say because my panini was cold by the time they got my wife's out and hers was burnt. Crumbled when she tried to take a bite. This place is slow, slow, slow. The service is so bad. And the real annoying thing is they don't seem to care. When I finally got my wife's order, it was burnt. I said something and the girl just stared at me. Didn't send it back, they were just too slow for regular orders, I figured a messed up order would have completely confused them. Not going back to this place. Way too many other places that have good service in the area.

Kari F.

Fresh food, great options. We love ordering for a quick dinner and don't forget the amazing gelato! Absolute best!

Jason Butcher

Amazing quality and value.

Adam S.

First time in. It's been awhile since I've tasted something so authentic. I was sold after the first bite. Tried the Donna Di Cuori - could taste all of the flavors and I was happy there was more arugula than the meat. I'll be back to try other flavors of sandwiches and the gelato.

Load More