Mary's Mountain Cookies

9784 W Northern Ave Suite 1250, Peoria
(623) 440-8841

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Jennifer “Jenni”

I love the oreo cookie omg!! I will definitely come back again!

Fawn “Gigglz” Cozad

Found Mary’s on Date Night 🥰
Peanut Butter cookie lovers
Reese’s cup lovers
Oreo cookie lovers
Sprinkles, chocolate chip lovers.
Everything is amazing!! 🤩
Took my granddaughters and they thought they were the softest and delicious cookies ever and still soft after two day. They are BIG cookies 🤭

Todd Yates

Thoroughly impressed with quality and the absolute deliciousness of these cookies.

Saint Geneviede

My work had bought some of their cookies, the Red Velvet and Oatmeal Pie cookies are delicious! Fluffy, not to sweet (just perfect) and the size for them is great. You can also still refigerate them (I did this with my oatmeal cookie since I wasn't going to eat it till later) and it still stayed fresh and didn't get hard, glad to be a new customer c: I would have pictures but I devoured them.

Jennifer Giralo

My favorite spot for cookies. They are the best.

Gary Johnson

There's no greater value in the cookie game than Mary's Mountain! Great cookies @ a fair price! These cookies won't leave you in crumbles 😉, but rather wanting more😋. Customer service has always been great the numerous times I've been in. Very consistent on all fronts.

Alexander Millan

I've been coming to Marys Mountains cookies for a while and I can honestly say that these cookies are way better than crumbl cookies. Amazing service as well.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Lauryn Ellstrom

Very kind ladies working! The bakery was so cutely decorated for the season, super clean , inviting , and smelt so delicious! They had such a wide variety and even had gluten free and dairy free options !!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

O J

Not great but not horrible either. Honestly the baked cookies you can buy from QT or Circle K taste better and cost less. I’m not a baker by any means but I’m assuming it has to do with the key ingredients used. If you want to spend this about of money go to crumble instead.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 5

Barbara Hickman

DELICIOUS 🍪 cookies!

Atmosphere: 5

Chanell Sourp

Best cookies ever!!! We love the oatmeal pie, chocolate chip, M&Ms, peanut butter cup and s'mores cookies the best! Their deal is amazing too!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: S'More, Various Cookies, Brownie Cookies

James Reas

We got square cookies, and they were as good as the round ones at a third of the price. You guys are awesome!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Richard Grala

Fantastic cookie shop, the price is worth it for the mere size and quality you are getting. Has a great home baked feeling.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Eddie Martinez

Immediately walking in I was greeting by some workers making cookies. I seen the chocolate chip cookies and said they were too thick. I bought one anyway and was slapped in the face with a chewy crispy goodness that they managed to get all the way through that thickness. A perfect balance of sweetness and savory. The chocolate chips matched all the way around and did not over due with chocolate.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jerome Barnes

Best cookies in the valley and great service

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...