Papa Johns Pizza

25101 N Lake Pleasant Pkwy, Peoria
(623) 572-7373

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Adolfo Martinez

Saturday, August 30th at 11:30am, I walked in to pick up my online order and the lady making the pizzas was vaping. I called her out on it and she admitted, and apologized. I threw my pizzas and wings away, disgusted. Lost out on $80 tip included. NEVER going back there again!!

Megan Johnson

This location always delivers everything cooked to perfection with the upmost care! I will always make a point to come to this Papa John's over other locations.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

J B

This truly is the worst pizza location EVER. Not the worst papa John's, the worst pizza restaurant out of all the restaurants ever 🤣 the level of incompetence is unparalleled. When we called about our issues, the manager offered credit for next time. We really were not going to use it, but it was free and we succumbed to free pizza. STILL CRAP!! LOL I warn you now, ANY 5 star review commenting on excellent service or food is a LIE!! They're just trying to get ratings back up by having friends/family leave good reviews because they are TERRIBLE. GO ANYWHERE ELSE

Ashley Trojanek

This is how my pizza just showed up. Not even sure what is going on here. Half the cheese is missing on a CHEESE pizza and it’s cut all kind of ways. This location sucks and we will not order from them ever again. Not sure how they are still in business. This is not the first time we have gotten a screwed up order but this is definitely the worst one. Let’s not get started on the breadsticks 😒

Nikki Peery

We just got 5 pizzas and a papadia for our Kids Christmas party they had at our house! We love papa John’s pizza it’s our favorite go to but lately it hasn’t been the best we seem to keep having some sort of issue every time we come into this location. We have never tried the papadia before we when we got home we opened the box and it was burnt, hard and it looked like it had been tossed in the box.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 3

Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza

Hussein Gawad

After ordering from this location today because I was in the area I learned why the rating is only three stars. I placed an order for pickup and didn't arrive to pick it up until 30 minutes after it was finished. They made no attempt to keep the pizza warm. They didn't put it on a warming shelf. They did nothing besides hand me a cold pizza. Definitely don't order from this location. Don't do it. Just save yourself the headache.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Jason Nichols

Nothing like waiting 2 hours for a cold pizza and dry, cold breadsticks. Also the wrong soda. Just unreal...

Food: 2

Service: 1

Dee Bo

Tall guy with the braids deserves a raise.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

AudioAcorn 22

Waited nearly 3 hours for my order, and it arrived cold. Very disappointing experience.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Todd Clark

Got the all meats pizza. Definitely a favorite of mine

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Ro Grin

I ordered the Papa John’s New York style pizza for $10.99. I went in and ordered, and picked it up. The box had a message stating that delivery fees were not tips for your driver. The message went on to exclaim “please tip your driver generously for excellent service”. The pizza WAS NOT New York style. The crust was twice as thick as a NY STYLE PIZZA and the pizza lacked flavor. Little sauce, little cheese. In conclusion, anyone who had an NYT style slice will be disappointed. Hey Papa, do it right or don’t do it all.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 3

Elena Koone

Delivery was almost an hour, arrived cold, barely any toppings on it. Last time I order pizza

Food: 2

Service: 2

Politics is lit m8

Everything was cold the pizza wasn’t really good at all the wings were pretty bad as well the jalapeño bites were ok but never ordering from here again

Food: 1

Lukiano

This is just unbelivable, order a pizza 20 months ago, and had to wait another 20 minutes in the shop, this is just lack of respect for people’s time!!

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Claudia Cabrera

Y'all need to teach your drivers to not place our pizza on the dang floor!!! its not 2020, there's no reason why they cant deliver to our door. And then they have the nerve to get a tip! DO BETTER! Do yourself a favor future customers and dont order from this location. Careless service.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 4

Service: 1

Loading...