Stevies Pizza Vistancia

I ordered dinner for my family and me, which was 2 pizzas, garlic bread, and 10 boneless wings. I ordered online, and it said the order would be done in 35 minutes. We arrived a bit early so we went in to get drinks at the Safeway next to the restaurant. We shop around for a bit and then go into Stevie’s to pickup the order.

At this point it’s about 50 minutes since we ordered and I was told the order was not ready. I asked the eldest employee on staff tonight (06/07/2025) if they were running behind and she told me that the order just didn’t print out for them. This was a bold faced lie because I saw the young girl at the front bring my pizzas out before she noticed the garlic bread and boneless wings were not prepared. They then started making these items, where we had to wait with a car full of kids for another 10 minutes. They finished the order bagged it up and tied it. I checked the pizzas and they were fine so we went on our way.

We got home, sat down to eat and when we opened the wings they were completely opposite of what we ordered. They gave us traditional bone-in wings instead of boneless. I assume this happened because they were scrambling due to being so late on the order already. When called all they could do is credit us a 10 pc boneless wing for our next trip to them.

My family will be taking our business to Barros or Vs tap room for good pizza from now on.

Ordered Gluten free pizza and they gave us a reagular.

WOW!!! What an amazing experience and the food was fantastic. Let’s start with the pizza. The toppings you could tell were fresh and had tons of flavor. The sauce reminded me of my Nonna’s. A little sweet but not too much. The crust was crispy and the overall bake was perfect. The meatball sub was great as well. The meatballs were tender and the roll was toasted just right so it could hold up to the sauce and cheese. My wife had the pasta with vodka sauce and chicken. She is very picky with vodka sauce and she loved it. Of course we couldn’t leave without a sweet treat. The cannoli was spectacular. If I could give more stars I would. As for the experience, Violeta and Brianna made sure we were taken care of. Their customer service is second to none and I will remember it for a long time. Another worker named Andrit was hustling, bringing out food with a smile. You now have a loyal customer.

Excellent NY style pizza.

I like the New York style. The food and atmosphere is great. I have been coming here for more than 15 years … I always get the white pizza…the pizza is great and the sandwiches are delicious. The white pizza is the only way I to make them. I worked in a New York pizzeria and I was told this is the only way. Everything thing else is terrible. I live in Gilbert,Az and this location is in vistancia,Az . Northwest Peoria,Az 40 miles from my home.

This is the 2nd time that we have eaten at this establishment and my entire family has gotten food poisoning. Working in the food industry for over 10 years and the medical industry the symptoms of food poisoning are completely different than a tummy bug which they kept saying that this was happening. They kept saying we were the very first people to report on this also. No we are just the first people who have the guts to call out an establishment for contaminated food. This has apparently been talked about in the community multiple times of people warning to not eat here. I will send a health inspector over for a suprise visit and then they can See what happens. He was very rude about the entire situation as well. We will absolutely NOT ever be going back there. Also I will be spreading to the word to the community to go elsewhere.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Great food and great service. Always clean inside. Perfect visit every time.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Called and ordered a x-large meat pizza and wings. Was told it was gonna take 90 minutes. I’m cool with that because it is Halloween. Drove there to get my order and it wasn’t ready and it was never received. Employees tried to blame me saying I didn’t call there. I showed them on my phone that I called and spoke to someone and they confirmed. After a while bunched of running around , I left without my order. I’m more upset on how they spent more time trying to blame me instead of realizing they made the mistake. Anyways, I wont be patronizing this establishment any further. Hope another pizza place gets put in over by the Fry’s super market.

Terrible food. This place was recommended by someone on Facebook as a good New York style pizza so we tried it. It's probably top 5 worst pizza I've had. Easily the worst salad. It's just ICEBERG LETTUCE! With the cheapest toppings thrown on it. For $7! Absolutely disgusting. My husband is a human garbage disposal and he said "this pizza's not even worth eating the next day". And the "dressing is not even worth saving". It's the equivalent of Peter Piper maybe. The bread knots were okay and the marinara sauce was decent, but man oh man, how are people recommending this place as excellent New York style pizza?

Food: 1

Excellent service, great food

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Great pizza friendly local pizza place

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots, Pizza by the Slice

In a word EXCELLENT!

I like stopping in for the lunch special. The pizza is good and the staff is friendly.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Several times I have tried to get some food from here after work, and several times this place has been closed hours before the posted closing time, sometimes they are closed at 7PM and sometimes they are closed by 8PM but I've yet to see them actually close at the posted 9PM closing time. This is misleading and very rude to the customers, I will make sure to let others in the neighborhood know to not order from here and to order Barros instead as it is better quality and more realiable.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 3

Service: 1

Drive all the way from Surprise today, just to get some good pizza! It was great!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5