The Sicilian Butcher

9780 W Northern Ave Suite 1100, Peoria
(623) 471-5771

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Christine Teague

Amazing service, best canolis

MATTHEW ROBERT URICK

A beautiful balance of bold and comforting.

Bryan Ford

I spent $115 on two plates and two drinks with an $18 tip. All I tasted was tomato paste and a ton of salt and pepper that I added to it didn’t even mask the overpowering taste of tomato paste, the cheese they used was store-bought sliced cheese Not even enough Parmesan to please a guy that likes cheese. I’ll never return. The food is terrible especially for the price. I am very furious at how much they charged me.

Jadamz598

Destiny was so great and very friendly! Super polite and sweet.

Claire B

Destiny was awesome and so helpful! She was efficient and polite. Cannolis were delicious

gabriella celaya

Great experience here at the Sicilian baker and restaurant! Destiny was a great help and very kind!

Ethan Yi

Destiny was lovely and patient with our experience and helped us throughout our selection process!

Donna Askew

Flora’s Salad was fresh, flavorful & great portion. The manager offered me a taste of their new upcoming kale-apple salad & it was fantastic!
The bakery has the best Italian Wedding cookies that I e had in a very long time! Great service in both restaurant & bakery!

Ligia Coman

We enjoy coming here every time. Manager Jason is always around and greeting customers. We especially enjoy the bakery after our pizza here.

D R

No bad. But really if you are not Italian. Don’t do Italian food. Won’t work

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 1

Annie Terhaar

Food was pretty good overall. The meatball Ferris wheel was fun and a great way to try a lot of different dishes. Teneka was great and very attentive.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Meatball Ferris Wheel

Christina Mayes

Amazing Italian restaurant! The service was top notch and the food was wonderful. Got the pick 4 bruschetta for an appetizer and it did not disappoint, it’s sliced already and easy to share. I got the meatball ferris wheel and my husband got the build your own meatball dish. The wheel was very cool and all the meatballs were tasty. We also got the mini cannoli ferris wheel for dessert and two cappuccinos. The cappuccinos came with two sugar cubes and a cookie. It was a great experience and definitely recommend for anyone looking for a nice date night spot.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Bakery, Cannoli, Meatball Ferris Wheel, Bruschetta

Marcella Grondahl

It was the best wedge salad I’ve ever had wonderful restaurant wonderful atmosphere wonderful server. We will be back and bring our husbands. Teneka was awesome!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Gina Scola

Jason And staff are so accommodating and pleasant period the food is fantastic and You must at the Sicilian Baker afterwards for dessert!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Robert Brooks Jr

Such a lovely atmosphere and absolutely delicious food. The variety of meatballs, variety of sauces, variety of pastas to accompany the appetizers. The seamless service. Ask for Tanika. She will make your experience wonderful. Returning again very soon!

Loading...