My Slice of the Pie Pizzeria - Arcadia (Catering Available)

We order their pizza on the regular for our clinic. The pizza is delicious and has never let us down. The only bad thing is I live too far and can’t have this for dinner on the weekend. Best pizza spot ever!!

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza

I had really high hopes for this pizza, especially given the $35 price point for a pie. We gave it another try after a not-so-great experience a few years back, but the flavor still fell a little short for us. This time we ordered a more traditional option with sausage and meatballs instead of their well-known Al Pastor pizza. The toppings just didn’t stand out, and the sausage tasted very similar to what you might find at the grocery store. There’s nothing wrong with that, but at this price I was hoping for something more unique and memorable.

That said, I still want to believe in what they’re doing and hope they continue to refine their craft, I would to come back and be wowed one day.

Food: 3

The location is cool but the service was mid and the pizza was ahh totally not worth 5.76$ for a slice of cheese 🍕🤣 DO BETTER

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 2

Service: 3

The pepperoni pizza we got was very dry and the crust was tough to eat. Very disappointing! We’ve eaten here before but today was not good!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 2

Service: 5

Awesome pizza. Met the owner today. Nice guy. Buy some pizza from him

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I’ve come here more than a handful full of times and it’s all been good. But this time very disappointing:( I got the Carne Asada pizza and a pepperoni w/ peppers. And every time I bit into it, all I could taste was the burnt mess on the bottom which made both pizza dry and couldn’t taste the flavors. For spending $52 on 2 pizzas such a let down

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 2

Service: 4

Their website says $25 for a pizza and 10 wings. I’ve used this special like 15 times. Try ordering online, price says $38. I call, asking about getting the price the website says. The girl who answered was hilariously rude and wouldn’t answer my question why the website says it’s $25. So much for going there again.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 1

Really good food but impossibly slow. I'm talking 45+ minutes for a simple pizza slow. They don't have food ready when they say. Its chronic issue.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 2

I work a couple doors down and I am obsessed with their margarita and Hawaiian pizza. Thank you guys for being here and always being so nice when I visit.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

The pizza here is absolute perfection. The dough is crafted just right, perfectly crunchy with an impressive depth of flavor. Trust me, I’ve been eating pizza in New York for over 20 years, and this is hands down the best pizza I’ve had in Arizona.

I always get a good laugh when people complain about the price. If you want quality, you have to pay for it, and there’s no doubt that the ingredients used here are top-notch. If you’re looking for cheap food, there are plenty of fast food options out there, but this place is not that.

Called jun 12. Girl who answered was very unprofessional and rude. Didn't answer my question and hung up on me.

I think they’re closed, I drove up on a Saturday at 6:30 and it was locked up with no lights on.

Unfortunately, the pizza is comparable to Peter Piper. Nothing wrong with Peter Piper but My Slice advertises as NYC meets the southwest. I've come to terms that what makes NYC Pizza is the water. The crust at My Slice is a Lil tough. The wing sauce was a classic buffalo, however the chicken was dry af. Their beer taps were out and only pouring foam & their fountain drink machine was Out of Order. I was about to get a beer fortunately I waited cuz the next patron ordered a beer and was refunded due to foam only beer. Yikes! The employees were nice. However the atmosphere was lacking music and overall positive vibes. Its was just a little sad. I can only imagine at one point it was awesome being that they've been in business for 10 years. Bummer to say but I wouldn't recommend.

Place is mid, a canned drink being just as much as a slice is crazy work, they didn’t even have any prices on what the food/drinks costed, and food was cold by the time I got it. This place used to be of quality but their standards have lowered and it’s showed, before I get a response I want to clarify I didn’t step into another establishment or get confused, I don’t want a berated response like how the worker Jaylyn treated me for asking a question on the price of the food. You’d think they would have them but they don’t.

They sure keep the prices a mystery. $4.45 for a can of Jumex 😵‍💫 Nowhere on the menu or counter were prices listed, and nothing was mentioned when I ordered. This lack of transparency feels misleading. Restaurants should be upfront with their pricing—especially for something as simple as a canned drink. It left a bad impression. Pizza was ok, but being scammed sure left a bad taste in my mouth.

Response to their response, I showed a picture of your whole menu to show how there isn’t any prices listed ANYWHERE…. I even grabbed the menu on the counter and still showed no prices. I stood their for a few minutes with the dilemma to order wings or not but was confused to what anything costed. This import beverage you speak of is .79 cents at your local grocery store. Stating I could’ve asked for water just misses the whole point of my complaint.