My Slice of the Pie Pizzeria - Arcadia (Catering Available)

I work a couple doors down and I am obsessed with their margarita and Hawaiian pizza. Thank you guys for being here and always being so nice when I visit.

The pizza here is absolute perfection. The dough is crafted just right, perfectly crunchy with an impressive depth of flavor. Trust me, I’ve been eating pizza in New York for over 20 years, and this is hands down the best pizza I’ve had in Arizona.

I always get a good laugh when people complain about the price. If you want quality, you have to pay for it, and there’s no doubt that the ingredients used here are top-notch. If you’re looking for cheap food, there are plenty of fast food options out there, but this place is not that.

Called jun 12. Girl who answered was very unprofessional and rude. Didn't answer my question and hung up on me.

I think they’re closed, I drove up on a Saturday at 6:30 and it was locked up with no lights on.

Unfortunately, the pizza is comparable to Peter Piper. Nothing wrong with Peter Piper but My Slice advertises as NYC meets the southwest. I've come to terms that what makes NYC Pizza is the water. The crust at My Slice is a Lil tough. The wing sauce was a classic buffalo, however the chicken was dry af. Their beer taps were out and only pouring foam & their fountain drink machine was Out of Order. I was about to get a beer fortunately I waited cuz the next patron ordered a beer and was refunded due to foam only beer. Yikes! The employees were nice. However the atmosphere was lacking music and overall positive vibes. Its was just a little sad. I can only imagine at one point it was awesome being that they've been in business for 10 years. Bummer to say but I wouldn't recommend.

Place is mid, a canned drink being just as much as a slice is crazy work, they didn’t even have any prices on what the food/drinks costed, and food was cold by the time I got it. This place used to be of quality but their standards have lowered and it’s showed, before I get a response I want to clarify I didn’t step into another establishment or get confused, I don’t want a berated response like how the worker Jaylyn treated me for asking a question on the price of the food. You’d think they would have them but they don’t.

They sure keep the prices a mystery. $4.45 for a can of Jumex 😵‍💫 Nowhere on the menu or counter were prices listed, and nothing was mentioned when I ordered. This lack of transparency feels misleading. Restaurants should be upfront with their pricing—especially for something as simple as a canned drink. It left a bad impression. Pizza was ok, but being scammed sure left a bad taste in my mouth.

Response to their response, I showed a picture of your whole menu to show how there isn’t any prices listed ANYWHERE…. I even grabbed the menu on the counter and still showed no prices. I stood their for a few minutes with the dilemma to order wings or not but was confused to what anything costed. This import beverage you speak of is .79 cents at your local grocery store. Stating I could’ve asked for water just misses the whole point of my complaint.

A little bit expensive but it's worth that money, really delicious and tasty!

It pains me to write this. This WAS an amazing place. Been going here for several years, usually every few months. But something has changed recently and it’s sadly not the same. The crust tastes the same, which is good. But my Sonoran didn’t have any green Chiles, cilantro or cotijo. It was basically corn onions and tomatoes. New staff/ new chef? Off night? I’m concerned that this one great place has fallen off.

2nd time in a row- wrong Doordash pizza and, missing salad this time. I ordered gluten free, but by my swollen stomach Id say it wasnt, plus, it had jalepenos. You must have exact orders waiting for the Doordash people.

Easily one of the best pizza spots in the valley. Carne Asada pizza is ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Was a little hesitant on a $4 slice but I asked for it not heated up and it was a big slice. Big fan. Thanks my slice!

Food: 5

Service: 5

I give this eatery a one star because today I was servered a cold old slice of pizza that was obviously left over from the night before. I couldn’t even eat it. It tasted like something left over in my own refrigerator. My husband’s slice was obviously from a fresher pie. However with that said his slice was nothing like the slices we used to get under the old owners. This place will have to do much better to keep our business. So sad it was our go to place for NY style pizza, what we got today was nothing like NY pizza.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 1

Service: 5

Update: Response to the Owner (who is a Man according to his response to other reviewers )! Must’ve been him I saw! Your Very Defensive & Rude Rant speaks so loud as to the truth I don’t need to say anything else! How about an apology and wanting to make things right for a customer who has a poor experience? Attacking an honest review based on this person’s experience and calling them a liar is just putting the nail in the coffin! Never will I darken your door again nor rec to anyone!

First Time in—mgr(owner) sitting at bar not talking to anyone—thought he was a customer, until I saw him go back behind the register and then just stand there while there were a couple of guys waiting to be helped.
Place is def Take Out—very dark, small, uninviting place. Bad odor inside, got a slice to go—took quite a while to get—smelled awful in car! Not appetizing at all. Meat looks gross, taste is ok. Crusts burned & hard on the edges. Looks like they just take an already made cheese pizza and throw some meat on top and heat it up. Not worth the time waiting or the taste. Took Charcoal Capsules as a precaution to possibility of getting sick from the meat. Sorry. Parking is small and tight. Can’t recommend this place.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 2

Service: 2

It's such a small older place, it doesn't have much atmosphere. The pizza is great. It has become my go-to pizza choice.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza