My Slice of the Pie Pizzeria - Arcadia (Catering Available)

Easily one of the best pizza spots in the valley. Carne Asada pizza is ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Was a little hesitant on a $4 slice but I asked for it not heated up and it was a big slice. Big fan. Thanks my slice!

Food: 5

Service: 5

I give this eatery a one star because today I was servered a cold old slice of pizza that was obviously left over from the night before. I couldn’t even eat it. It tasted like something left over in my own refrigerator. My husband’s slice was obviously from a fresher pie. However with that said his slice was nothing like the slices we used to get under the old owners. This place will have to do much better to keep our business. So sad it was our go to place for NY style pizza, what we got today was nothing like NY pizza.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 1

Service: 5

Update: Response to the Owner (who is a Man according to his response to other reviewers )! Must’ve been him I saw! Your Very Defensive & Rude Rant speaks so loud as to the truth I don’t need to say anything else! How about an apology and wanting to make things right for a customer who has a poor experience? Attacking an honest review based on this person’s experience and calling them a liar is just putting the nail in the coffin! Never will I darken your door again nor rec to anyone!

First Time in—mgr(owner) sitting at bar not talking to anyone—thought he was a customer, until I saw him go back behind the register and then just stand there while there were a couple of guys waiting to be helped.
Place is def Take Out—very dark, small, uninviting place. Bad odor inside, got a slice to go—took quite a while to get—smelled awful in car! Not appetizing at all. Meat looks gross, taste is ok. Crusts burned & hard on the edges. Looks like they just take an already made cheese pizza and throw some meat on top and heat it up. Not worth the time waiting or the taste. Took Charcoal Capsules as a precaution to possibility of getting sick from the meat. Sorry. Parking is small and tight. Can’t recommend this place.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 2

Service: 2

It's such a small older place, it doesn't have much atmosphere. The pizza is great. It has become my go-to pizza choice.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza

It's one of the best pizzas ever from food deserts and personal ?.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Wings

This was hands down the best pizza I've ever had! The atmosphere is welcoming, and the staff goes above and beyond to make you feel right at home. The attention to detail in every part of the experience is incredible, it’s not just pizza, it’s a whole vibe! The Al Pastor Pizza is out of this world; I’ve never tasted anything like it. Plus, the owner personally made me a dessert pizza that was nothing short of spectacular. I’ll definitely be coming back more often!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

We discovered this place today and the food was amazing. We had the pastor pizza and the pepperoni one. I can really tell you that I will surely go back for more. The personnel was very nice and everything was just great. The owner was there and he was very nice.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

It’s pretty simple. They charged my credit card for what I ordered online and then told me they had to cancel my order but kept my money. Then they didn’t bother to answer my call. So now I’m disputing it with my credit card company. This place is terribly run.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Come and try the best rated NY Pizza style in Arizona by Washington Post.
You will just get amazed .

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza, The Supreme Being, Pizza Ever, Chicken Wings, Al Pastor

Boyfriend and I enjoyed a couple of slices here and the pizza was great, crispy crust, plenty of cheese and pepperoni. They had a pretty diverse menu and the atmosphere inside the restaurant was easy going.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Honestly, this place is a hidden gem. If we didn’t watch what we eat, we’d be there at least once a week minimum! The flavor and texture is great fresh and cold. Only downside is the inconsistency of customer service - you never know what kind of attitude you’ll receive when stepping foot in there

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 1

Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza

Awesome pizza! Easily the best we’ve had here in the valley in a long time. Small business and comfy vibes. My Husband Got a look in the kitchen and it was very clean and the cook was very precise. This is our new pizza spot! We just didn’t enjoy the jalapeño bread. The cheese cake is not made there but it is pretty delicious!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I came in after seeing a Facebook ad. Having grown up in NY, I really know my pizza. This stuff is ... just okay. I can't quite explain it. It definitely isn't BAD, but it also definitely doesn't live up to the claims in the ads. I ordered a pepperoni and a plain cheese slice. The pizza came out VERY hot, and the edges were a little burnt - maybe the oven was set too high? Crust texture was mostly okay, cheese taste was a little off kind of also on the verge of being burnt. Pepperoni just gets tossed on top of a cheese slice, it isn't baked in - so when you fold the slice to eat it, it all falls into the crease of the fold. I will say the pizza isn't overly greasy, which is nice.

It might be better if you order a whole fresh pie, I'm not sure. I came in around 1pm, so still during lunchtime and what would have been left should have been pretty fresh. I understand this is normal and individual pizza slices get reheated out of a full pie but ... something about how they do it isn't quite right.

The restaurant was very warm inside, and after reading some prior reviews it looks like this has been the case for at least a year. That is why "atmosphere" gets a 3. Otherwise the place was clean and decor wasn't bad. If the AC was better this would be a 4.

Staff was friendly, at least. Pricing was reasonable.

I would be willing to try it again if I'm in the area, especially if I'm ordering a whole fresh pie, but I definitely wouldn't go out of my way to eat here.

Wheelchair accessibility: Restaurant itself is wheelchair accessible, but the bathroom definitely isn't.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 4

Great little pizza place in a strip mall. Good pizza.