Pizza On 40th

3937 E Indian School Rd, Phoenix
(602) 595-3003

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Jacqueline Petra (Jackie)

Best Italian food I've had since I been back to New York 😋

Eric Maxwell

Best Italian food I've had since I been to New York 😋

Kate Welding

The cannolis are ridiculous man so good. Soooooo good. I ate two today. I’m moving super close and I am actually worried about how much I’m going to spend on these cannolis. And the pizza is delicious too. And the owner (I think) is the nicest guy ever he waves hello and smiles.

juan ramirez

Always good and reasonably priced pizza. One of my longtime favorites.

Petar Momcilovich

Great place to grab a quick lunch. Pizza tasted good, and the kids loved it. Friendly staff and decently priced.

Elizabeth Stefanel

So far this is the best New York style pizza I've found in Phoenix!

Megan Valenzuela

I would never go here!! There super rude. I walked in and placed an order waited 20 minutes. Walked up to the counter and they were like “ what’s your name” I was like “ you never asked”!! But yet the cashier has walked next store to the liquor store but somehow forgot to put my order in the oven!! I asked for a refund and they did not even acknowledge the mistake they did, they could have suggested while I had to wait for a drink or an extra piece since it was an appetizer. I don’t like their pizza it’s not even real product. All frozen. Overpriced. Now I have to see if the bank reverses the charge and I still was left with no product. I work in customer service industry and at least own the mistake and make it right!!!

Night Shift

So this afternoon I had a taste for pizza driving down Indian School road. So I looked on here for a nearby pizza place. I had a taste for pizza and wings.

As I found this restaurant looked on the reviews there were some good reviews for the fettuccine Alfredo with broccoli. So I ordered two slices with tomato on it. 6 wings medium buffalo sauce. Decided to get fettuccine Alfredo with chicken and broccoli to go. It smelled good as I got into the car and I took a bite. Then a few more bites and couldn't stop.

I had already eaten the two slices and wings inside the pizza was good the end crust could have been a little bit bigger. The wings had a really nice taste with a little bit of crisp to them.

But that fettuccine Alfredo was amazing. As a New York Italian I could tell they put some love into that sauce. You could taste the broccoli was cooked in that sauce for a while rather than some places just throw it and cooked. I will be back and tear it up again. Lol thank you guys. And the girl that was working the counter was very friendly.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: 2 Slices and Small Sofa Side of Salad, Wings

Kali Najah

I’m a spaghetti head , and know ones spaghetti taste this good , has such a large portion , and has a reasonable price , this place has it all together , my goto spaghetti place , taste price and portion size , best around hands down…

Vegas Psyclone

Great pizza! Accidentally found the place after I hit town for a job. Will back again.

... And again...

... And again.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

donald sampson

I placed an online order for a pizza at 525 and was given a time of 625 when it would be ready. When it was 650 I stated to wonder where my pizza was so I attempted to call the store 3 times and got no answer. So I drove to the store to find out the driver finally delivered the pizza after I had left. When I got back home 5 minutes later my pizza was at the doorbut it was already cold which makes sense since it was delivered over a half hour after it was done. Great service thanks alot

Food: 2

Service: 1

Brian Olek

Extremely underrated. Perfect authentic pizza. Simple, fresh, and affordable. I order a large plain cheese with sides of ranch once a week.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Yureal Isakov

Great pizza shop that reminds of a New York style pizzeria. Can’t go wrong with the lunch special 2 slices and a cola.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza

Tyler W.

Decidedly mediocre pizza but friendly staff.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 2

Service: 5

Cece CaLibra

Service was quick and friendly. Ordered 2 slices of pepperoni. The crust was crispy enough to hold up & fold in half, which was good bc I don't like a soggy crust. The cheese wasn't melty, so the peperonis easily fell off. It could've been hotter, but tasted good at first. As it cooled, the crust became a little too hard. Maybe it would've been better if I had ordered a fresh whole pie? Value was decent though. I would like to give them another try with a fresh pizza vs. a slice that's just warmed up upon ordering.

Loading...