We ended up eating here twice during our visit! Our first meal we tried 3 pizzas and loved them all. The clam pizza was awesome (although a bit spicy if you’re adverse). The second meal we ended up with wings, salads and a few other pizzas. Everything was delicious. We were bummed the mushrooms were out when we came by. The outdoor patio does have heaters, but can be a bit chilly. Violeta went above and beyond to take care of us, she was funny and very attentive even with it busy.Parking: Lots of parking on all sides, gravel lot, freeKid-friendliness: They have high chairs, lawn games and a changing table in the women’s room (not the men’s though, bummer).Wheelchair accessibility: There aren’t any steps to be worried about, but the parking lot is gravel and may be hard to navigate.
Recommended dishes: Woodfired Wings, Clam, Spinach Artichoke Chicken Pizza, Spinach Artichoke and Chicken, Cast Iron Cookie, Poncho, East Coast Clam Pizza, Salad
brad wells
This place is beyond 5 stars. The pizza is absolutely amazing but the wings are super amazing. It's worth the drive from Phoenix alone. Everything is great.
Best pizza in town (wood fired) and the craft beer is cold! Friendly staff and good place to bring the whole family.
Nick Salvatico
Amazing wood fired pizzas, with just the right amount of char. The bread sticks are addictive with the beer cheese. I wish I could have had my drink refilled with the beer cheese instead. Big chunks of green chili's in it. Definitely worth the drive up from Phoenix.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Green Chili Beer Cheese with Breadsticks 8ct, Meat Pizza, Meat Pie, Gelato
Emily Fidler
The wings are amazing and cooked to order. Pizza is so good and so fresh. The food and drink hit the spot! Highly recommend the lavender
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Woodfired Wings
Mary S.
OCI went through some growing pains for a couple years but now it is totally dialed in. The owner really listens to customers challenges and makes all needed changes (which were staff related never the food). Now the staff is incredibly friendly and efficient, the food delish and the creative cocktails even better than most places in the Valley. Soooo great!!
Lisa Nielsen
Dietary restrictions: Able to get gluten free dishes
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pancho Pizza, Gelato, Salad
Frank Fraccalvieri
Pizza and salad were unbelievably delicious. Service was astonishing.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ben Quinata
Just down the road from us. Love the pizza crust. Good choices of brews on tap. So far really enjoying this place.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Meat Pizza, Cast Iron Cookie
Cherrie
Stopped for pizza to take home. Didn't have desired ground beef, so ordered chicken. Said it would be 20 minutes. Took groceries back to our cabin. Returned after what would be an HOUR. Said would put it in oven & have it out in 8 minutes. Took back to cabin to eat. It was awful. Mushy & unbaked center, black charcoaled crust. Almost inedible!! For the $22, I could have picked up 2 Di Giorno frozen pizzas at the grocery store that would have been better!! Will never go there again when visiting Pine, AZ!!!
Gourmet pizza was so delicious! The top choice ingredients were fresh and plenty.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Walter Shivers
Just got back from a week in Pine Arizona. We arrived on a Tueday so they were closed. We went on Wednesday and just let me say THE BEST PIZZA I HAVE EVER HAD. I am kinda a pizza freak. The pizza was so good we ate there 4 days out of 7 and twice on 2 days. This pizza is on another level. We tried 5 different pizzas and all were off the charts. The Burrata was our favorite with the simple coming in second. It was unbelievable to get this pizza in such a small town. It was sad for us they were closed on Sunday and Monday or we would have ate there more days. We went to Pizza Biaco in Phoenix on our way back to Houston and this is a place that has been awarded for it pizza and it was good but no where the level of the pizza here and that speaks volumes. So if you are anywhere near here do your self a favor and order a pizza from here. You will not be disappointed.
Bill Wydeven
Fun and great
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Megan Cox
My fiance and I took our 4 teens up to Strawberry over the weekend for a change of scenery and fresh air. Saturday night we picked up 5 pizzas and 2 orders of wings. As soon as my son bit into his Hawaiian BBQ pizza his eyes rolled back in his head and he claimed it to be the best pizza he has ever had. We all enjoyed it! The wood fired pizza is phenomenal and we would recommend this place to everyone. My son asked if they had another location in the Phoenix area as well. Great food! We will visit again!
Peter Angelopoulos
I finally made the trip up to Old County Inn after seeing it on many lists for having great pizza. Being from Chicago, I've had a hard time finding pizza that I'd consider to be on par with back home, but I finally found that here. The Burrata pizza and portobello mushrooms were delicious and I'd gladly make the hour drive to eat it again. Overall, the food, service, and atmosphere were great.
We ended up eating here twice during our visit! Our first meal we tried 3 pizzas and loved them all. The clam pizza was awesome (although a bit spicy if you’re adverse). The second meal we ended up with wings, salads and a few other pizzas. Everything was delicious. We were bummed the mushrooms were out when we came by. The outdoor patio does have heaters, but can be a bit chilly. Violeta went above and beyond to take care of us, she was funny and very attentive even with it busy.Parking: Lots of parking on all sides, gravel lot, freeKid-friendliness: They have high chairs, lawn games and a changing table in the women’s room (not the men’s though, bummer).Wheelchair accessibility: There aren’t any steps to be worried about, but the parking lot is gravel and may be hard to navigate.
Recommended dishes: Woodfired Wings, Clam, Spinach Artichoke Chicken Pizza, Spinach Artichoke and Chicken, Cast Iron Cookie, Poncho, East Coast Clam Pizza, Salad
This place is beyond 5 stars. The pizza is absolutely amazing but the wings are super amazing. It's worth the drive from Phoenix alone. Everything is great.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Woodfired Wings, Meat Pie, Salad
Best pizza in town (wood fired) and the craft beer is cold! Friendly staff and good place to bring the whole family.
Amazing wood fired pizzas, with just the right amount of char. The bread sticks are addictive with the beer cheese. I wish I could have had my drink refilled with the beer cheese instead. Big chunks of green chili's in it. Definitely worth the drive up from Phoenix.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Green Chili Beer Cheese with Breadsticks 8ct, Meat Pizza, Meat Pie, Gelato
The wings are amazing and cooked to order. Pizza is so good and so fresh. The food and drink hit the spot! Highly recommend the lavender
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Woodfired Wings
OCI went through some growing pains for a couple years but now it is totally dialed in. The owner really listens to customers challenges and makes all needed changes (which were staff related never the food). Now the staff is incredibly friendly and efficient, the food delish and the creative cocktails even better than most places in the Valley. Soooo great!!
Dietary restrictions: Able to get gluten free dishes
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pancho Pizza, Gelato, Salad
Pizza and salad were unbelievably delicious. Service was astonishing.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Just down the road from us. Love the pizza crust. Good choices of brews on tap. So far really enjoying this place.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Meat Pizza, Cast Iron Cookie
Stopped for pizza to take home. Didn't have desired ground beef, so ordered chicken. Said it would be 20 minutes. Took groceries back to our cabin. Returned after what would be an HOUR. Said would put it in oven & have it out in 8 minutes. Took back to cabin to eat. It was awful. Mushy & unbaked center, black charcoaled crust. Almost inedible!! For the $22, I could have picked up 2 Di Giorno frozen pizzas at the grocery store that would have been better!! Will never go there again when visiting Pine, AZ!!!
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 1
Restaurantji Recommends
Gourmet pizza was so delicious! The top choice ingredients were fresh and plenty.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Just got back from a week in Pine Arizona. We arrived on a Tueday so they were closed. We went on Wednesday and just let me say THE BEST PIZZA I HAVE EVER HAD. I am kinda a pizza freak. The pizza was so good we ate there 4 days out of 7 and twice on 2 days. This pizza is on another level. We tried 5 different pizzas and all were off the charts. The Burrata was our favorite with the simple coming in second. It was unbelievable to get this pizza in such a small town. It was sad for us they were closed on Sunday and Monday or we would have ate there more days. We went to Pizza Biaco in Phoenix on our way back to Houston and this is a place that has been awarded for it pizza and it was good but no where the level of the pizza here and that speaks volumes. So if you are anywhere near here do your self a favor and order a pizza from here. You will not be disappointed.
Fun and great
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My fiance and I took our 4 teens up to Strawberry over the weekend for a change of scenery and fresh air. Saturday night we picked up 5 pizzas and 2 orders of wings. As soon as my son bit into his Hawaiian BBQ pizza his eyes rolled back in his head and he claimed it to be the best pizza he has ever had. We all enjoyed it! The wood fired pizza is phenomenal and we would recommend this place to everyone. My son asked if they had another location in the Phoenix area as well. Great food! We will visit again!
I finally made the trip up to Old County Inn after seeing it on many lists for having great pizza. Being from Chicago, I've had a hard time finding pizza that I'd consider to be on par with back home, but I finally found that here. The Burrata pizza and portobello mushrooms were delicious and I'd gladly make the hour drive to eat it again. Overall, the food, service, and atmosphere were great.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5