Best Italian we have had in Arizona so far. Who would have thought we had to come to Prescott Valley to get authentic Italian food!The ambiance was fun and welcoming, the music was perfectly Italian, the staff although we tried to get them to be grumpy were fantastic but the FOOD…. The food was amazing! Big healthy portions that were so tasty there we not much left over for lunch tomorrow! We are here for a couple days and may just got back tomorrow!
Kathleen Scott
Great Food, wonderful Staff
Melissa Horton Barcelona
This is not authentic Italian pizza. Nothing but cheap ingredients! Can’t believe I spent that much money for this pie! These Italians won’t be back!
E Mc
Perhaps it's better if you order the pizza, but unfortunately we all ordered pasta. The marinara sauce was too sweet (which doesn't bode well for the pizza!). The cheese ravioli was served in a milk soup. It had to be soup given how thin the sauce was. The ravioli squares sunk to the bottom of the bowl (see picture). The other dishes our party ordered fared little better. So, my recommendation is to avoid.
Rhonda T.
Good Italian food. If you order to pick up, it's ready in the time they tell you. Looking forward to coming here again and dining in.
Debbie Lupton
Fettuccine Di Mare, Mussels, Clams, Shrimp, Baby Scallops, in a white wine cream sauce over Fettuccine pasta.BEST FOOD I've EVER HAD.Never disappointed!Thanks Donna & Team
Andrew M.
Our pizza was well done! And I'm confident that the rest of the menu is great! Looking forward to eating inside.for pizza this is a good place.
Amber A.
The best Italian food I've every eaten. The portions were large and the service great even though it was busy. The dishes were all fresh and presented exquisitely.
Jessica B.
What a great spot for a low-key family pizza night! The complimentary garlic knots were delicious. We also got the fried zucchini, two pizzas, and a cannoli. Everything was great. We found the ambiance to be really casual and relaxing- low lighting, booth seating, and the music. If you're looking for another pizza place to add to the rotation, don't miss this one!
Kenneth L.
We got great service here. We were just looking at the menu on the window and was flagged to come in by staff. We're visiting and found it on yelp. I hope my photo will shows how great the pizza we got!
An internet search for Italian food found Grumpy Sicilian. What a score! From the first bite of garlic knots to the last bite of tiramisu, we were amazed! Excellent service, excellent atmosphere and perfectly prepared food! We WILL be back!
Kam M.
I placed an order over the phone for pick up and drove over to get my order. When I got there no one was waiting and the woman came to assist me. I told her my name and she went to get my order. She took out half my order then a white couple came in and she put my food down to go help them. She tells me someone else is coming, and proceeds to go help the couple that came in after me. That was just bad customer service. After she took them to their table she proceeded to do anything else besides help me. I wonder why? This interaction alone makes me not want to be a patron here. I was finally help by a very pleasant blonde woman. Eggplant Parmigiana Hand breaded eggplant, mozzarella, house marinara. It would have been nice if it came with a salad but it came with garlic knots. I guess we can't have it all Grumpy pizza Spinach, Ricotta, Tomato, Garlic & Oil, Balsamic Glaze. Everything was pretty good but the interaction with the staff member has left a bad taste in my mouth and I don't think that I will return.
Heather Wilson
I host Cookies Decorating Class's at my house and choose local food to serve. Tonight I choose Grumpy Sicilian in PV a large cheese pizza .I placed my order ran next door to the store. I came back and it wasn't ready. I was getting nervous because it was taking a really long time. The Hostess stepped up apologized and threw some Knott's our way . They gave us a delicious cheese pizza. It was served with kindness and the best garlic Knott's I have ever had.
Linda P.
We tried this place before heading back to the valley of the heat. Took a chance and glad we did!! This was a great experience, from garlic knots before dinner to salad to entree. Too full for dessert though!! Busy and family friendly. Great service.
Clifford L
Ordered the breaded zucchini as an appetizer and a pizza for dinner. Both were very good. he place was very crowded on a Sat. evening on a holiday weekend and the service was a little slow, but not bad.
Best Italian we have had in Arizona so far. Who would have thought we had to come to Prescott Valley to get authentic Italian food!The ambiance was fun and welcoming, the music was perfectly Italian, the staff although we tried to get them to be grumpy were fantastic but the FOOD…. The food was amazing! Big healthy portions that were so tasty there we not much left over for lunch tomorrow! We are here for a couple days and may just got back tomorrow!
Great Food, wonderful Staff
This is not authentic Italian pizza. Nothing but cheap ingredients! Can’t believe I spent that much money for this pie! These Italians won’t be back!
Perhaps it's better if you order the pizza, but unfortunately we all ordered pasta. The marinara sauce was too sweet (which doesn't bode well for the pizza!). The cheese ravioli was served in a milk soup. It had to be soup given how thin the sauce was. The ravioli squares sunk to the bottom of the bowl (see picture). The other dishes our party ordered fared little better. So, my recommendation is to avoid.
Good Italian food. If you order to pick up, it's ready in the time they tell you. Looking forward to coming here again and dining in.
Fettuccine Di Mare, Mussels, Clams, Shrimp, Baby Scallops, in a white wine cream sauce over Fettuccine pasta.BEST FOOD I've EVER HAD.Never disappointed!Thanks Donna & Team
Our pizza was well done! And I'm confident that the rest of the menu is great! Looking forward to eating inside.for pizza this is a good place.
The best Italian food I've every eaten. The portions were large and the service great even though it was busy. The dishes were all fresh and presented exquisitely.
What a great spot for a low-key family pizza night! The complimentary garlic knots were delicious. We also got the fried zucchini, two pizzas, and a cannoli. Everything was great. We found the ambiance to be really casual and relaxing- low lighting, booth seating, and the music. If you're looking for another pizza place to add to the rotation, don't miss this one!
We got great service here. We were just looking at the menu on the window and was flagged to come in by staff. We're visiting and found it on yelp. I hope my photo will shows how great the pizza we got!
Restaurantji Recommends
An internet search for Italian food found Grumpy Sicilian. What a score! From the first bite of garlic knots to the last bite of tiramisu, we were amazed! Excellent service, excellent atmosphere and perfectly prepared food! We WILL be back!
I placed an order over the phone for pick up and drove over to get my order. When I got there no one was waiting and the woman came to assist me. I told her my name and she went to get my order. She took out half my order then a white couple came in and she put my food down to go help them. She tells me someone else is coming, and proceeds to go help the couple that came in after me. That was just bad customer service. After she took them to their table she proceeded to do anything else besides help me. I wonder why? This interaction alone makes me not want to be a patron here. I was finally help by a very pleasant blonde woman. Eggplant Parmigiana Hand breaded eggplant, mozzarella, house marinara. It would have been nice if it came with a salad but it came with garlic knots. I guess we can't have it all Grumpy pizza Spinach, Ricotta, Tomato, Garlic & Oil, Balsamic Glaze. Everything was pretty good but the interaction with the staff member has left a bad taste in my mouth and I don't think that I will return.
I host Cookies Decorating Class's at my house and choose local food to serve. Tonight I choose Grumpy Sicilian in PV a large cheese pizza .I placed my order ran next door to the store. I came back and it wasn't ready. I was getting nervous because it was taking a really long time. The Hostess stepped up apologized and threw some Knott's our way . They gave us a delicious cheese pizza. It was served with kindness and the best garlic Knott's I have ever had.
We tried this place before heading back to the valley of the heat. Took a chance and glad we did!! This was a great experience, from garlic knots before dinner to salad to entree. Too full for dessert though!! Busy and family friendly. Great service.
Ordered the breaded zucchini as an appetizer and a pizza for dinner. Both were very good. he place was very crowded on a Sat. evening on a holiday weekend and the service was a little slow, but not bad.