NY Pizza Department

The staff is really great - one time they forgot to put our appetizer in, so they brought a large version of it and comped it! The menu and food are wonderful, the prices are reasonable, and the portions are large - we always take home leftovers!

I order pizza from here every now and again. This time my pizza tasted like men’s cologne. Definitely not like the previous great experiences I’ve had. I was already home and eating before I realized or else I would’ve requested a refund.

Awesome food, great friendly service. Genuine New York pizza. Reminds me of my childhood home.

My husband and I decided to order some take out since it was a nice cozy, raining day. We’re new to the area and we’re excited to see a place that offered Sicilian Pizza. It was pretty nice on the inside but the standouts were the service and the pizza. I had a few gentlemen help me with my take out and all of them were great! I wish I got their names but shout out to anyone here who was working on May 4th at around 6:00. The pizza was also amazing! I’m not an expert on Sicilian pizza by any means, but I can sure say it tasted good and it was huge! Will be ordering again!

We got slices for lunch. The lasagna slice was delicious. Easy ordering and delicious pizza.

I just wanted to come in here for lunch since I was doing some work for some customers in the area.

Love the NYPD Pizza atmosphere. Andrew was my server, he did a great job he was awesome.

I ordered some slices with ricotta cheese. It was great. Every of their restaurants I eat at are always consistent. Nice crust on the pizza Nice crisp chewy on the inside great sauce great cheese.

The salad with the balsamic was just as good as the pizza. Thank you guys for everything. 🍕

Oh yeah and just as importantly any places don't really care about serving the iced tea kind of sewers. Any places will give you less and quality tasting iced tea. This iced tea is a premium tea tropical. When it's a good iced tea like this I don't need to use sugar. So there are some of us that really appreciate a restaurant considering serving a good tea.

I order take out several times a month and its always delicious with the best service anyone could experience. I'm allergic to wheat. The gluten free BBQ chicken pizza (perfection) or the large Chelsea Salad are my go-tos. Quality & service are top notch and everything is consistent every.single.time. Thank you to the front and back of house for all that you do.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

chill spot to grab a quick bite or sit down drink a beer eat a whole pizza lol love coming here for date nights. The server was the only one but he was on top of it and had great personality!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Pathetic. All around

Good Pizza ? ? ? ?

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Sicilian Pizza

Love the pizza. Customer service is great too. Jesse and Liz are wonderful.

Food: 5

I have nothing good to say about this experience! The garlic cheese knots were a joke. The cheese on top of the knots was thinner than tissue paper. I ordered the pizza with no sausage on the left side and no pepperoni or olives on the right side. Well, the hole pizza had sausage and pepperoni!!! They did get the olives right...miracle. The slices of tomatoes that they had on top had made the whole pizza soggy! The three of us ate less than half of the food...it was that bad!! Lesson learned--never again!

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 1

Dry and tasteless. Hey NYPD, you do realize pizza is supposed to have sauce on it?

We are always on the lookout for decent, if not good pizza. I ordered two different pizzas and both were great! Good sauce to cheese, the amount of veggies was proportionate.
My only issue, which is a preference, I put it in the toaster oven to cook it a little longer. That’s an easy remedy.
We will be ordering from here again, which is more than I can say for other pizza places we have given a lot more money to.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Great experience all around. They brought out little slices of pizza dough for our kids to play with while they waited, which was a hit!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5