9 Best Italian Restaurants in Sedona

“10/10 for food, service, and atmosphere! Their Pollo & Pesto sandwich and Cannoli were amazing“

“Our server was friendly and quite knowledgeable on the menu, ingredients, and specifically the wine. I found my meal was very good and even exquisite. We were treated with great care and they even arranged a shuttle from our resort to the restaurant and back. The dessert was a decadent chocolate cake. We will be back on our next Sedona visit“

“We ate dinner at the Hideaway House this week. The food was so good that we came back for lunch the next day.“

“We arrived without a reservation and only waited about 25 minutes. We went to the bar to get a drink while we waited and the bartender was SO rude. He never acknowledged that we were standing there then when I asked to order a drink he got very snippy and was rude during our entire interaction. I asked for a drink menu and he told me to go over to the hostess and get one. I shouldn’t have tipped him at all but gave him less than 10%. On to the positive. The food was AMAZING! Our server was Isaiah who was so kind. He was very attentive. I recommend you ask for him. Very knowledgeable about the food. We had chicken parm, Cesar salad, eggplant parm and bolognese. Everything was so good. I recommended this restaurant just don’t go to the bar first.“

“I made reservations for 26 people
And worked with Kevin..He was very helpful and even fixed a last minute change for us to use the patio. Our server Jamee was awesome. She made sure everyone had what they wanted and needed. I have to admit I was a little worried about having such a large group about the food quality but the food was very good. I would definitely book Sedona pizza again if I’m in the area for large group.
Thanks Jamee and Kevin for all your hard work.“

“I’m happy with our server“

“Fantastic! I don’t give reviews unless things are spectacular! Best Italian restaurant I’ve ever been too. Thank you!“

“We had an amazing meal at Pago's, our only regret is that we didn't find the restaurant until our last night in Sedona. The short drive here was well worth it.
The pizza is incredible, we loved the thick Sicilian crust and the toppings were generous. The pasta was delicious and a huge serving, accompanied by a fresh salad and garlic bread.
The service was exceptional, and I loved that we were supporting a family restaurant. Highly recommended.“