Slickables Ice Cream Sandwich

The only reason I give this place a 5 star review is because on Google you can't leave a 10 star review, which is what this cool little shop deserves.

A customer focused treat shop with seriously delicious cookies and ice cream at a low price on Mill Ave.

A great place to bring the whole family and the staff was super great too!

Delicious quick treat!

I visited on Sunday and thought the two girls working provided excellent service and were very friendly!

I recently visited Slickables on 3/28/2025 at around 8pm. The ice cream sandwich I got was really tasty. The staff was very friendly and the girl in the pink shirt answered all my questions. I’ll definitely be returning!

People eating or getting ready to eat iced cream are generally in a pretty good mood, and an iced cream shop usually reflects this. When it is the polar opposite experience, it makes me feel like I need to leave a review.

I understand it's being renovated, and it really feels like it…but I didn’t hold that against them. I was in a pretty good mood when I walked in, excited for some iced cream. I greeted the staff with a friendly “how are you tonight?”. I didn’t get so much as a grunt to acknowledge my presence, which didn't necessarily bother me, but it did seem to suck any positive energy I brought in right out of the room. It was 9pm on Sunday night, but they were open 3 more hours.

A shop specializing in iced cream sandwiches, I assumed, may have a different process than “give me a scoop of vanilla”. I have bad vision so I couldn’t see the menu/sign all that well, and just felt like having someone tell me how it all works. This time I may have heard a slight grunt (not 100% sure) following my question, after which I translated the subsequent uncomfortable silence to mean: “look at the menu/sign & figure it out yourself”.

I know quality customer service is rare these days in general, but with at least 2 other shops within walking distance, you have to do better to stick around on Mill. The group I was with recommended every other place; no one mentioned Slickables. I chose it because it sounded unique, but mostly because it was the only one without a line. I got 2 sandwiches to go, but if I were with that person I was buying for, I'd still have taken it home vs. eating there. A couple of energetic, engaged employees capable of at least pretending to want to be there & serve customers would have made it a completely different experience. It would have taken just 5 minutes, and then they could get back to TikTok.

A 2nd star because the dessert was still pretty good, but everything else could be a lot better.

Gross hard cookies

Good ice cream joint at a good price. Disappointed that my cookies were rock hard which isn't conducive to an ice cream sandwich. My husband's brownie was also not warmed for his sundae. I'm not sure if this is normal for this location but was disappointing for the experience. Otherwise the ice cream was good and the experience/atmosphere was nice.

Dude $5 two cookies and a scoop of ice cream. In this inflated ass market. The cookies are good and soft (not mushy) and the service is fast. Let’s go.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cookie Sandwich

If you're looking for delicious ice cream with a fun twist, Slickables is worth a visit! Their ice cream flavors are fantastic—I tried the vanilla on double chocolate, and it was a perfect pairing. My only wish? That they warmed the cookies used for their ice cream sandwiches. A softer, warm cookie would elevate the experience even more!

I also had the salted caramel ice cream on a chocolate chip cookie. After pressing the cookie into the ice cream to soften it up, it was perfection! I’d definitely give it a 10/10 and highly recommend it for a sweet treat.

The inside may look a bit small and janky, but don’t let that fool you—the service and quality are top-notch, making it worth the visit

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 5

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Salted Caramel, Double Chocolate Chip Sandwich

Cookie was a little on the crunchier side, but I also went towards the end of the night. The caramel ice cream was delicious. Would recommend.

Best Ice Cream Cookie Sandwich in town. Prices have gone up, but inflation is EVERYWHERE. COOKIES baked on-site. Family owned business. I have been going here since they first opened up pretty sure it has been 12 years now. Open fairly late too. #sweepstakesentry

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Love walking down to this little ice cream joint on mill! Prices are good and the ice cream is, well, ice cream. Hard to go wrong there! The cookies they offer to put it in between are always good. This was a common spot between me and my roommates when they were still here.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Ice Cream Sandwich

These ice cream sandwiches were 10/10! I had family in town and they really enjoyed how they could customize their ice cream sandwich. We came on Sunday and were able to utilize free street parking! #

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Ice Cream Sandwich

Beans.

Beans.