The Screamery (Speedway Location)

10/10. It was my first time going in and I got a sundae with the honey sweet cream (can't really remember the name lol) flavored iced cream with buttercake and whipped cream. It tasted really high quality, the flavor was well balanced and not overly sweet. I liked that the cake was warm under the cold ice cream. I'll definitely be back. Only complaint I have is the menu is written in pastel chalk on a blackboard that's really far back so it was kinda hard for me to read it but that was easily fixed by just pulling up the menu online. Everyone was friendly and helpful.

We had the ice cream flight and got to choose our flavors. Would definitely go back. 10/10 Also, we tried the strawberry gelato. OBSESSED.

I don’t usually leave reviews, but I was a bit disappointed and won’t be back. It started off with how the employee built my cone. They smacked it onto the cone without really trying to make a nice presentation. The strawberry ice cream wasn’t sticking very well and I could tell they just gave up trying to serve a proper stack. I carried on and still took it because I personally care more about the flavor than how it looks—I was just bummed they slapped the cone together and didn’t care. The strawberry flavor itself was basic, not really anything to get excited about. It was nice that it had real pieces of strawberry but overall just left a weird film on my tongue and just left more to be desired. If I go to an ice cream shop I want to have a nice experience, at this place I basically could have made myself a better cone at home.

Have been regulars at the Screamery for several years, but lately I have been finding flecks of what seems to be butter. We recently bought a quart of chocolate that was full of these white flecks about the size of rice grains, and greasy on the tongue. Maybe they churned it too long and it turned into butter instead of ice cream? In any case not very palatable, especially at the premium cost.

They were closed despite their hours indicating there open. Don’t waste your time

Whether you're looking to cool down after a hike or enjoy a leisurely treat with friends, The Screamery delivers a top-notch ice cream experience. With its fast service, extensive flavor options, and friendly staff, it's no wonder this shop has become a local favorite.

Overpriced, out of root beer for floats, even though they claim to have the best, out of regular cones and very few choices of flavors!

Great customer service, super friendly, clean, and the ice cream was amazing!

The service is great and the ice cream is great! The young ladies that work there are always cheerful and helpful. My favorite is the Sweet Cream Honeycomb with hot fudge and whip cream.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Hot Fudge, Sweet Cream Honeycomb

Good ice cream. Fun flavors.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Hot Fudge, Banana Split

The girls working were friendly and incredibly patient. Ice cream was good, but overpriced. Cowboy cookie is delicious!! And the christmas decorations look amazing.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cowboy Cookie

Really unique and delicious flavors! The ice cream had an excellent creamy consistency. Friendly and patient staff behind the counter. Limited seating inside though.

Dietary restrictions: I did not see any dairy free options for vegans.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cowboy Cookie, Sweet Cream Honeycomb

Good ice cream, table inside and outside

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Like what another review said, customer service is poor. Cashiers look and act miserable.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 3

Ice cream was good. Service was kinda weird? Just generally unfriendly.

Dietary restrictions: Good selection of gluten free options.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 3

Recommended dishes: Banana Cream Pie