Always amazing no matter what you order!! Highly recommend!! Do not be put off by the hole in the wall vibe!! Best pizza in town
Liz
Very Disappointed. $50 Bucks For Cold Slop! For That Price It Should Be Hot! Not Aure If Someone New Is Making The Pizza's But They Tasted Lile Garbage. Which Is Upsetting I Love Mr Jay's But Not Sure If I Will Buy From Again
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 2
Madison Holloway
It seems to me they rely on phone-in take-out orders but only start cooking when you arrive, like they don’t trust you. We were told 35 minutes; pretty accurate number, but from experience have them a full 50 minutes before arriving. Then, waited another 20 while 2 walk up orders got the food first. Had to wait outside, unsheltered from wind and rain hoping not to miss them calling my name. The whole operation seem confused as three different people came to the order window to check orders and it was not due to crazy busy, just lack of communication. With this type of disorganization at the front, we can only guess the state of the kitchen in the back. Never eating here again, telling everyone we can. This was not our first bad experience here but it was the one that stopped us going forever.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Jason Green
Closed on anyone's day off the Saturday and Sunday why woukd they do that makes me never want to give them.buisnes again plus food aintvavthat but eqx gonna five it thumbs uo cause its something but not when close the whole weekend how you think you gonna make it when yiur whining about how your prices can change at any moment without notice and come on customer eat it up.lol
Regina Embernate
Amazing service, great pizza, and delicious left overs for the next day!
Best pizza in comox valley. Good in both quality and quantity.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 2
hames1953
Living in NS this is the best pizza between us and Mr J's
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Paul Rodriguez
Best pizza hands down
B H
Used to be great small town pizza. The last two times have been dry, poorly thrown together pizza. People are nice and professional but it’s $30 a pie for something I could easily make better at home. Hate to leave a bad review, I hope they back to their roots.
Such a lovely little hole in the wall pizzeria. Thin , soft and crunchy crust. Loaded with toppings. Highly recommend for authentic pizza. Wonderful staff.
Jordan
Don't let the parking or line up deter you. This is the best pizza I've ever had. It is very reasonably priced, loaded with toppings, THICK slices of bacon, fresh mushrooms, just absolutely perfect in every way. Also, possibly the best BLT I've ever had. I can confidently say, that for as long as I live in the valley, I will never get pizza anywhere else.
Rita Zawila
Delicious pizza, thanks guys!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
shamus billings
First time trying Mr J's has the lasagna combo with ceaser salad and its probably the best lasagna I've had on the island. Highly recommend very good
Always amazing no matter what you order!! Highly recommend!! Do not be put off by the hole in the wall vibe!! Best pizza in town
Very Disappointed. $50 Bucks For Cold Slop! For That Price It Should Be Hot! Not Aure If Someone New Is Making The Pizza's But They Tasted Lile Garbage. Which Is Upsetting I Love Mr Jay's But Not Sure If I Will Buy From Again
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 2
It seems to me they rely on phone-in take-out orders but only start cooking when you arrive, like they don’t trust you. We were told 35 minutes; pretty accurate number, but from experience have them a full 50 minutes before arriving. Then, waited another 20 while 2 walk up orders got the food first. Had to wait outside, unsheltered from wind and rain hoping not to miss them calling my name. The whole operation seem confused as three different people came to the order window to check orders and it was not due to crazy busy, just lack of communication. With this type of disorganization at the front, we can only guess the state of the kitchen in the back. Never eating here again, telling everyone we can. This was not our first bad experience here but it was the one that stopped us going forever.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Closed on anyone's day off the Saturday and Sunday why woukd they do that makes me never want to give them.buisnes again plus food aintvavthat but eqx gonna five it thumbs uo cause its something but not when close the whole weekend how you think you gonna make it when yiur whining about how your prices can change at any moment without notice and come on customer eat it up.lol
Amazing service, great pizza, and delicious left overs for the next day!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best pizza in town, hands down.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Meat Lovers Pizza, Garlic Toast, Cheese Toast
Best pizza in comox valley. Good in both quality and quantity.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 2
Living in NS this is the best pizza between us and Mr J's
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best pizza hands down
Used to be great small town pizza. The last two times have been dry, poorly thrown together pizza. People are nice and professional but it’s $30 a pie for something I could easily make better at home. Hate to leave a bad review, I hope they back to their roots.
Restaurantji Recommends
Great place, good food
Such a lovely little hole in the wall pizzeria. Thin , soft and crunchy crust. Loaded with toppings. Highly recommend for authentic pizza. Wonderful staff.
Don't let the parking or line up deter you. This is the best pizza I've ever had. It is very reasonably priced, loaded with toppings, THICK slices of bacon, fresh mushrooms, just absolutely perfect in every way. Also, possibly the best BLT I've ever had. I can confidently say, that for as long as I live in the valley, I will never get pizza anywhere else.
Delicious pizza, thanks guys!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
First time trying Mr J's has the lasagna combo with ceaser salad and its probably the best lasagna I've had on the island. Highly recommend very good
Loading...