New York New York Greek Restaurant

We have dined at this restaurant for many years. It's not the same as it used to be. We liked the Greek salad better the way it used to be.

Update: While we were dining, we ordered take-out. They bundled the take-out order into our bill that had an auto 18% gratuity. It appeared that we were being charged a gratuity on the take-out portion, too. The server was not able to explain the billing, so we thought we had been charged 18% on the take-out. The manager responded promptly to my review and assured us that the gratuity was not charged on the take-out portion. Upon careful calculation of the bill, the manager was correct. No gratuity had been charged on the take-out.

Sorry for any previous negative remarks. I have removed them.

We have gone to this restaurant for many years. It used to be very good food, a welcoming atmosphere and reasonably priced. Sadly, its not anymore like it was. While the food was still quite good, it has changed and not for the better. It is also quite expensive now. Warning, if you order take-out while dining at the restaurant, ask for it to be on a separate bill. They bundled out take-out order into the dining bill and charged an 18% gratuity on the take-out. They refused to remove the gratuity from the take-out portion of the bill. At the end of the day, it's their loss. They just lost some longtime customers. We won't be going there anymore and won't recommend it to our many friends either.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 3

The best Greek food in Surrey! Tried their Calamari platter and Eggplant parmegiano , portions are huge and consistent taste since last 10 years. The new menu has vegetarian and halal options, which is amazing!

My first time ever writing a review Ordered souvlaki take out Never Again Every think tasted so different Food was not fresh

I recently ordered food for 25 guests for my daughter’s 5th birthday, and I can’t express how wonderful everything was! The flavours were exceptional, and the portions were beyond generous. From the perfectly roasted lemons on the chicken skewers to the finest details, everything was thoughtfully prepared and absolutely delicious. Thank you for helping make our celebration so special. We’re incredibly lucky to have such a gem of a place to return to for all our future events—we’ll definitely be back!

Our waitress was so sweet, upbeat and friendly.

Went with friends, we all loved it. Roast Lamb is still one of their best options. The recipe hasn't changed after all these years. Staff were great, too.

This place is great! Huge portions, excellent food, great service! The kalamari platter was so huge, my mom and I could've shared it (we each had our own, and had leftovers). Will definitely be back. Plus I loved the bubble wall with the fake fishes.

Pretty good Greek food. I'd go with lamb over prawn next time. Server was great!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Got take out from here. It was horrible. This place used to be good years ago but not anymore. The rice was dry and had no flavor. The potatoes were hard. Called to complain and the manager was too good to even come to the phone. Will not be going back and it's a shame because I've ben a customer for years .

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

The staff here have horrible attitudes. Look at their replies for proof.

Service: 1

The food is great every time we come here! Great flavors and one of our favorite go to restaurants in the area.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Roast Lamb a L'Astoria, Beef Souvlaki

Great for before a show at Bell theater, Calamari was perfect, lemon potato was a wonderful revelation to me and Ecmeq dessert is like eating a sweet cloud. Didn't like the potato based Moussaka, always had it as eggplant but that's just me. Baklava looked crispy and honeyed, companion enjoyed it. Would go back for Lamb dishes.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 5

EVERYTHING IS SOOOOOOOO GOOD HERE!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Roasted Lamb, Housemade Ecmek, Roast Lamb a L'Astoria, Saganaki

I always get pick orders from this authentic Greek diner thus never get disappointments.the foods great and the staff super friendly

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5