Not a bad slice for its crisp, but why advertise it as “NY pizza”? Just because it’s thin crust, by the slice and simple toppings- it certainly doesn’t make it New York style.
Food: 2
Kirk
8.9/10
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Hawaiian Pizza
Zinkzilla
Came here around 8:30 pm after driving back up to Whistler due to the landslide in west van. Staff were super friendly and the vibe was really good. The salami and banana pepper pizza was unreal. The crust is nice and thin and the pizza oven just made for a super authentic thin crust pizza. I’ll 100% be coming back the next time we come up. Super convenient location if you are staying in or near the upper village.
ajai singh
Came here based off a recommendation of a friend and it didn’t disappoint. One of the better pizza slices I’ve had. The pints here were probably the best I’ve had in Canada. Most places are usually flat and not ice cold.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Alex Martinez
Good pizza. Great after skiing.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
L G
The pizza is incredible. You’d never suspect it by the looks of the place - it feels like primarily a watering hole with some slice options but do not be fooled, this is a respectable pizza joint! The owner is self-taught and doing 63% hydration dough according to one of the pizza makers. It’s so light and crispy. Perfect pizza for a ski day because it won’t bog you down. I could probably house an entire large pie by myself though. And those little curling pepperonis are always elite. This is a must-get pizza when in whistler-blackcomb. Friendly servers too.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Melissa Tan
They forgot my order, but they didn’t forget to make it up to me. I ordered a Pepperoni and a Hawaiian Slice. Everyone around me got their order and I started to wonder. I inquired into the kitchen whether my order was on the way. They eventually got it out to me 5 mins after my inquiry and also gave me some spicy honey and ranch complimentary for waiting. I appreciate that and I will be back. So few places ever try to make it up to you that this was memorable that they did. Now that I had a chance to try the spicy honey, I might actually order the spicy honey in the future. It sounded too odd to make the jump but it was really nice on my Hawaiian and Pepperoni pizza.
If the manager is reading this… I would have ordered a drink but the only non-alcoholic beverage they have is soda water (which I actually generally like). Would have loved to see something like Kombucha on tap. Also would love other choices for dipping sauces as Dill Ranch isn’t necessarily my favourite.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Hawaiian Pizza
That Elvis
I enjoyed their wonderful pizza. It is very Napoletana New York style pizza. It has wonderful flavorings, and also just a simple, thin crust that holds up and does not flop once. I have met the owner Tommy and the bartender Shannon they are wonderful people that treat Do you like a local even though you were out of town!
I am trying to convince Tommy the owner to get Dave Portnay to review his pizza!
Great folks and pizza with soon live entertainment during the busy season! What more could you ask for!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza
Mike T
Had takeout, super yummy. Went to pick it up, wished I had stayed and eaten in house, looked to have a banging vibe & sweet selection on tap.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Vince Shuley
On par with best pizza in Whistler. Great beer selection and awesome service.
Choice of 6 toppings on pizza. Was really delicious. Garlic bread and cheese was a letdown.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Charlie
Very good New York style gluten-free pizza. Well-cooked on top, but the crust was soft enough to fold. The sauce to topping ratio was great, I just wish that the ham stood out a little bit more. It kind of got lost amongst the rest of the pizza. Maybe that’s my fault for ordering a Hawaiian pizza though. Staff was extremely friendly, and it was just a great vibe overall!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Andy Korczynski
We ate here a few years back and it was really good. Was recently in Whistler again and ate here a few more times...I think it may have gotten even better. Hawaiian pizza is awesome and you can't really go wrong with the other options. Good beer selection and the patio area is great when it's nice out. Service was great and friendly! I just hope they are still there next time I go to whistler!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Patrick Nelson
HandleBar is a gem, in my opinion. I loved their pizza; it’s awesome if you have it made fresh! I had the Spicy Calabrese pizza and it was indeed quite spicy and delicious in every bite. They have a very good beer selection as well (including some ciders), which we enjoyed. The vibe there was very casual and I really liked their tech/pixel design in the interior; it’s pretty cool. If you’re in the mood for good pizza and you’re nearby, you definitely can’t go wrong here.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Spicy Calabrese Pizza
D MC
Easy 5 stars for this chill pizza shop. I would highly recommend HandleBar Pizza to anyone in the area. We tried the cheese, pepperoni, Hawaiian, and spicy calabrese and they were all delicious. We really enjoyed the thin crust and flavorful red sauce.
We went during a surprisingly very busy Thursday dinner at 5pm and our server (Lani?) was amazing holding down the fort. She was the only server and was juggling 4 tables inside and about 4 outside. We wanted to order a whole pizza but she told us that the wait time would be 45mins so we grabbed pizza by the slice and a few drinks. I can't wait to return to HandleBar Pizza in Whistler.
Not a bad slice for its crisp, but why advertise it as “NY pizza”? Just because it’s thin crust, by the slice and simple toppings- it certainly doesn’t make it New York style.
Food: 2
8.9/10
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Hawaiian Pizza
Came here around 8:30 pm after driving back up to Whistler due to the landslide in west van. Staff were super friendly and the vibe was really good. The salami and banana pepper pizza was unreal. The crust is nice and thin and the pizza oven just made for a super authentic thin crust pizza. I’ll 100% be coming back the next time we come up. Super convenient location if you are staying in or near the upper village.
Came here based off a recommendation of a friend and it didn’t disappoint. One of the better pizza slices I’ve had. The pints here were probably the best I’ve had in Canada. Most places are usually flat and not ice cold.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Good pizza. Great after skiing.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The pizza is incredible. You’d never suspect it by the looks of the place - it feels like primarily a watering hole with some slice options but do not be fooled, this is a respectable pizza joint! The owner is self-taught and doing 63% hydration dough according to one of the pizza makers. It’s so light and crispy. Perfect pizza for a ski day because it won’t bog you down. I could probably house an entire large pie by myself though. And those little curling pepperonis are always elite. This is a must-get pizza when in whistler-blackcomb. Friendly servers too.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
They forgot my order, but they didn’t forget to make it up to me. I ordered a Pepperoni and a Hawaiian Slice. Everyone around me got their order and I started to wonder. I inquired into the kitchen whether my order was on the way. They eventually got it out to me 5 mins after my inquiry and also gave me some spicy honey and ranch complimentary for waiting. I appreciate that and I will be back. So few places ever try to make it up to you that this was memorable that they did. Now that I had a chance to try the spicy honey, I might actually order the spicy honey in the future. It sounded too odd to make the jump but it was really nice on my Hawaiian and Pepperoni pizza.
If the manager is reading this… I would have ordered a drink but the only non-alcoholic beverage they have is soda water (which I actually generally like). Would have loved to see something like Kombucha on tap. Also would love other choices for dipping sauces as Dill Ranch isn’t necessarily my favourite.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Hawaiian Pizza
I enjoyed their wonderful pizza. It is very Napoletana New York style pizza. It has wonderful flavorings, and also just a simple, thin crust that holds up and does not flop once. I have met the owner Tommy and the bartender Shannon they are wonderful people that treat Do you like a local even though you were out of town!
I am trying to convince Tommy the owner to get Dave Portnay to review his pizza!
Great folks and pizza with soon live entertainment during the busy season! What more could you ask for!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza
Had takeout, super yummy. Went to pick it up, wished I had stayed and eaten in house, looked to have a banging vibe & sweet selection on tap.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
On par with best pizza in Whistler. Great beer selection and awesome service.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Spicy Calabrese Pizza, Hawaiian Pizza
Restaurantji Recommends
Choice of 6 toppings on pizza. Was really delicious. Garlic bread and cheese was a letdown.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Very good New York style gluten-free pizza. Well-cooked on top, but the crust was soft enough to fold. The sauce to topping ratio was great, I just wish that the ham stood out a little bit more. It kind of got lost amongst the rest of the pizza. Maybe that’s my fault for ordering a Hawaiian pizza though. Staff was extremely friendly, and it was just a great vibe overall!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We ate here a few years back and it was really good. Was recently in Whistler again and ate here a few more times...I think it may have gotten even better. Hawaiian pizza is awesome and you can't really go wrong with the other options. Good beer selection and the patio area is great when it's nice out. Service was great and friendly! I just hope they are still there next time I go to whistler!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
HandleBar is a gem, in my opinion. I loved their pizza; it’s awesome if you have it made fresh! I had the Spicy Calabrese pizza and it was indeed quite spicy and delicious in every bite. They have a very good beer selection as well (including some ciders), which we enjoyed. The vibe there was very casual and I really liked their tech/pixel design in the interior; it’s pretty cool. If you’re in the mood for good pizza and you’re nearby, you definitely can’t go wrong here.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Spicy Calabrese Pizza
Easy 5 stars for this chill pizza shop. I would highly recommend HandleBar Pizza to anyone in the area. We tried the cheese, pepperoni, Hawaiian, and spicy calabrese and they were all delicious. We really enjoyed the thin crust and flavorful red sauce.
We went during a surprisingly very busy Thursday dinner at 5pm and our server (Lani?) was amazing holding down the fort. She was the only server and was juggling 4 tables inside and about 4 outside. We wanted to order a whole pizza but she told us that the wait time would be 45mins so we grabbed pizza by the slice and a few drinks. I can't wait to return to HandleBar Pizza in Whistler.
Kid-friendliness: Kid friendly. Casual pizza restaurant.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Spicy Calabrese Pizza
Loading...