A Guide to the Best Pizzerias in Milwaukee

Milwaukee is a city known for its beer, cheese, and rich culinary traditions. But alongside bratwurst and cheese curds, it’s also home to some incredible pizza spots. Whether it’s traditional Italian recipes or modern takes with a Wisconsin twist, Milwaukee's pizzerias bring unique flavors and quality to the table. Here are five local favorites where you’ll find memorable slices.

1. Zaffiro’s Pizza

Photo Credit: facebook.com/profile.php?id=100051124370295

Zaffiro’s Pizza is a Milwaukee restaurant, known for its thin-crust style. Opened in 1954, Zaffiro’s has built its reputation on quality, with pizzas that are thin, crispy, and topped generously. The “Special” with sausage, mushrooms, and onions is a popular choice, alongside the "Deluxe" loaded with fresh veggies. People keep coming back for the nostalgia and reliable flavors that make Zaffiro’s feel like home.

Photo Credit: facebook.com/profile.php?id=100051124370295

2. Transfer Pizzeria Café

Photo Credit: instagram.com/transfermke/

Located in a historic building on Milwaukee’s south side, Transfer Pizzeria Café serves up pizza with wide selection of topping. This pizzeria uses fresh ingredients, including Wisconsin cheeses. Their "Fig & Prosciutto" is a standout for those looking for something different, while the "Milwaukeean" includes bratwurst and sauerkraut. Transfer Pizzeria is loved for its community vibe and regular live music nights.

Photo Credit: instagram.com/transfermke/

3. Wy’East Pizza

Photo Credit: instagram.com/wyeastpizza/?hl=en

Wy’East Pizza offers a taste of the Pacific Northwest with a wood-fired approach and chewy, flavorful crust. The "Hot Marmot" with pepperoni, jalapeños, and honey is a favorite, while the “Green Mountain” with pesto and ricotta brings a fresh taste. Locals appreciate Wy’East for its casual setting and high-quality pies.

Photo Credit: instagram.com/wyeastpizza/?hl=en

4. Lisa’s Pizza

Photo Credit: instagram.com/lisaspizzamke/

A Milwaukee staple since 1960, Lisa’s Pizza keeps it classic with Italian-American recipes that have stood the test of time. Known for its hearty, cheesy pizzas, Lisa’s uses rich sauces and fresh toppings, with options like the "Meat Lovers" loaded with sausage, pepperoni, and bacon, and the classic "Margherita." This spot has a warm, familiar feel, making it a go-to for families and long-time locals.

Photo Credit: instagram.com/lisaspizzamke/

5. San Giorgio Pizzeria Napoletana

Photo Credit: instagram.com/sangiorgiopizzerianapoletana/?hl=en

San Giorgio Pizzeria Napoletana is loved for bringing the flavors of Naples to Milwaukee’s downtown. Their pizzas are cooked in a wood-fired oven, giving them a soft, charred crust and rich taste. Their "Margherita" pizza is simple but flavorful, while the "Diavola" offers a spicy kick with Italian sausage and red chili. San Giorgio also features fresh, homemade pasta and traditional Italian desserts, making it a favorite for anyone looking for an authentic Italian meal in the city.