Where to Enjoy Perfect Fruitcake in NYC

Fruitcake has been a holiday favorite for generations. For those who love this classic dessert—or are curious to give it another try—New York City is home to some of the best bakeries and restaurants offering fruitcake in creative and traditional forms. From time-honored recipes to modern twists, here’s where you can find some of the finest fruitcake options in the city.

Baked is a beloved bakery known for its classic American desserts. Founded with the goal of crafting high-quality baked goods, Baked quickly became a favorite among locals. 

Among the many treats they offer, their fruit pies deserve special attention. The bakery uses fresh fruits and natural additives to create juicy, flavorful pies.

While Baked is also famous for its iconic brownies and other desserts, the fruit pies hold a special place on the menu, especially during the holidays. The cozy setting of the bakery invites guests to enjoy a cup of coffee or tea alongside their delicious treats.

Magnolia Bakery, located at 401 Bleecker Street in the West Village, is an iconic establishment that has become synonymous with classic American desserts since its opening in 1996.

The bakery is particularly famous for its cupcakes, which helped spark a nationwide cupcake craze in the late 1990s. In addition to cupcakes, Magnolia Bakery is praised for its banana pudding.

While Magnolia Bakery is best known for these signature items, they also offer a variety of other baked goods, including cookies, pies, and seasonal specialties like fruitcake during the holidays. The fruitcake is crafted with high-quality ingredients and reflects the bakery's commitment to traditional recipes and flavors.

Mah-Ze-Dahr Bakery in New York offers a range of baked goods crafted with attention to detail. Their fruit cake is particularly popular during the holiday season. It reflects a thoughtful approach to traditional recipes while maintaining quality and balance. Customers appreciate the bakery's consistent focus on creating desserts that emphasize flavor and texture.

Balthazar Bakery offers an impressive array of artisanal baked goods, often featuring desserts with a focus on fresh fruits. Located in SoHo, it’s known for its European-style pastries, breads, and seasonal creations. While traditional fruitcake may not be a staple on their menu, the bakery showcases fruit-centered treats like fruit tarts and special holiday items.

Orwasher's Bakery is a charming and historic bakery located on the Upper East Side of Manhattan. Established over a century ago, it has built a reputation for its high-quality baked goods and traditional recipes.

At Orwasher's, you can find a wide variety of fresh-baked products, including artisanal breads, pastries, cookies, and more. One of the highlights of their offerings is their fruitcake. In addition to it, Orwasher's Bakery offers other treats, such as bagels and pastries.