Winner's NY Pizza

Got takeaway small cheese pizza and Philly cheesesteak. The pizza is okay but the cheesesteak is delicious. Get with a side of ranch!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

This pizza is so good! I have to limit my visits there! A must if you love a good 🍕pizza!

As a Jersey girl, I know pizza. It’s just true. Forget about it. Jessica is such a sweetheart and the pizza authentic. I’ll stop by next for a meatball parm or Philly cheese steak next. I always stop for a slice whenever I’m passing through. Thank youuuuu

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Gotta love a neighborhood pizza joint. The pizza is good and is something you're not going to get with the greasy major chains, and has pretty decent pasta options as well.

My favorite thing outside of the pizza is the philly cheesesteak. Make sure you don't get the chicken one because there's just something missing there and was the only thing I wouldn't get again. Follow up is the italian ice which I have to get every time I am here.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

I usually have a picky eater, but not here. We loved the food. The cook did an amazing job and staff Please never let them go. They were wonderful.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

I used to love this place and used to promote it to everyone. The service tonight seemed incapable of getting my order together in an organized and timely fashion - no business sense or experience and no manager on site on a busy Saturday night. I made a call (I live 2 blocks away) for a delivery because I had little kids I was watching. After 3 missed calls because of no mozzarella sticks, they said they would replace w cheesy bread and gave me a total. I said ok. I gave them my card number and was quoted a number. I agreed with the number and gave them my card info to charge that exact number they gave me and I said I would add a cash tip. Somehow my card wasn’t going through (this is 50 minutes after making the order) and we found out they were charging a different amount than what I agreed with so I said that’s not ok - charge me the original amount you quoted and it will go through - it didn’t work, il spending a lot of time on the phone being disappointed time after time - and after an hour of waiting and increasingly hungry children - I got in the car and drove the 2 blocks to pick it up myself - I used the same card and it worked. They tried to charge me yet a different amount - I don’t know why was quoted 3 different prices through all this, and somehow my pizza was stale and they messed up the ravioli order - I asked for meat and got cheese and it was burnt and cold. I had a pretty bad night of going back and forth with a staff who was unable to handle my order. I am very disappointed and I will be contacting the manager. It was a really expensive bad dinner with a side of incapable service. I am still so sad at how I was treated. No business sense.

Service: 1

My all time favorite pizza for 20+ years. The dough, cheese, and sauce are unique to this restaurant and the perfect blend of flavors and textures that I love about pizza. Winners is the gold standard that I judge all other pizzas against. Not to mention their bomber philly sandwiches are as good as it gets as well.
I’ve tried mulberry st in Beverly Hills, Prince st,, Slicehouse and all other NY-style pizzerias around LA, Winners is #1, period.

Thanks to everyone at Winners NY Pizza for keeping your food consistently amazing for all these years!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I come here all the time with my friends and it’s the best cheap/fast pizza in town. The ranch dip with a cheese slice in particular is fantastic!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Don’t get this place confused with the other pizza places called Winners or Tony’s. This place is the only one of its kind and it’s the best!

We eat here at least a couple times a month and it’s always delicious. Their ranch is prize-worthy!

Our favorite pizza place hands down.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Lovely people, great prices and delicious pizza! What's not to like.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I just doordashed a cheesesteak and it was my first time trying this place, i feel like cheesesteak on the west coast is always hit or miss. I called the restaurant to ask for my bread extra crispy, the lady who answered the phone was so nice !! And it was hands down the best cheesesteak ive ever had !! I cant wait to try other stuff on the menu as well !!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Best pizza in our area and lady at the front is genuinely the nicest person ever.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Best Sammy's this side of the Mississippi!!!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

It's one of my favorite pizza and sub shops in Agoura.

Chefs were very nice, owners son took my order and was extremely rude and had didn’t even crack a smile or greet me. Then proceeded to mess up my order and blame the chefs, while soon after leaving and not even solving the problem. Everyone else who works here is usually nice but the owners son is genuinely a lazy worker who drives away customers.