Arcata Pizza & Deli

1057 H St, Arcata
(707) 822-4650

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Lee LeJanic

Stellar pizza by the slice!

Charles Davy

This place lost us as customers tonight. We ordered the halibut and chips to go. We only live 10 minutes away but the chips and fish were not at all hot when we got home. And that's not even talking about the dryness of the fish, over-frying, and bad chips (although there were an extreme amount of them. This was an expensive meal, too, so we are very disappointed in a place we have been to before and liked.

Phil Arnot

The pizza was straight trash. I ordered a Hawaiian and the crust was so thin, the pizza could not support its own weight.

Althea Grimes

What the heck happened to their Margherita pie?? 😭 I've always really enjoyed APD's Margherita pie—and appreciate that this is one of the relatively uncommon joints where it's even a menu offering—but this looks absolutely NOTHING like the advertised photo (picture #2) nor comparable to anything I've received in various past orders here. The tomatoes here are thick, uncooked, and seemingly thrown on top as afterthoughts, while the cheese slices look laughably cheap and hardly cover a cumulative ~60% of the pizza. You missed a spot, y'all!
At the very least, the experience wasn't entirely inoffensive thanks to the still well-crafted crust (though it's plausible to worry when they'll cut corners on this, too) and natural pleasant potency of fresh basil... these ingredients will always go well together even at their worst, but that's a really unfortunate way to feel about a $40 delivery from a (formerly) reputable local favorite!!
If this is how APD does their pizza now... fine, I guess, but I certainly would have considered my patronage differently had I known. This just isn't the standard I've come to expect from APD.
Guess it's time to hunt down a new favorite Margherita pie :(

Bryan

Well went in late drove for 3 to pickup my daughter's boyfriend who is going to college there.
Before heading home the 3 hour ride home we stop in to fill up for a nonstop drive home.

šŸ• was fabulous thanks guys.
It did take a bit long to make but well worth it. Just don't lag on getting to good out

David Shinabarger

Sandwiches are a 10/10 and the Smoked Salmon Soup was some of the best soup I've ever had.

nichole hoge

Local place big servings good food

Jacob ā€œBurritoā€ Thornburg

The pizza has a little more bread than cheese for my preference, but it’s pizza. So it’s still pretty good.

Elizabeth Hadden

My partner and I went here to celebrate a birthday, we had to wait 20 minutes for our food and they never called our names. When we finally got the food it was cold and the fries were terrible. None of it was fresh. The service was poor, we asked to dine in and the order was given to go. Not worth it for the high prices. Won’t be returning.

Robert Toops

Philly cheese to die for.

Sherbet

Good serving sizes, burgers are better at lunch time. I always get the Swiss mushroom

Ryu Xi

Be careful of multiple charges! I paid for my order. The manager Maggie argued with me that it didn't go through. I showed her my phone confirmations. She wanted me to pay again! I refused and she told the kitchen to not make my order. Long story short, 4 days later the charge did show up on my credit card. I had to go out of my way to get a refund. And I will never ever forget the horrible customer experience provided by Maggie, one of the most incompetent managers I have ever met.

Ahren Haedrich

Food is great but why don't they heat? It's freezing in here!!

Caroline Buster-Brown

Fish and chips were awesome, everybody loved their pizza, and the specialty craft beer menu is something else. They'll even let you try what's on tap if you haven't had it. The raspberry lambic was great.

Andy Smith

Best pizza ever!

Loading...