For the price I expect better. So the food was decent my dad got a roast beef, great. However I order the Rueben, my mistake. The ingredients were good the execution was not. The meat is microwaved and the sauerkraut was placed directly on to unheated bread creating a mushy mess. The gal making it even noticed asking another person and they said “whatever.” My sandwich literally fell apart even when wrapped in paper.
Braxton Barrett
Best sandwich I’ve had in years. This place knows how to stack ‘em.
Ezra Bowers
Their only vegan option is a PB&J, and vegetarian options are just as scarce. The local tofu shop closed down and instead of switching to a new supplier they have instead opted to cut their plant-based menu items almost entirely.
I’m rating them 1 star not out of malice but because 1 star ratings are more visible, and I want other folks who might be looking at outdated reviews and menus to know that they are no longer vegan or vegetarian friendly.
Hideki Kimura
Excellent food and service. Gigantic sandwiches 🥪 😋
Todd Ellingson
I get a sandwich from hole in the wall about once a week. This week I ordered a Italian combo on Brio French it ended up being on Dutch crunch I ordered mayo on both sides and got it on only one side and I asked for super light lettuce and lettuce made up 1/3 of the sandwich. SMH I'm done with this place for a while
Jeanine Manatad
Great sandwich. Very flavorful, lots of meat and fixings. Very cool atmosphere.
Chris Trunkey
I’m on a Torta mission! I was turned on to the fact that Hole In The Wall has one on the menu. Today made 31 Tortas from 31 different locations just in Humboldt County. This Torta was very delicious. The cilantro really set it off and the jalapeños were actually spicy! The Brio French roll was a fresh change from the typical Telera roll on most Tortas.
Kelly Russell
The best and freshest sandwiches. It’s a must every time we are in the area 10/10
Kit Crane
This is a great spot and is easily in my top 3 favorite restaurants in town. The only reason I opt not to give them a full 5 stars is because they don't offer half size sandwiches. I would honestly eat here WAY more often, if I could order half a sandwich. Hole In The Wall, I love you, your team is great, the food is great, the selections is great, the location is great, but please please please consider offering smaller sandwich sizes.
This place came recommended by an old friend and it lived up to the hype. Sweet as old gas station converted to a sandwich shop. I dig it!
Great sandwich that was too much for me to eat.
Will definitely go again.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Brian Caldwell
The sandwiches were awesome. My mom used to take me after school. Love it!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Luka Schuller
Hole in the Wall makes subs the exact way I like them. Thinly shredded lettuce and thinly sliced onion and tomato with salt, pepper, oil, and vinegar give such a crunchy, fresh texture and offset the heavier meat and bread to create the ultimate sub. I absolutely ADORE this place and could easily eat there every day for the rest of my life if i could afford it.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sandwich
Charles Dumont
I ordered from this restaurant twice while visiting Arcata recently. I only intended on visiting once, but returned again because my first sandwich was so good. The folks working there were both professional and friendly. I hope to eat here again when I'm the area next. I'm baffled as to why some folks don't like this place. No gloves? Who cares. I saw the workers washing their hands multiple times. Would you rather they create pounds of non-biodegradable plastic glove waste every day? Too pricy? Then go to Subway down the road or make your own sandwich.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loren Osborn
The muffuletta really was a “great sandwich”, the shop holds up its name. Second best sandwich I’ve ever had. I ate it in a grove at Ave of the Giants so maybe there was some magic in that but tbh I was shocked at just how fantastic the sandwich tasted!! It’ll be living rent free in my mind.
For the price I expect better. So the food was decent my dad got a roast beef, great. However I order the Rueben, my mistake. The ingredients were good the execution was not. The meat is microwaved and the sauerkraut was placed directly on to unheated bread creating a mushy mess. The gal making it even noticed asking another person and they said “whatever.” My sandwich literally fell apart even when wrapped in paper.
Best sandwich I’ve had in years. This place knows how to stack ‘em.
Their only vegan option is a PB&J, and vegetarian options are just as scarce. The local tofu shop closed down and instead of switching to a new supplier they have instead opted to cut their plant-based menu items almost entirely.
I’m rating them 1 star not out of malice but because 1 star ratings are more visible, and I want other folks who might be looking at outdated reviews and menus to know that they are no longer vegan or vegetarian friendly.
Excellent food and service. Gigantic sandwiches 🥪 😋
I get a sandwich from hole in the wall about once a week. This week I ordered a Italian combo on Brio French it ended up being on Dutch crunch I ordered mayo on both sides and got it on only one side and I asked for super light lettuce and lettuce made up 1/3 of the sandwich. SMH I'm done with this place for a while
Great sandwich. Very flavorful, lots of meat and fixings. Very cool atmosphere.
I’m on a Torta mission! I was turned on to the fact that Hole In The Wall has one on the menu. Today made 31 Tortas from 31 different locations just in Humboldt County. This Torta was very delicious. The cilantro really set it off and the jalapeños were actually spicy! The Brio French roll was a fresh change from the typical Telera roll on most Tortas.
The best and freshest sandwiches. It’s a must every time we are in the area 10/10
This is a great spot and is easily in my top 3 favorite restaurants in town. The only reason I opt not to give them a full 5 stars is because they don't offer half size sandwiches. I would honestly eat here WAY more often, if I could order half a sandwich. Hole In The Wall, I love you, your team is great, the food is great, the selections is great, the location is great, but please please please consider offering smaller sandwich sizes.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
One of my favorites. Always great sandwiches.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sourdough Roll, Sandwich, Muffuletta
Restaurantji Recommends
This place came recommended by an old friend and it lived up to the hype. Sweet as old gas station converted to a sandwich shop. I dig it!
Great sandwich that was too much for me to eat.
Will definitely go again.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The sandwiches were awesome. My mom used to take me after school. Love it!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Hole in the Wall makes subs the exact way I like them. Thinly shredded lettuce and thinly sliced onion and tomato with salt, pepper, oil, and vinegar give such a crunchy, fresh texture and offset the heavier meat and bread to create the ultimate sub. I absolutely ADORE this place and could easily eat there every day for the rest of my life if i could afford it.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sandwich
I ordered from this restaurant twice while visiting Arcata recently. I only intended on visiting once, but returned again because my first sandwich was so good.
The folks working there were both professional and friendly. I hope to eat here again when I'm the area next.
I'm baffled as to why some folks don't like this place.
No gloves? Who cares. I saw the workers washing their hands multiple times. Would you rather they create pounds of non-biodegradable plastic glove waste every day?
Too pricy? Then go to Subway down the road or make your own sandwich.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The muffuletta really was a “great sandwich”, the shop holds up its name. Second best sandwich I’ve ever had. I ate it in a grove at Ave of the Giants so maybe there was some magic in that but tbh I was shocked at just how fantastic the sandwich tasted!! It’ll be living rent free in my mind.
Loading...