Pauls Live From New York Pizza Arcata

The service here is extremely poor. Going up to the counter, the lady behind the register didn’t even acknowledge us until we had been standing there for several minutes. She seemed annoyed at our presence. We ordered a slice of pizza, which was premade and on display. Despite ordering something that was ready to go, our order still took 10 minutes to fulfill, and the man handling the food did not wear gloves. I would not return here again, but my boyfriend thought the pizza tasted good!

Very cool staff. They helped me figure out what I wanted to eat. Also they pour a mean beer! Thank you!

NY style pizza. We went early afternoon, they have a pizza slice special, drink, and salad. Slices are on display, they heat them up and serve in a jiffy.

$70 for two large pizzas is a rip off….BUT…it’s the only decent pizza for hundreds of miles that will be anything like what you get in the northeast. So it is what it is.

I hate to do this because I really love this place, but this was honestly a little disturbing. I ordered a GF pizza. I happened to be inside when they were making it and the guy took out the box and put it on the counter where he makes the pizzas on the board and put my GF crust on top of the box and then put a plastic lid on top of my crust. I asked one of them if that pie was for me and if they wouldn’t mind being a little more sanitary. He said he’d let him know. I watched him tell his coworker to which his coworker threw away the crust and took out another one and again put it on top of the box. I just don’t get it. I’ve been in the industry and I would never in a million years do this especially if customers can see you. Found it incredibly disrespectful. I was really excited about dinner. I hope that the owner will see this and make sure the employees are aware of health code.

It's real pizza 🍕 on the north coast

Great little pizza joint. One large fed us all. Staff was nice. We didn't feel rushed even with our late arrival.

Omg love their pizza!! 😋

It's good but not as good as the Eureka location. Still, 2nd best pizza joint on the North Coast

Wowzer! Incredible pizza! My new favorite pizza place. Great family location. Super large pizza. Very tasty! Great staff. Great vibe.

usually love this place but… how is this ok?

Great pizza place. Wide variety with 7 choices. Local btewery beers on tap

Kid-friendliness: Indoor and out side

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Godfather Pizza Slice, Pesto Pizza, Pepperoni Pizza

Best pizza in town...

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza

Best New York slice in Nor Cal.

Vegetarian options: The best veggie pizza in my opinion is the "Sunset" pineapple, sundried tomato, and basil. So good!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cannoli, Godfather Pizza Slice, Hawaiian Pizza with Jalapeños, Pepperoni Pizza, Garlic Knots

Fried ravioli

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4