Papa Johns Pizza

1901 N Buhach Rd, Atwater
(209) 676-4125

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Anon Kritiker

Ordered 2 large pizza. Total came out to 60 bucks and we were wanting to split the payment in half. However this lady serving us did not speak English and also had a rude attitude. I took 2 cards out to show her that I wanted to split the payment in half. She still didn't understand and just told me the total. I then say the total and divide that by 2...meaning to split the total amount. It was very frustrating to speak with her. Very poor customer service. If she did not understand me, why not ask for the manager? Anyway they need to train their staff more.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 5

Service: 1

Recommended dishes: Extra Large New York Style Pizza

Jamal Jones

Rude angry Indian lady who can't read or speak English. More than 25 minutes wait time for one small pizza and some bread sticks, they do not wear gloves (dirty).

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Muse Phyre

I came for the breadsticks and the garlic dipping sauce and was not disappointed. Though, the location tag on Google Maps initially led me to a private residence. I was able to call for location details and found that it is next to the Arco on Avenue Two. Breadsticks were great, dipping sauce was , and the jalapeño cheese bites made me sweat ?. Service was great, no notes. Delighted to come through again for my next craving.

Vegetarian options: Veggie pizza, jalapeño cheese bites

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Jalapeño Papa Bites 8pc

April Sanchez Hernandez

The lady was nice, the pizza was great. We tried the Hawaiian pizza half with bacon and the other half with ham and the new cuppy pepperoni pizza. Great choices. ?

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 4

Ren7ee

I stopped going there. The last time I ordered a pizza from there, they were very chintzy on the meat. I got about five pieces of salami dispersed throughout the pizza, as if I wouldn't notice.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 3

Daniel Avila

Absolutely Terrible Service Slow as he'll of Delivery didn't bring the order to the right address ?

Peter Jogry (Pete)

It's disgusting how they make pizza. I watched as a delivery driver came in after a delivery and started tossing dough over her arms hair and all. It's the same way all of the employees make pizza. The workers didnt have my food ready and told me it was already picked up. They told me it was going to be a wait since somebody stole my order. I asked why did you give my order to someone else and they said the person gave my same name. What!? Now Im confused how did they know my name and order? Inside job! After I called them out, I seen one of the workers smile and put their head down in shame. I told them just cancel the order. After that and seeing unclean habits I'm done.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

paola diaz

I love their pizza ! I think their first deals are amazing and not to mention the pizza is always tasty. I’ve never had an issue. Every time I order carry out or delivery my order is accurate. Not to mention one time I ordered carry out but couldn’t get out the car as I had my child asleep in the car. I called them when I arrived and asked if they could bring my order out. They did and I was so thankful!

Food: 5

Service: 4

Rafael Zelaya

Dietary restrictions: None

Parking: Plenty of parking spaces

Kid-friendliness: Kids loved the food

Wheelchair accessibility: Ramp available

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Kim G

Waited awhile before they open but fresh food hot and delicious 😋🤤

Joshua

I've been waiting months and several visits to review this place as it's brand new to the community and wanted the kinks to be ironed out. Here it is:Papa John's as a company has declined in its marketing, quality, and taste. However, this location has stepped it up, in the beginning the pizza was really greasy and the quality was poor and so was the customer service (when recently opened), since then the quality has gone up, pizza has been way better (although they could be more generous with toppings - skimpy even when ordering extra), and the customer service has been amazing!Each time there has been an issue (2 liter forgotten, missed item in order) they've been very helpful and made it right. On top of that, although it says "curbside pickup" that isn't something offered by this location or in it's app, but when I really needed them to come through for me and bring the pizza to my car, they had no problem with it. I genuinely hope they continue to keep this up and prove the public wrong about their chain. The local community needs better customer service and good quality places to visit and right now this place is on that list.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Alessandro Pagani

Dad, my favorite

courtney cerra

Delivery: Yes

Danny

Husky is the best pizza

Kimberly “Kim” Gray

Waited awhile before they open but fresh food hot and delicious ??

Loading...