I went to lunch today and the pizza was so good! We been eating at Pizza Pirate for year and always liked it, but today was the absolute best pizza we ever had from Pizza Pirate. The staff were really friendly and I got a chance to meet the new owner which I really enjoyed chatting with. We can’t wait to go back!
Mohita Traveler
The pizza wasn’t very impressive and felt overpriced. It was mostly thick bread with a lot of cheese, but lacked flavorful sauces or spices. Compared to places like Pieology, MOD, or Blaze, it just didn’t have as much taste or variety. Otherwise, the place was clean and the staff were friendly.
Rosemary Long
Pizza Pirate is our go to place...and we go often. The food is delicious, hot and plentiful. The staff are always friendly and personable. Zoe is one of the very best. She has been at PP for quite a few years and is always pleasant and efficient. We look forward to seeing her!
Autumn Fury
We just moved to the area and Pizza Pirate was recommended to me by a friend. Since it was our first night in town, and all of our dishes were packed, we decided to try it out. We placed our pick up order via the website, and 35 minutes later I made the lengthy 3 minute drive (lol) to pick up our dinner. The inside of the building was super cool, I even saw a claw machine with Squishmallows that I’ll attempt to win in the future, and both staff members I interacted with were incredibly friendly. Upon arriving at home the food was promptly devoured, everyone agreed it was some of the best pizza we’ve had in a while. We also got their garlic bread, which was seriously some of the best I’ve had in a while. The half spaghetti came with 2 garlic twists and the portion was enough for my son and I to split, with a price point you can’t beat. We will definitely be hitting up Pizza Pirate again in the future!
John P
It's a decent pizzeria..not many like it left
Sonja Cornell
Love Pirates and Pizza. Reasonable price.
Jacob Menjivar
Great quality food and amazing service. Great place for the family and for amazing eats! Making this place a weekly thing!
Jeremy Wong
Pizza pirate has always been great in benicia but especially now with the new ownership group! Chad and his team have really cleaned the place up and continue to provide the great pizza and pasta quality you would expect!
Duckette Gaming (Ducky)
Kid-friendliness: They have a mini arcade inside
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Walk the Plank
Alejandra Baladón
Loved their food. But they seriously need a Deep Cleaning from top to bottom of the whole place. There is way too much dust in ceilings, walls, chains, ceiling fans bathrooms needs a very deep cleaning.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Lagunitas Craft Beer, All Meat Pizza, Captains Combo, Combination Pizza, Spicy Hot Wings
Late lunch treat at one of the oldest and coolest local pizza establishments! Though I miss the salad bar, the service is still exceptional, awesome pirate decor from decades ago and... delicious pizza! ? ? Can't wait to sit around the fireplace when it starts to chill.
Jesse is the hidden gem in this place. First if all the food is amazing and the service is just as amazing. YOU WILL LOVE IT HERE ????. Jesse made the experience amazing and was super attentive and kind towards my family and I. Give that man a raise!!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: All You Can Eat Salad, Pepperoni Pizza, All Meat Pizza, Garlic Bread Salad Bar, Spicy Hot Wings
The black Cat
First of all the atmosphere is awesome.super super cool pirate stuff the food is better then Abby’s or any other pizza place price is like every other pizza place the service was really good we got our food within 10 minutes and when we left the younger people behind the bar were super respectful and overall 5 out of 5 ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Maricel Kinsella
We love that it takes us back to those 90s pizza parlors you would go to after a game with friends or on Friday night as treat with your family. Like the decor, the kids running the place, the pizzas themselves, and just the whole local vibey atmosphere...all so reminiscent of the simpler times :)
I went to lunch today and the pizza was so good! We been eating at Pizza Pirate for year and always liked it, but today was the absolute best pizza we ever had from Pizza Pirate. The staff were really friendly and I got a chance to meet the new owner which I really enjoyed chatting with. We can’t wait to go back!
The pizza wasn’t very impressive and felt overpriced. It was mostly thick bread with a lot of cheese, but lacked flavorful sauces or spices. Compared to places like Pieology, MOD, or Blaze, it just didn’t have as much taste or variety. Otherwise, the place was clean and the staff were friendly.
Pizza Pirate is our go to place...and we go often. The food is delicious, hot and plentiful. The staff are always friendly and personable. Zoe is one of the very best. She has been at PP for quite a few years and is always pleasant and efficient. We look forward to seeing her!
We just moved to the area and Pizza Pirate was recommended to me by a friend. Since it was our first night in town, and all of our dishes were packed, we decided to try it out. We placed our pick up order via the website, and 35 minutes later I made the lengthy 3 minute drive (lol) to pick up our dinner. The inside of the building was super cool, I even saw a claw machine with Squishmallows that I’ll attempt to win in the future, and both staff members I interacted with were incredibly friendly. Upon arriving at home the food was promptly devoured, everyone agreed it was some of the best pizza we’ve had in a while. We also got their garlic bread, which was seriously some of the best I’ve had in a while. The half spaghetti came with 2 garlic twists and the portion was enough for my son and I to split, with a price point you can’t beat. We will definitely be hitting up Pizza Pirate again in the future!
It's a decent pizzeria..not many like it left
Love Pirates and Pizza. Reasonable price.
Great quality food and amazing service. Great place for the family and for amazing eats! Making this place a weekly thing!
Pizza pirate has always been great in benicia but especially now with the new ownership group! Chad and his team have really cleaned the place up and continue to provide the great pizza and pasta quality you would expect!
Kid-friendliness: They have a mini arcade inside
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Walk the Plank
Loved their food. But they seriously need a Deep Cleaning from top to bottom of the whole place. There is way too much dust in ceilings, walls, chains, ceiling fans bathrooms needs a very deep cleaning.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Lagunitas Craft Beer, All Meat Pizza, Captains Combo, Combination Pizza, Spicy Hot Wings
Restaurantji Recommends
Late lunch treat at one of the oldest and coolest local pizza establishments! Though I miss the salad bar, the service is still exceptional, awesome pirate decor from decades ago and... delicious pizza! ? ? Can't wait to sit around the fireplace when it starts to chill.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Lagunitas Craft Beer, Pepperoni Pizza
Best pizza for kids in Benicia lots of games
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jesse is the hidden gem in this place. First if all the food is amazing and the service is just as amazing. YOU WILL LOVE IT HERE ????. Jesse made the experience amazing and was super attentive and kind towards my family and I. Give that man a raise!!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: All You Can Eat Salad, Pepperoni Pizza, All Meat Pizza, Garlic Bread Salad Bar, Spicy Hot Wings
First of all the atmosphere is awesome.super super cool pirate stuff the food is better then Abby’s or any other pizza place price is like every other pizza place the service was really good we got our food within 10 minutes and when we left the younger people behind the bar were super respectful and overall 5 out of 5 ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We love that it takes us back to those 90s pizza parlors you would go to after a game with friends or on Friday night as treat with your family. Like the decor, the kids running the place, the pizzas themselves, and just the whole local vibey atmosphere...all so reminiscent of the simpler times :)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 4
Loading...