Quickly made my online order of bbq chicken before the due time. The staff were attentive and considerate, even made relevant small talk which getting me checked out. The place was clean and orderly, felt a bright and crisp vibe throughout the experience.
Chloe R.
Unfortunately I had a less than great experience at this location. They had maybe two workers on a busy spring break day at the beach. The line didn't move for over 30 minutes. You could call in orders or order online, but if you wanted a slice you were basically out of luck. Many people left the line and it still was at a stand still. They definitely needed more staff to accommodate the crowd. My kids were upset we packed up and went to the Santa Cruz location where we could sit down and enjoy pizza by the slice so everyone could get what they wanted.
Karen C.
I recently got an early dinner here. The line was out of the door as it was spring break and the beach was packed. They did not have enough staff. I don't think they planned for the spring break crowd. But the line went pretty quickly. They had plenty of slices to choose from. I got a slice of mushroom. They warmed it up in the pizza oven. They were out of the Greek salad so I got the Caesar. I asked for ranch dressing since I hate Caesar dressing. The salad was tasty. Dipped my pizza crust in the ranch. Overall a nice meal.
Frank Flentye
As close to New York Pizza I have had, not in NY. Pizza was delicious, location was beautiful! Must try!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Dominik S.
This place has been a staple of the community since I was a kid. It's been consistently delicious and never disappoints! I recommend the Big Sur.
Casey M.
Caleb and crew are amazing. We come year round but they are the best summer spot by far. Be sure to snag a shirt while they last.
Paul H.
Walked in the door & immediately greeted The selection of pies were well displayed and the staff were very pleasant and welcoming as well Take note all you business owners out there this is how a pizza place should be Thin slices , fresh and served hot Dining area was well attended to as well considering it was busy and a Friday night I much rather give my money to a place that knows how to run their store than to other places that could give 2 chits Friday night staff. Y' all got it going on !
Cindy Nelson
We enjoyed the really good customer service and the really good pizza ? ?
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza
Andrew V
Top notch pizza served at a window on the beach. What's not to
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Big Sur Pizza, Pizza, Little Sur
(Plant-based reviewer) Yes! They have VEGAN pizza! I'm not a fan of Beyond meat, but it is available along with Miyokos vegan mozzarella. For dairy lovers, they also have pizza by the slice. Highly recommend this spot!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Toné Duarte
Love this original Pizza My Heart restaurant! ? They make a great Pesto pizza amongst other great pizzas.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Boo B.
Omg!! Such good pizzas. I got two- one was the veggies one with artichokes- sooo good. The other was their specialty one. That was decent but veggies won hands down. Great for the road or chill at the beach.
Elizabeth I.
Very good pizza. We came here the other day and I got a slice of their awesome tasty Hawaiian pizza.Very yummy I recommend this place
Quickly made my online order of bbq chicken before the due time. The staff were attentive and considerate, even made relevant small talk which getting me checked out. The place was clean and orderly, felt a bright and crisp vibe throughout the experience.
Unfortunately I had a less than great experience at this location. They had maybe two workers on a busy spring break day at the beach. The line didn't move for over 30 minutes. You could call in orders or order online, but if you wanted a slice you were basically out of luck. Many people left the line and it still was at a stand still. They definitely needed more staff to accommodate the crowd. My kids were upset we packed up and went to the Santa Cruz location where we could sit down and enjoy pizza by the slice so everyone could get what they wanted.
I recently got an early dinner here. The line was out of the door as it was spring break and the beach was packed. They did not have enough staff. I don't think they planned for the spring break crowd. But the line went pretty quickly. They had plenty of slices to choose from. I got a slice of mushroom. They warmed it up in the pizza oven. They were out of the Greek salad so I got the Caesar. I asked for ranch dressing since I hate Caesar dressing. The salad was tasty. Dipped my pizza crust in the ranch. Overall a nice meal.
As close to New York Pizza I have had, not in NY. Pizza was delicious, location was beautiful! Must try!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This place has been a staple of the community since I was a kid. It's been consistently delicious and never disappoints! I recommend the Big Sur.
Caleb and crew are amazing. We come year round but they are the best summer spot by far. Be sure to snag a shirt while they last.
Walked in the door & immediately greeted The selection of pies were well displayed and the staff were very pleasant and welcoming as well Take note all you business owners out there this is how a pizza place should be Thin slices , fresh and served hot Dining area was well attended to as well considering it was busy and a Friday night I much rather give my money to a place that knows how to run their store than to other places that could give 2 chits Friday night staff. Y' all got it going on !
We enjoyed the really good customer service and the really good pizza ? ?
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza
Top notch pizza served at a window on the beach. What's not to
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Big Sur Pizza, Pizza, Little Sur
Going to Capitola, gotta go to Pizza My Heart!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza
Restaurantji Recommends
Great t-
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
(Plant-based reviewer) Yes! They have VEGAN pizza! I'm not a fan of Beyond meat, but it is available along with Miyokos vegan mozzarella. For dairy lovers, they also have pizza by the slice. Highly recommend this spot!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Love this original Pizza My Heart restaurant! ? They make a great Pesto pizza amongst other great pizzas.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Omg!! Such good pizzas. I got two- one was the veggies one with artichokes- sooo good. The other was their specialty one. That was decent but veggies won hands down. Great for the road or chill at the beach.
Very good pizza. We came here the other day and I got a slice of their awesome tasty Hawaiian pizza.Very yummy I recommend this place