Wow, what a delicious, delightful restaurant. So glad I got to experience the food and delightful service ☺
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sloan W.
completely messed up my order rendering it inedible (half anchovies on an XL pizza). Despite my proof from the receipt, they would not agree to a refund.
Loren W.
Confirmed my order twice all meat extra cheese jalapeños on half a jalapeños and cheese only pizza called for them to fix it a guy the manager tried to make it my fault instead of saying let us get you one they said it's a different price it's more. I don't care about the money but not my mistake. I run a auto repair shop and got turned on to this place by the owner when I would give him a ride home he would give me a free pizza coupon and I've always ordered from them ever since. But it's not Having a problem or a mistake that is the problem it's how you bounce back from that mistake that matters. Sorry Bob your staff didn't get it right this time
Mabel Guzman
The pizzas are very delicious...we always take Stefano's...recommended...
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lindsey Smith
I usually go to the mill valley location but went to this one because i ordered through too good to go. They gave me cheese pizza and it was great. Nice
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Yanro Álvarez
It is the best pizzeria here in San Rafael California from my point of view as a Guatemalan if you are from Guatemala try it. This. Pizza will remind you of
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Nash Holcomb
This place has been here for YEARS and it’s always been wonderful! If you’re the type who likes to just get a single or a couple slices of a specific pizza, this is that type of pizzeria and it’s frankly one of the best in Marin. Yeah everyone says the west coast can’t do pizza very well compared to NYC or Chicago but I’d say at least give this place a fair try before you judge!
Anthony Pham
Me and my friends wanted a good pizza place to eat at, and we tried Stefano’s Pizza. We ordered a pepperoni pizza. The pizza was very very cheesy and delicious. They put the perfect amount of pepperoni on there and overall was just absolutely delicious and amazing.
Ben Bowler
Pesto veggie delight pizza is delicious! Pizza was ready on time, online ordering was super easy, and they were friendly and helpful in the store. Great job Stefano’s!
Sheila C.
Amazing pizza and the staff are incredible! Very consistent fresh ingredients! Highly recommend!
Great little pizza shop. Not many good priced deals around, but this is definitely a great deal 2 slices and a drink for 7 dollars. Pizza is delicious.
L P.
We've eaten at Stefano's for 30 years- practically raised our kids on it every Friday night. Unfortunately the quality just gets worse and worse... time and again we order thick crust (long been our favorite) and it's burned on the bottom and the toppings, and RAW on the inside. When we try regular crust it's slightly better, but the toppings are not always fresh and we never know if it's going to be too hard to bite into. The prices keep going UP and UP, it is the most expensive pizza ever for what it is- out of town visitors can't believe what we pay for a pie. Used to love the coupons, 2 for 1's, etc- now they just keep expanding stores and raising prices and forgetting about customer service and quality. So sad to be looking for a new favorite pizza joint. Any recommendations?
Makayla P.
My partner and I love Stefano's. We have eaten pizza across the USA and nothing compares to Stefano's. Wish we could have Stefano's everywhere we go
Andy G.
I've unfortunately ordered pizza from this specific pizzeria several times now and have had serious issues. One time they delivered the wrong pizza, then refused to make/ deliver another one. The manager was extremely confrontational and after a long phone call finally sent me another pizza. after a while I tried this place again, the salad was old, the lettuce had pink along the inside, tomatoes were mushy, and the pizza was not eatable. after about 40 minutes, both my child and I became super sick. I called and the manager basically said it's not his problem and did not care. I will never eat here again nor would I recommend anybody else as food poisoning, and dealing with extremely rude staff is not worth the trouble.
Wow, what a delicious, delightful restaurant. So glad I got to experience the food and delightful service ☺
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
completely messed up my order rendering it inedible (half anchovies on an XL pizza). Despite my proof from the receipt, they would not agree to a refund.
Confirmed my order twice all meat extra cheese jalapeños on half a jalapeños and cheese only pizza called for them to fix it a guy the manager tried to make it my fault instead of saying let us get you one they said it's a different price it's more. I don't care about the money but not my mistake. I run a auto repair shop and got turned on to this place by the owner when I would give him a ride home he would give me a free pizza coupon and I've always ordered from them ever since. But it's not Having a problem or a mistake that is the problem it's how you bounce back from that mistake that matters. Sorry Bob your staff didn't get it right this time
The pizzas are very delicious...we always take Stefano's...recommended...
Food: 5
Service: 5
I usually go to the mill valley location but went to this one because i ordered through too good to go. They gave me cheese pizza and it was great. Nice
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
It is the best pizzeria here in San Rafael California from my point of view as a Guatemalan if you are from Guatemala try it. This. Pizza will remind you of
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This place has been here for YEARS and it’s always been wonderful! If you’re the type who likes to just get a single or a couple slices of a specific pizza, this is that type of pizzeria and it’s frankly one of the best in Marin. Yeah everyone says the west coast can’t do pizza very well compared to NYC or Chicago but I’d say at least give this place a fair try before you judge!
Me and my friends wanted a good pizza place to eat at, and we tried Stefano’s Pizza. We ordered a pepperoni pizza. The pizza was very very cheesy and delicious. They put the perfect amount of pepperoni on there and overall was just absolutely delicious and amazing.
Pesto veggie delight pizza is delicious! Pizza was ready on time, online ordering was super easy, and they were friendly and helpful in the store. Great job Stefano’s!
Amazing pizza and the staff are incredible! Very consistent fresh ingredients! Highly recommend!
Restaurantji Recommends
Great little pizza shop. Not many good priced deals around, but this is definitely a great deal 2 slices and a drink for 7 dollars. Pizza is delicious.
We've eaten at Stefano's for 30 years- practically raised our kids on it every Friday night. Unfortunately the quality just gets worse and worse... time and again we order thick crust (long been our favorite) and it's burned on the bottom and the toppings, and RAW on the inside. When we try regular crust it's slightly better, but the toppings are not always fresh and we never know if it's going to be too hard to bite into. The prices keep going UP and UP, it is the most expensive pizza ever for what it is- out of town visitors can't believe what we pay for a pie. Used to love the coupons, 2 for 1's, etc- now they just keep expanding stores and raising prices and forgetting about customer service and quality. So sad to be looking for a new favorite pizza joint. Any recommendations?
My partner and I love Stefano's. We have eaten pizza across the USA and nothing compares to Stefano's. Wish we could have Stefano's everywhere we go
I've unfortunately ordered pizza from this specific pizzeria several times now and have had serious issues. One time they delivered the wrong pizza, then refused to make/ deliver another one. The manager was extremely confrontational and after a long phone call finally sent me another pizza. after a while I tried this place again, the salad was old, the lettuce had pink along the inside, tomatoes were mushy, and the pizza was not eatable. after about 40 minutes, both my child and I became super sick. I called and the manager basically said it's not his problem and did not care. I will never eat here again nor would I recommend anybody else as food poisoning, and dealing with extremely rude staff is not worth the trouble.
Good pizza. Decent lunch deal. Huge Caeser salad.