Pie Trap Pizza

720 Arrow Hwy Suite A, Covina
(626) 541-0051

Recent Reviews

Nikki A

Uhm why did it take so long for me to try this place? The pizza is so good!!! Then crispy it doesn’t flop when you hold it up! Reminds me of a New York style pizza! They sell individual slices, but they didn’t have the flavor that we wanted! We tried the white gurll with a side of hot honey and ranch! WOW! It was really good ! It looks like they share seating with the brewery next-door so there’s a lot of space to sit with some arcade games!! Definitely definitely coming back! Great service too ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Hot Honey, Slice of Pizza

Candace Vinje

Amazing pizza! Omar took great care of us and was at the top of his customer service game. Happy to see such a great spot doing well in my hometown.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Xxplosive

David Cho

Let me start by saying that I think the rating would be higher if we bought a fresh whole pie. This review is based on slices. Prefer the NY slices better than the thick square for sure. The square was a little dry for me, but the slice was just right. The options were also limited, so we got a slice of cheese (best of the bunch), and Xxplosive (good, but I’m a simple guy and just pep would have been fine), then the square with pep only. All really good, but plain pep or cheese slices for me next time or will try a whole pie if I can only get my GF to agree on toppings, which probably won’t happen :), so appreciate the slice options. Service was fast and friendly and deserves a few more trips to round out my review.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Dave Henson Jr.

Amazing pizza. The best within 30-40 miles. One of the top 5 in the LA area for sure. And they have a great brewery attached. 5 stars for me.

misael castaneda

Hands down the best pizza I've had ! They've got a really great selection of whole pizzas and pizza by the slice. I would recommend the notorious pep, I get it on a weekly basis. They have great service usually in and out of there within a couple of minutes, but you can always expect it to be busy on the weekends especially in the afternoon. They have doorway connecting them to the brewery so it's a great atmosphere to sit back relax and enjoy your pizza. Would definitely recommend it to anybody looking for a good quality pizza in the area.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Hot Honey, Specialty Slice, Garlic Balls

Danielle Rivas

As good as the reviews say!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Cory Ray Puryear

outta 5 this place it’s as close to the top as you can possibly get. The food was superb the tired it was honestly amazing like from the host to is just

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Michelle Hickman

Pizza is delicious! If you want thick crust order Detroit style! Get their honey and try it on your pizza it’s delicious!

Luis De santiago

Fire pizza drove 1:30 from redondo beach

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Sebastian Boetticher

So incredibly good l've found my death row final meal. Hands down the best pizza l've ever had; scratch that, the best MEAL I've had in my 30 years. The crust deserves to be in the Smithsonian museum that's how off the charts good it is. Paul & Sean are true masters ofthe trade and are even better dudes (if that's even possible). You, as the reader, may not believe me when I say this, but their NY- and Detroit-style pizzas brought me to tears as I soaked up the ambiance and watched these two masters at work. I don't usually write reviews but I could write a whole book about this unbelievable culinary experience I was privileged to. I'Il be coming back on the weekly or more often, even though there are like 50+ pizza shops that are closer to where I live.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Hny N.

great ambience, nice pizza, no veggie pizza but i could customize from their available option. The boss is standing making the pizzas next to the entry, giving me great ambience of the open kitchen deli

Jordan C.

Small piZza joint attached to a good sized brewery good beer and and 5-8 pin-ball machines to keep nostalgia alive. The brewery also has a few board games and TV's to help pass the time if you're waiting for a pizza.I get the "Xxplosive " it's my go to pie when I'm craving pizza: Jalapeños, pepperonis and hot honey drizzled on top. It's savory and a little sweet everything you need with just the right kick of spice to tickle the taste buds.... try it and thank me later.Make sure you ask for a side of hot honey - a little goes a long way. Not the best picture but it will improve

Meena N.

Pizzas here are sooo good. We made our own. Sausage, pep and mushrooms on half and sausage, bacon and mushrooms on the other half. The pizzas are huge. Enough for 3 people with leftover. Loved the garlic rolls as well. The dipping marinara sauce is good. Dogs are welcome here. There's a whole area just for them. It's a little loud inside so there's an outside patio area that you can sit if you want it a little quieter. The wine was surprisingly good. I got the rose. Order at the counter for the pizza and they'll call you when it's ready. And then you order the drinks at the bar inside. Lady behind the counter was patient with us while we decided what to get.

Linda Burns

Pizza was great and garlic knots were to die for!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Garlic Balls

Retrozombie's Readings w/Tiffany

Deezknots were the best! We drove from East Los Angeles to Downey to Here just for the pizza and the bread knots called Deezknots. The Pizza is amazing! My entire family loves the pizza when I bring it home. The crust is thin. I suggest the pizza called, white girl, for diabetics, it did not raise my blood sugar as it does not have sauce and the bread is thin on the crust it has three cheeses it's so delicious and amazing. The regular pizza has a delicious sauce. Everything is hand tossed and baked fresh right there. It is definitely worth the drive as the pizza taste very fresh very amazing the crust is excellent to the bite. The staff is absolutely amazing and has wonderful customer service skills and personality! We will be back! I highly recommend this location if you're looking for a clean location that makes wonderful Pizza.Vegetarian options: The cheese pizza and the bread knots are amazing.Dietary restrictions: The pizza called, White girl, has a very thin crust with no red pizza sauce which that has sugar, it is just the thin crust, and three cheeses on it so it will not raise your blood sugar that much, also if you are watching your calorie intake this would probably be the best option. I am type 2 diabetic and the white girl Pizza I ate three slices it did not raise my blood sugar that much.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cheezus, Garlic Balls

Load More