I've eaten Mr. Pickle's Sandwich Shop twice. I almost always like to try a toasted meatball sandwich at any sandwich shop so I did that here as well. It's actually the first time I didn't enjoy it as much. There was just something about the meatballs and marinara sauce that I didn't love. I felt the meatballs weren't tasty enough and not juicy enough but I appreciated how many meatballs were put into it. The bread here is awesome though. It's crunchy on the outside, but still soft and moist. I like Mr. Pickle's bread texture-wise a lot more than the toasted bread at Columbo's Delicatessen (overly toasted; so it was hard on the outside and dry inside for both of the sandwiches I've tried there). The Maui toasted sandwich was pretty good though and the food is so fresh here. I do feel they care about quality while not being skimpy on ingredients. I also like buying a pint of their macaroni salad and potato salad. Honestly, the price is great and so is the flavor so I'm still giving this restaurant 4 stars. I'll definitely try more of their sandwiches.
Anaia M.
This must not be a part of the actual mr.pickles chain or something because i just went to a different one in redwood city that was sooo good so i saw this one closer to my home. Literally to get the same exact sandwich they had all different ingredients including the meat. Idk what kind of chicken that was if they shredded it there or what but it was so disgusting. And i think she overcharged me. Literally could not eat this sandwich not even one bite, it tasted like dog food the meat definitely looked like dog food. Will never go here again
Gary P.
Today I had the best sandwich from this place. I have been coming here for the past years and the sandwiches were just okay. But today was different. The turkey sandwich I had was amazing! Great amount of meat and condiments were on point. I don't if management change, but whatever they are doing now, keep it up! I will definitely recommend this place to everyone! Thank you to the friendly staff for the great customer service and food! Thank you, Gary
Junsheng X.
First time here and was pleasantly surprised. Small cozy sandwich place near the Daly City DMV with small store vibes. I got the meatball (#1), and was surprised at how many meatballs were put into it + how large the sandwich was! I couldn't finish it all in one meal, and it was the first time I had a sandwich in the area that I feel like was worth the price tag. Service was nice - the workers shouted my name very enthusiastically - love it!
Lawrence B.
The service was great, the Sandwitches were both wonderful and had lots of meat. Prices were good. I definitely will return for more!!!
Rick Faulconer
Nice sandwich.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Tony Soprano
Philip Davis
I have been coming here, or dashing from here, for over a year. There is NO other sandwich shop I would consider. Best food, Best people, Best place.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Bacon Sandwich What Soda and Chips
Evelyn Petersen
-2 stars because the bread was bad today, and my to go order was wrapped in only one paper and leaked through the bag.
Stop by for dinner. Ordered an Italian style sandwich. Plus, pop, chips, and a pickle. My review, nice fresh sandwich. Good cuts of meats. Pickle was fresh. Service was good. Ready in 5 minutes. It was huge sandwich, eat half. Took the other half for a later meal. Eat outside and enjoyed my meal and people watch. Everything was great. I recommend this place over any sandwich place. For the price hands down. Best sandwich in the South Bay.
asyaali
Never ordered from this location before but did for the first time on ubereats and put for a cold sandwich because of some of the fresher ingredients, but the sandwich was still warmed up, so by the time it was delivered it was a sloppy lukewarm mess, the vegetables in there were wilted, and the chicken I had added was gross, it tasted like some old leftover pieces they just threw in there. I used to order at the Livermore and Tracy locations and their sandwiches were so good every time, and they’d also throw in a free cookie every time. Never ordering from this lazy stingy location again?
Food: 1
Service: 1
Justin Antener
Online hours say 4pm, I walk in at 3:08pm and I was told they were closed. They were very polite, but I ask that you please update your website as we drove 20 minutes to get to your location. Thank
Service: 3
Diana Ibanez
Convenient for us because we where staying at the hotel next door.Chicken bacon sandwich was good and big portions but what I did not like is they sneak in a 10 percent tip fee with out even being an option or even notifying the customer
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 5
Service: 2
frank ibanez
Food is good for price but be careful if using a credit card to pay they sneak in a tip with out asking even on to go orders an all they did was just hand you the
I've eaten Mr. Pickle's Sandwich Shop twice. I almost always like to try a toasted meatball sandwich at any sandwich shop so I did that here as well. It's actually the first time I didn't enjoy it as much. There was just something about the meatballs and marinara sauce that I didn't love. I felt the meatballs weren't tasty enough and not juicy enough but I appreciated how many meatballs were put into it. The bread here is awesome though. It's crunchy on the outside, but still soft and moist. I like Mr. Pickle's bread texture-wise a lot more than the toasted bread at Columbo's Delicatessen (overly toasted; so it was hard on the outside and dry inside for both of the sandwiches I've tried there). The Maui toasted sandwich was pretty good though and the food is so fresh here. I do feel they care about quality while not being skimpy on ingredients. I also like buying a pint of their macaroni salad and potato salad. Honestly, the price is great and so is the flavor so I'm still giving this restaurant 4 stars. I'll definitely try more of their sandwiches.
This must not be a part of the actual mr.pickles chain or something because i just went to a different one in redwood city that was sooo good so i saw this one closer to my home. Literally to get the same exact sandwich they had all different ingredients including the meat. Idk what kind of chicken that was if they shredded it there or what but it was so disgusting. And i think she overcharged me. Literally could not eat this sandwich not even one bite, it tasted like dog food the meat definitely looked like dog food. Will never go here again
Today I had the best sandwich from this place. I have been coming here for the past years and the sandwiches were just okay. But today was different. The turkey sandwich I had was amazing! Great amount of meat and condiments were on point. I don't if management change, but whatever they are doing now, keep it up! I will definitely recommend this place to everyone! Thank you to the friendly staff for the great customer service and food! Thank you, Gary
First time here and was pleasantly surprised. Small cozy sandwich place near the Daly City DMV with small store vibes. I got the meatball (#1), and was surprised at how many meatballs were put into it + how large the sandwich was! I couldn't finish it all in one meal, and it was the first time I had a sandwich in the area that I feel like was worth the price tag. Service was nice - the workers shouted my name very enthusiastically - love it!
The service was great, the Sandwitches were both wonderful and had lots of meat. Prices were good. I definitely will return for more!!!
Nice sandwich.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Tony Soprano
I have been coming here, or dashing from here, for over a year. There is NO other sandwich shop I would consider. Best food, Best people, Best place.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Bacon Sandwich What Soda and Chips
-2 stars because the bread was bad today, and my to go order was wrapped in only one paper and leaked through the bag.
Food: 4
Great place for a tasty sandwich!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great chips selection tooParking: Street parking
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Top of the Hill Sandwich
Restaurantji Recommends
Stop by for dinner. Ordered an Italian style sandwich. Plus, pop, chips, and a pickle. My review, nice fresh sandwich. Good cuts of meats. Pickle was fresh. Service was good. Ready in 5 minutes. It was huge sandwich, eat half. Took the other half for a later meal. Eat outside and enjoyed my meal and people watch. Everything was great. I recommend this place over any sandwich place. For the price hands down. Best sandwich in the South Bay.
Never ordered from this location before but did for the first time on ubereats and put for a cold sandwich because of some of the fresher ingredients, but the sandwich was still warmed up, so by the time it was delivered it was a sloppy lukewarm mess, the vegetables in there were wilted, and the chicken I had added was gross, it tasted like some old leftover pieces they just threw in there. I used to order at the Livermore and Tracy locations and their sandwiches were so good every time, and they’d also throw in a free cookie every time. Never ordering from this lazy stingy location again?
Food: 1
Service: 1
Online hours say 4pm, I walk in at 3:08pm and I was told they were closed. They were very polite, but I ask that you please update your website as we drove 20 minutes to get to your location. Thank
Service: 3
Convenient for us because we where staying at the hotel next door.Chicken bacon sandwich was good and big portions but what I did not like is they sneak in a 10 percent tip fee with out even being an option or even notifying the customer
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 5
Service: 2
Food is good for price but be careful if using a credit card to pay they sneak in a tip with out asking even on to go orders an all they did was just hand you the
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 2