New York Bagels

Redwood Highway Frontage Rd #215, Mill Valley
(415) 381-3599

Recent Reviews

Scarlett H.

Love the place Comfortable , but small 4/5 table, one outdoor Breakfast/ Brunch within Strawberry shopping center in Millvalley. Don't know if anyone can ever beat the level of extraordinary restaurants located in and around NYC. Bagels were first created in lower East Side of Manhattan Cre Orthodox Jewish Hts. Of Brooklyn mell as w Bagels are traditional Jewish favorites here are Onion and the Everything bagel. staple of Brooklyn anytime but definitely for breakfast thru 2:30 is recreated here . Enjoy !

Barry X L.

the most real, authentic bagels in the bay area (but the bialy not real, tasty, but unauthentic). very good loX, too. B.XL.

Marci McCosh

Family stopped in while passing through. They were pretty crowded for 10:30am on a Friday, but service was fast. They have about 12+ flavors of bagels and about the same number of cream cheeses (also available low fat which is nice). They also have sandwich options, several serve yourself coffee options and bottled juices. I had a cheddar -jalapeño bagel with lox spread and it was the best bagel I've had in quite some time (including a recent trip to NYC). It's a tiny place, but I highly recommend.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Bagel

jocelyn jessica jacinto

I like Noah's 's bagel better but it was a good place yltoo!.. Not as many bagles but sufficient..

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Bagel

Malori Lynne

We ordered bagels to-go here, which I will say, they were very speedy. It is a small shop and was very busy so I had high hopes for the bagel. Unfortunately, the bagels were very unexciting. The jalapeño cheddar was not at all spicy or cheesy. And the cream cheese was extremely watered down and had a funky yogurt taste. Satisfy your bagel cravings elsewhere.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Bagel with Plain Cream Cheese

Kimberly

Bought half dozen bagels and cream cheese. Then some $2.50 charge was added they wouldn't explain and wouldn't give receipt.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 3

Service: 5

Epsilon 2.

Best bagel sandwich I've ever had, was very delicious, perfectly fresh and creamy and was very well sauced, could eat 3 of their empire bagels.

chumblespuzz

Three words: Best. Fresh. Bagels. !

T. F.

Their bagels are super good and so are their sandwiches. My favorite of each are the three cheese bagel, the cinnamon sugar bagel, and the farmhouse sandwich. I tend to stock up so I love that I can bulk buy and then pop 'em in my freezer to eat over the next little bit.

Alexa M.

Super expensive $5 for a puffy bagel. $7.50 with cream cheese, ridiculous for mediocre quality

Andrea M.

I love New York Bagels. They've been a Marin staple ever since I can remember. Lynn runs a fantastic business and their bagels are the best in Marin. They offer great customer service as Lynn is familiar with my order and knows exactly what I want. I highly recommend them.

Hossein Sean Sohaei

Good fresh bagels and coffee

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Bagel with Plain Cream Cheese

Alex A.

Though the wait was long, the bagels were fluffy and delicious. The bacon egg and cheese sandwiches looked like they were just reheated egg, which is why I ordered a bagel with cream cheese, which was fantastic! They had fun cream cheese flavors, like strawberry and maple walnut which were very sweet.

Kyle Hansen

Great selection of bagels. Recommend the salt and strawberry cream cheese

Kedar Grama

Excellent bagels and spreads. We buy their bagels and spread(veggie and vegan are our favourites) here regularly. Their bagel sandwiches are also really good and inexpensive for their quality.

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Breakfast Veggie Wrap, Breakfast Veggie Bagel, Lox Sandwich

Load More