Cosentino's Pizza

Pizza was great, would highly recommend. High quality ingredients, everything is fresh and the service is absolutely amazing! The sandwich is really well priced and you get a lot of food. The food is just amazing.

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

Absolutely delicious!
We dined in and had an outstanding experience at Pizza Castello. The food was fresh, flavorful, and generously portioned. The cheesy meatball sandwich was perfectly toasted and loaded with melted cheese and herbs—comfort food at its best. We also tried a few dessert pizzas, and they were truly unique. The Nutella and pistachio combinations were indulgent without being overly sweet, and the crust was light yet crisp.

The service was friendly and efficient, and the casual atmosphere made it a relaxing place to enjoy a meal. It’s clear that attention to detail goes into every dish, from preparation to presentation.

We’ll definitely be back. Highly recommended!!!

Excellent pizza and service. Crispy crust. Fresh toppings.

Pizza Costello is an absolute jewel. I tried it for the first time today, and it completely blew me away. If you love pizza, this place needs to be on your list — no question. You will not be disappointed.

The pizza is perfectly balanced: the crust is crisp yet light, the sauce is fresh and flavorful without overpowering, and the quality of the ingredients shines through in every bite. It’s clear that real care and craftsmanship go into what they serve.

Speaking as someone who has traveled all over the world and lived on the East Coast — where great pizza is a serious thing — I can confidently say Pizza Costello is a must-try. This place delivers on every level.
Can’t wait to come back.

Highly recommend!

We didn’t go in we ordered this Maui pizza for delivery while staying at the beach and it was so bad we couldn’t eat it and I hate leaving bad reviews but it was so soggy in the middle it just fell apart the kids wouldn’t even eat the plain cheese one we got separate for them

Great food great services one of the most authentic pizza in town👌👌👌

Crust had a lot of flower on it. Not enough red sauce. Very bland pizza.

Wow this was a definite surprise to have such an amazing pizza here. Went for a quick lunch and I was truly impressed.

Unbelievable pizza and the owner is the kind of guy u want to have a beer with. Everything was super clean and this place has a great vibe. Highly recommend

Clean!!!!! Owner kept his restaurant very clean its a one man shop so let him cook!!! I loved the Hawaiian I received from him today and the wings were ginormous!!!! Very great experience would recommend this place !!!

being a pizza fanatic this place used to be one of the best if not the best around. The original owner re tired and sold the place. He showed the new owner how to make his pizza but the new guy didn't want to make his pizza the same. I was so bummed I returned the pizza from the new owner. Not even close

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 5

Always great pizza!
We tried the dessert pizza so delicious!!
Very friendly service!! This place is a treasure!!

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Maui Hawaiian Pizza 18

Very good sandwiches but I last went here when it was Big O To

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Please bring back Big-O-to-Go pizza!! The restaurant you acquired has a legendary following among those who grew up in Mission Viejo, with Big-O-to-Go being a beloved staple. The crust on their pizza was uniquely special with a crunch like no other pizza. Unfortunately your current pizza crust is just like every other pizza restaurant. If you have the old recipe please let me know as I would happily pay for it. In closing if you would like to double your revenue, consider bringing back the old recipes. To help here is how you marketvit. Big O is making a triumphant return, offering an expanded but complimentary experience for our loyal customers. The iconic crunchy crust that Mission Viejo has adored for over 40 years is back and better than ever. The oc register LA times among others will help you.

Food: 2

Service: 3

Where have all the good quality pizza places gone? We drove here from LN and a large Hawaiian pizza felt like an empty pizza box. It was so thin. Me and my hubs will likely have to get more food. For almost $30? This should be fraud.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 4